Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 August 2008

Against the odds, Motorola gains handset chief and Q2 profit

Motorola has pulled off a startling coup, hiring a top flight CEO for its handset division, which is to be spun off, possibly now before year end. It has appointed Sanjay Jha, highly respected and impactful COO at Qualcomm, in a hire that seems beyond the ailing company’s wildest dreams. Since it bowed to pressure from activist investors, and market freefall, and announced earlier this year that it would separate off the devices unit ‘ the largest of its three businesses, but lossmaking and in decline ‘ one of the major risk factors has been the problem of attracting someone to head up the company. Failure to find a chief of sufficient calibre to take on the mammoth task would kill confidence in the unit once spun off, but what top ranking executive would accept the potentially poison chalice?

The answer is Jha, who has worked closely with Qualcomm CEO Paul Jacobs in his COO role to start a process of transformation at the leading mobile chip designer (see separate item). He is a far stronger leader than Motorola could have banked on attracting ‘ until recently it had seemed horribly possible that the unit would have to put up with a sub-standard candidate, possibly internal; be flogged off in a non-strategic acquisition, like that proposed by Indian electronics company Videocon; or even that the break-up plan would be abandoned altogether (which would not necessarily be a bad thing for the long term future of Motorola group)..

None of these doom scenarios will now occur ‘ Jha will be strong enough to instil a level of confidence in the spin-off plan, enough to ensure it happens at least (and current CEO Greg Brown will certainly not want to prolong the current situation where he shares co-CEO duties with his new recruit, who would threaten quickly to outshine him). The new appointee has already made it clear that he will stay on with the devices company for the long haul after its separation, which for the first time adds real credibility to Motorola’s claims that it has no wish to sell the division.

Of course, the company is far more than the man. So, while Jha’s departure will be a blow to Qualcomm, the well run chip company, on a high after its d’tente with Nokia, will recover well, and could well gain a closer relationship with Motorola to add to its new friendship with Nokia and its existing strong bonds with Samsung and LG (Motorola has a somewhat fragile 3G chip deal with Qualcomm which the silicon giant will now hope to solidify, especially as one of Jha’s first stated objectives is to continue and accelerate the process of diversifying Motorola’s chip supply chain, several years after it spun off its own chip division, now Freescale).

Conversely, Jha’s strengths, and the good team he will hopefully put around him, will not be enough on their own to change the fortunes of Motorola’s devices business, which has plummeted from the heady days of the RAZR’s success to its current depression in two short years (though many underlying problems, especially on the logistical front, have been there far longer and to some extent were masked by the RAZR boom). There is a long way to go for the company to regain its number two position from Samsung ‘ or indeed, stop itself being overtaken by LG or even Sony Ericsson ‘ and to get itself back into profit after a disastrously over-aggressive move into ultra-low cost markets under former CEO Ed Zander, and a general loss of brand appeal, especially in markets like India and Europe where Nokia is growing more and more dominant.

Strong management; new designs and branding; a software strategy; a wider range of handset models with better smartphone offerings in order to balance margins better; a marketing rethink; an expansion into non-handset devices (something Jha spearheaded at Qualcomm); critically, an overhaul of the supply chain and logistical efficiencies to improve the cost base and inch closer to Nokia in this area where the Finn, emulated by Apple, is supremely strong ‘ all these need to be addressed urgently, and this will be without the cross-selling and brand support and margins/revenue buffer provided by the other, more profitable, Motorola units.

What will Jha bring? He has no CEO experience, though he worked as a very close team with Qualcomm’s Jacobs, and is not a turnaround expert, having spent his time in senior positions at Qualcomm, which has been beleaguered in legal terms but never in serious business trouble. And logistics is not his expertise, though he could hire someone (and needs to do that urgently) to mastermind a new approach here.

But what he does offer is compelling. First, he is well respected and has a fairly unblemished COO record, and yet has been ready to take the Motorola job, which in itself throws a more positive light on the handset spin-off plan and instils a jolt of confidence that has been sadly lacking. He is an engineer who will understand and sympathize with the deep engineering culture of Motorola, but has extended his expertise sufficiently into executive roles, and into marketing and software, not to fall victim to the Motorola disease of believing that good engineering makes strong performance in management, marketing and logistics unnecessary. Most importantly, his later years at Qualcomm demonstrated his ability to be a visionary – seeing clearly how markets would change and the sometimes radical changes that the company would need to take to take advantage; and more importantly still, able to communicate the vision and inspire the company to support it. Many of the important recent changes of strategy at Qualcomm ‘ the formulation of an advanced software and services platform, the expansion into computing and consumer electronics, the slow change of approach to IPR and market alliances ‘ have been guided and articulated by Jha. Motorola’s starting point and necessary changes will be different, but Jha gets the mobile internet and convergence markets and what they require in product terms, and so will be able to think out of the box in terms of coming up with something his new company has not had since the RAZR’s heyday on the handset side, a real vision.

Jha is making it clear that we will not see turnaround plans outlined hastily. He told the news agency Reuters that he would conduct at least a 90-day review before making major changes. “I don’t know that I have a magic plan today. It will take me about 90 days to… figure out what is the right way to move this business to the next level.” He did hint, however, that the first priorities, apart from reviewing chip relationships, would be to improve Motorola’s software platform, user interface and form factor design ‘ areas where it has lagged far behind the rest of the cellphone top five and also new challengers like Apple.

The other nagging question is ‘ why does Jha want this job? A silicon engineer to his marrow, with strong prospects of inheriting the throne at a far stronger company than Motorola or being offered a CEOship in another chip major, the risks of taking on this role and seeing the devices unit fail anyway are high, leaving him in the wilderness. His relationship with Qualcomm clearly remains cordial and probably will be commercial, and his close ties with US operators at that company make him a popular choice with Verizon and others, which are keen to see Motorola strengthened to maintain competition among their handset suppliers, and a check on the power of Nokia, a company with which they have problems dealing. All this means he will, at least in the honeymoon period, have significant support from the Motorola ecosystem and wider markets. But he has still taken on a hugely difficult task with no assurances of success.

The new co-CEO at least joins at a time when Motorola is announcing some rare good news, although the excitement in the US financial community about a minor group profit and slightly better than expected handset sales in the last quarter does not indicate signs of a real turnaround yet, but rather the desperate desire of Wall Street to see the US’ only tier one phonemaker survive.

After a string of appalling quarters, it was indeed easy to read too much into an unexpected brighter one. Most importantly, handset sales were 28.1m units, better than the 26m or so expected by analysts, and keeping Motorola safe, for now at least, from losing its number three position in the sector. Motorola as a whole recorded revenues of $8.1bn in its second quarter with a small profit of $4m, though the handset division still made a loss of $300m. Cost cutting at the devices unit and very strong performance by all the non-handset business were responsible for the brighter quarter, though this reflected better on the remaining value in the other units ‘ which could themselves be separated and sold off ‘ than on a turnaround in handsets.

Motorola still has over $3.6bn in cash and total liquid assets of over $7.8bn, but investors are worried that even this amount of money will not be enough to turn around the business without a partner, or a buyer for some or all of the units. The markets greeted the results, and Jha’s arrival, positively overall. ‘We believe Mr Jha’s strong execution history at Qualcomm will be viewed favorably,” said Maynard Um, an analyst at UBS. “Mr Jha has a proven operating execution history and see this as a positive for Motorola.” His ability to innovate was also commented upon by financial analysts, though there is a danger of over-expectation, given that handset design cycles are long and the company will need 18 months or so to refresh its portfolio.

Brown said last week: “Mobile Devices does need continued improvement in financial performance, as well as a better level of predictability, and that improvement is crucial to a successful separation.’ He warned that the division’s market share was likely to fall again in the third quarter.

China Mobile deal:

Motorola has won a $431m contract for GSM gear with China Mobile, which is a boost to the vendor’s claims that its 2G business remains robust, despite its virtual exit from W-CDMA and the squeeze on pricing in GSM. Operators in developing markets are investing huge sums in GSM expansion and this new deal will see Motorola gear deployed across 16 provinces and cities. About half the revenue from the deal was recognized in Motorola’s first half of 2008. It follows contracts worth $394m with the largest operator by customer numbers last year.

The vendor said it aims to strengthen and deepen its cooperation with China Mobile after the restructuring of China’s telecoms industry, which has been going on most of this year. Ericsson and Alcatel-Lucent have both won billion dollar contracts with China Mobile this year also and, unlike Motorola, are well positioned also to participate in the operator’s upcoming roll-out of TD-SCDMA 3G networks.