The past few weeks have been a rollercoaster for Qualcomm. First it abruptly settled its licensing and patents battle with Nokia, potentially setting the stage for the Finnish leader to become a customer and development partner. The relief among the senior executives of the chip designer was palpable as they held their annual analyst conference just a week after the settlement, and the powerful double-act that has been the public face of Qualcomm through its recent transitions ‘ CEO Paul Jacobs and COO Sanjay Jha ‘ looked set to lead the company into the mobile broadband era in a position of new strength and industry acceptability. Then, just days later, it was announced that Jha was leaving to become co-CEO of Motorola and head up the separation of the handsets business.
This move may well be a strong boost for Motorola and a poison chalice for Jha (see separate item), but it must also be something of a blow for Qualcomm. Jha has been one of the architects of a new Qualcomm that is adapting rapidly to the prospect of a post-CDMA world, and a market where a chip designer needs to understand and drive software, services and operator models as well as silicon. He has helped soften the edges of Qualcomm’s once abrasive image and carries huge respect with his teams and his markets as a visionary and an engineer. Perhaps his most important legacy at Qualcomm will be to have single-mindedly accelerated the company’s move towards ‘integration, integration and more integration’ on the phone chips, as one lieutenant described it, and to start to extend its reach into the PC and consumer electronics fields. And in his new role at Motorola, he may continue to be valuable to his old company, building on relatively new and sometimes shaky chip purchasing relationships between the two, and bringing a deep understanding of the Qualcomm technologies and roadmap to the US phonemaker.
Most significantly, the two major news headlines for Qualcomm this summer combine to highlight that the ‘new Qualcomm’ is only just emerging. It may have adapted its strategies and polished up its image in recent years, but now it is poised, as Jacobs put it, to take up a new position of influence, as ‘the bridge builder between the internet/software business and the wireless operators as the mobile internet becomes real’. This will mean a heightened focus on software and services, and therefore new standards participation and IPR approaches. It is, to some extent, enabled by the truce with Nokia ‘ ‘the Nokia litigation was a big drag on our potential to take up that role’, said Jacobs. And it is certainly epitomized by the change of COO, with Jha, a chip engineer to his core, giving way to Len Lauer, a non-engineer with a lifetime career with telecoms operators, and a focus on services more than silicon.
So while the executives crowed about Nokia ‘endorsing Qualcomm’s IPR business model’, the real issue was that the chip giant is now freer to pursue new business models, some of them, potentially, in partnership with the world’s leading phonemaker. Jha was well aware that, while Qualcomm can rely on its patent hoard for decent earnings and revenue for many years to come ‘ even as it adapts its precise rates and structures along with the shift to OFDMA and emerging markets – it will need to revise its IPR systems as it moves into CE and computing markets, where expectations are different and Qualcomm is a newcomer. But the change goes far deeper than new licensing deals and even chips for new sectors ‘ Lauer’s primary responsibility is now to turn Qualcomm into a services and software giant as well as a chip leader.
This is a transformation Nokia is also attempting, though in services its focus is on consumer web offerings via the Ovi portal, whether delivered directly or in alliance with operators. Qualcomm, by contrast, is looking to be the operator’s friend, rather than provoke any of the conflicts of interest that direct to consumer web services imply. Its goal is to build on its low profile but long established services experience to provide a wide range of managed, white label back end frameworks that enable operators ‘ traditional and new-style ‘ to deliver differentiated services in areas like mobile banking or asset management. This achieves three objectives – driving uptake of advanced devices and mobile web functions, and so stimulating Qualcomm’s core business; generating a new revenue stream that Lauer sees as ‘off-Broadway’ for the next two years, but then emerging to deliver sales and margins that will get noticed by shareholders; and enhancing Qualcomm’s influence over, and close working relationship with, large operators (the company has always worked more directly and closely with operators than most chipmakers would expect to do).
Some key services areas that Lauer wants to attack are mobile banking, in which it purchased operator service enabler Firethorn last year; mobile TV, the most high profile example because of MediaFLO; asset tracking and logistics, a business activity already established through the Omnitracs arm; health and medical monitoring, and ‘body area networks’, a market where Qualcomm already has a venture with CardioNet; and other less developed areas where the chip giant can manage a wireless and web based service on behalf of a carrier. Lauer also sees huge potential for the expansion of the Amazon Kindle model, where the user purchases a device in order to receive a specific wireless service or application, with the fee that goes to the wireless operator being entirely invisible to the consumer (the Kindle device is Qualcomm-based and runs on the Sprint network).
The other area where the new Qualcomm will step up its activities will be in the handset software that rides on top of its chips for mobile products, whether smartphones, laptops with embedded 3G, consumer electronics products based on the Snapdragon platform, or the ‘pocketable devices’ (what others call ultramobile PCs or mobile internet devices). It has been increasing its software activities for some years, mainly with offshoots of the Brew content platform, such as the UIone user interface system and the new Plaza widgets offering. Brew has made little headway outside CDMA, but now Qualcomm seeks to open it up, and bring many of its functions and differentiators into the standards world, as well as stamping its mark on the major evolving mobile software architectures of the new generation.
Until now, the situation with Nokia has kept Qualcomm at arm’s length from Symbian, though that could change now, and the potential is high for the two companies to define a new breed of Symbian reference platforms drawing on the chip company’s excellence in advanced integration and multimedia. The company is also ‘keeping an eye’ on the LiMo Foundation, but to date its highest profile developments have been for the other major Linux contender, Google Android, and Windows Mobile.
Jha generated the most widely read headlines of the analyst summit when he hinted that Qualcomm and Android could combine to create the first strong competitor to Apple’s iPhone. While complimenting the product’s appearance and engineering, he said: ‘There are opportunities to do some things better’ and, despite recent stalling of Android’s progress amid developer frustration, Jha is confident that there will be large numbers of phones based on the Google software and Qualcomm chips, from 2009. Snapdragon would support several advances over the iPhone, such as a 1GHz processor, 8-megapixel camera and high definition video camera. However, there are no official plans to support Android on Snapdragon, and to date Windows has probably been a more concrete focus. And now, the new Nokia alliance may shift Qualcomm’s software priorities somewhat, especially as it chases greater influence in Europe ‘ just as Nokia will see its ‘new BFF’ as a possible help in attacking its weakest market, north America.