Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 May 2006

Aloha and SeS provide third mobile television option for US carriers

The satellite industry has been paying close attention to broadband wireless and the potential to partner with radio spectrum owners to deliver a mobile triple play. However, the first to move is not Rupert Murdoch’s DirectTV or rival Echostar, but satellite content and services provider SeS Global, which is partnering with the largest current holder of 700MHz spectrum in the US, Aloha Partners, to support a move into the wireless sector. The duo, under the name Hiwire, is introducing a third option to the increasingly crowded US mobile television market, planning a national network that, like Qualcomm’s MediaFLO and Crown Castle’s Modeo, will be marketed to cellular and other operators as a means to deliver mobile broadcast services.

Aloha Partners was set up, with the backing of several investors with backgrounds in telecoms infrastructure, to acquire the initial tranche of 700MHz spectrum auctioned in the US. It gained 12MHz of spectrum, double the amount bought by the other auction winner, Qualcomm. Further 700MHz allocations will be made as the current analog television occupants vacate the band, with the sale likely to take place next year. This will be hotly contested by backers of WiMAX and other broadband wireless technologies, since the propagation qualities of 700MHz enable it to support high spectral efficiency and base station range. Modeo, which is building a national mobile TV network using the DVB-H standard and backed by Nokia, has the somewhat less economically attractive 1.6GHz band to work with.

Interestingly, Aloha originally trialled the Flarion Flash-OFDM technology, now owned by Qualcomm, in its 700MHz spectrum, but its current commercial trials are using DV-H. Of the three companies looking to underpin the mobile carriers’ push into mobile broadcasting, Qualcomm’s MediaFlo subsidiary, which is using the company’s own OFDM-based FLO platform, is the only one to have a tier one customer signed up ‘ Verizon Wireless. The other major CDMA-based cellco, Sprint Nextel, plans to make do with using its own 3G spectrum for television services until it rolls out its planned 2.5GHz broadband wireless system, at which point it will create its own television network, possibly using the emerging TVtd technology from IPWireless. Cingular, the largest W-CDMA user, is expected to sign up with Modeo, because DVB-H is backed by the GSM/W-CDMA community. However, it could opt for Hiwire’s implementation of the same standard ‘ weighing the risk of opting for a start-up with no major industry supporters, and which is lagging Modeo in build-out schedule; against the attractions of the 700MHz band and the control that working with a small player can bring to the carrier (compare Sprint’s dalliance with the small IPWireless).

If Cingular does stick with Modeo, that would leave Hiwire with only T-Mobile or another CDMA player ‘ and therefore logical Qualcomm prey ‘ Alltel. However, it could also ‘ especially given the SES involvement – focus more heavily on wireline and satellite operators looking to add mobility to their mix.

Aloha’s 12MHz of spectrum (TV channels 54 and 59) covers 60% of the US, including holdings in the top 10 markets and with coverage of 84%, on average, of the population of the top 40 markets. Hiwire expects to spend $500m to roll out services in the top 150 markets, according to president Scott Wills, about the same budget claimed by Modeo, though less than Qualcomm’s proclaimed $800m. Aloha says its system will use fewer transmitters than those of its rivals, and will distribute up to 40 high resolution video channels to handsets. The efficiency of the 700MHz spectrum should enable it to achieve greater coverage and broadcast capacity for the same financial outlay as Modeo, Aloha claims. The company has so far spent $150m on spectrum.

Aloha says that significant portions of its two channels of spectrum ‘ covering 56m points of presence – are already available for use, three years in advance of the deadline for analog broadcasters to vacate 700MHz. This is mainly because, with two channels held, it is easier to free up at least one in each market.

The main role of SeS Americom ‘ the US subsidiary of Luxembourg-based SES Global ‘ will be to deliver content. Its chief current business is selling content to cable operators, but it has been looking to enter the wireless space.

“We have all of these signals in IP format ready for distribution. We have already made the investment and we have the relationship with the programmers,” said Bryan McGuirk, president of media solutions for SeS Americom. “We have deals with a number of wireline companies and now we are moving to the wireless.” SeS is the largest international commercial satellite operator by revenue and by number of satellites, but believes its long term growth requires expanding beyond the supply of wholesale space capacity to traditional broadcasters. Instead, it believes it can take a share of the emerging mobile TV segment, by using its satellites to transmit music and television to wireless systems on the ground.

Mediaset

In Europe, the battle is also underway to gain tier one cellco support for mobile TV networks. While prime minister Silvio Berlusconi fights to retain a foot in the running of Italy after narrowly losing elections there, his Mediaset media business empire is fighting equally hard to control mobile TV in the region.

Mediaset says that it has signed upVodafone to use its DVB-H mobile TV broadcasting network for the next five years. But we don’t think the deal is quite what it seems. Last year Mediaset said it had also signed up 3 Italia in a similar deal, but this fell through in February when the Hutchison Whampoa-owned cellco said instead that it would launch a mobile TV service at the beginning of June set to coincide with the launch of the soccer World Cup using spectrum it acquired when it bought Italian TV’s Channel 7, which had its own national digital TV license with spectrum for its own DVB-H mobile TV service.

Potentially a Vodafone deal is a far more lucrative one for Mediaset. It has already signed up Telecom Italia Mobile (TIM), which controls over 40% of the Italian market, and with the extra 33% to which Vodafone would give Mediaset access, that would leave it controlling a dominant route to market.

However 3 Italia has mobile TV rights for all the world cup soccer games, which is part of a $60m spend this year on content, and it will put it out at less than one euro a day. Most European DVB-H mobile datacasting services are being priced at about $12 a month, so the soccer must come at a huge premium.

Of course if 3 Italia has a huge success, it will owe much of the its content revenues to the dominant content providers, and Mediaset is one such supplier.

But Vodafone’s position is far from clear. In January Mediaset said that Vodafone was in discussions to join its consortium, then in February at 3GSM Vodafone came out and it said it was working with broadcaster RAI in Italy to experiment with DVB-H services. Some of the experiments were carried out at the Winter Olympic games.

RAI and Vodafone Italia said that in the second phase, they will shift the trial focus to content and media formats and then genuine customers will be brought into the trials process to explore new types of services and customer reaction to them. Instead it now appears that Vodafone has thrown in its lot with Mediaset after all.

Last year Vodafone cut a deal with satellite TV operators Sky, to launch 19 television channels for 3G phones in the UK running over the Vodafone 3G network rather than using a dedicated mobile broadcasting network and said it would also launch the same service in Germany, Greece, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal and Spain and with three associate networks in Belgium, France and Switzerland and one partner network in Austria. So it will at least be offering two separate TV products in Italy, one in cellular and another in DVB-H.

700MHz proposals

The swathe of 700MHz spectrum that remains unauctioned in the US has attracted interest from many quarters ‘ not just traditional wireless operators but supporters of rural and municipal access zones, technology suppliers like Intel and would-be alternative service providers like Google. While these mull their possible moves, the type of companies that win licenses will decide whether 700MHz fulfils the role largely envisaged by the regulator, the FCC, of extending broadband wireless access to underserved rural areas, or is used mainly to deliver new multimedia services, such as TV, to boost the margins of pressurized carriers. The picture is further complicated by debates over how much (if any) of the band should be left license-exempt to encourage new competition and low cost services; and what role it should play in the future US public safety plan.

Already, 24MHz of the band is set aside for public safety, but some campaigners believe this will be inadequate. Last week, Cyren Call Communications, a new company led by former Nextel executive Morgan O’Brien, petitioned the FCC to initiate a rule to reserve an additional 30MHz of the band to create a nationwide broadband public safety network that would provide interoperability for first response agencies around the country ‘ lack of which is seen as a major weakness in the US ability to respond to major emergencies. Cyren Call wants a public-private partnership with commercial operators that would fund network infrastructure deployment in exchange for leveraging the 700MHz band for wireless business opportunities. First responders and others would have first access to the 30MHz block during emergencies, but would otherwise use a small part of network capacity to satisfy daily public safety requirements. The FCC would oversee a single licensee, the Public Safety Broadband Trust, with the authority to lease capacity to companies that are helping to construct the national broadband public safety system.

The CTIA, the body that represents cellular carriers in the US, unsurprisingly criticized the plan.

“CTIA has long advocated on behalf of – and continues to support – an interoperable communications system for public safety,” said CTIA president Steve Largent in a statement. “That is why CTIA strongly supported the Digital Television Transition legislation signed by the President in March, which allocated 24MHz of spectrum in the 700MHz band to pave the way for a robust interoperable public safety communications system. CTIA believes this new proposal will have the unintended consequences of halting deployment of this much needed communications system.”