Despite its strengths in enterprise IP systems, Cisco has shown faltering progress in the mobile side of the game. Most recently, it has cancelled its joint venture with Motorola to focus on fixed/mobile convergence in large companies ‘ but only to replace it with a more ambitious alliance with Nokia, the supplier that has been most aggressive about turning the handset into the ‘only device the enterprise needs’.
The switch of allegiance makes sense for Cisco, as well as bolstering Nokia, which has been pursuing big corporate technology hitters to boost its credibility in this sector. Nokia has understood fixed/mobile convergence (FMC) far earlier and better than most other players, and this is the main focus of its fledgling enterprise unit. Its ambition is to make the smartphone ‘ in whatever incarnations it may take over the coming years ‘ the dominant device for business users, replacing the wireline phone, the PDA and eventually the laptop, and so claiming the position in the mobile access strategy currently occupied by the Windows notebook.
The new Cisco-Nokia project will enable calls to be routed to Nokia phones ‘ initially the Series 6000 range ‘ via the office PBX, over a WLan or cellular connection. Unlike the FMC products that European cellcos plan to push to home markets, which use the UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access) mechanism to hand off between networks, this approach will rest on the SIP standard, which significantly consolidated its claim to be the undisputed standard underlying all-IP evolution when Cisco gave it full support at the start of the year. Although UMA may eventually be integrated with IP systems based on SIP, such as the IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS), it currently remains mainly of interest to the cellular operators as they try to challenge for fixed line revenues, while enterprises and wireline operators are more likely to favor SIP (despite the irony of non-wireless telco British Telecom being the first commercial UMA operator).
With three Cisco business units reportedly working on the Nokia venture ‘ the wireless, carrier services and Core Manager/VoIP divisions ‘ it is likely to attain high profile over the coming year, although so far all that has emerged is an agreement for Nokia to support Cisco extensions in VoIP products.
This in itself was interesting and indicative of the Cisco approach, however. The company introduced its CCX (Cisco Compatible Extensions) programme in February 2004, providing a set of specifications that, when supported, guarantee a device’s compatibility with Cisco WLans and with certain security technologies. While ostensibly offered to reduce an enterprise’s risk when selecting WLan products, and ensure interoperability of their users’ devices, CCX has been widely criticized for seeking to leverage Cisco’s market weight to set de facto standards and exclude smaller players. Now Cisco is extending the extensions to wireless VoIP and has enlisted a powerful combination of Nokia, RIM and its most natural ally, Intel.
Like Cisco’s original CCX, introduced in February 2004, the updates will be implemented at the system level on client devices and chipsets, promising power saving capabilities, better roaming, and improved call prioritization, as well as improvements to sound quality thanks to reduced ‘packet jitter’. Instead of clusters of calls around a single access point, the new CCX will set a pre-set number of calls per access point and enforce that, so there’s no risk to the quality of the calls already in session. There will also be built-in load-balancing, providing the option of handing off a call from one overloaded AP to another. CCX will offer some tricks to improve battery life of mobile devices, as well as analyzing voice attributes like delay and jitter.
Cisco is taking its usual stand of claiming that enterprise needs move ahead of standards committees and therefore it needs to fill gaps through its own technologies ‘ opening these up so they can be supported across the industry. Cisco has taken a similar approach in many areas of wireless, such as creating its own EAP (Extensible Authentication Protocol) variant for security, and opening this up to third parties, rather than backing the vanilla standard EAPs.
Cisco only licenses CCX out to makers of client devices, so only its own access points and switches contain it (even home WLan gear from its subsidiary Linksys does not come with CCX).
Intel builds CCX into all Centrino chipset and was the first to support version 4.0 last year, while RIM is expected to create a Wi-Fi enabled BlackBerry PDA with CCX support.
So Cisco claims the enhancements offered in the new CCX are critical to get voice over WLan adopted by large enterprises, whose needs will not be satisfied with the IEEE extensions, notably 802.11e, on their own ‘ a position also supported by smaller vendors like Meru, though they have less market power to turn their view into revenues.
Ben Gibson, Cisco’s director of wireless and mobility marketing, told an interview: “The key to successful voice deployment is QOS end-to-end’, and also claims to address the other critical issue for voice, latency.
Whatever the technical arguments, Cisco is clearly seeking to extend its dominance of the wireline enterprise VoIP sector to wireless. This is not by breaking with standards ‘ its products still support 802.11 specifications, and will work with any Wi-Fi devices, but it claims CCX just adds further functionality on top. Rather, it is by making its offering appear safe, easy to deploy and functional for enterprise buyers, and then luring the most influential makers of Wi-Fi devices and chips to its cause with the attraction of its enterprise base.
The Motorola-Cisco deal
Last July, Motorola and Cisco announced plans to deliver “a seamless enterprise mobility solution that will include wireless Lan IP telephony and cellular phone technologies’, allowing mobile handsets to roam between the different networks. This was supposed to build on work already done by Motorola, IP telephony specialist Avaya and WLan supplier Proxim on enterprise convergence products. This had resulted in the Motorola CN620 WLan/VoIP device, a dual-mode WLAN/GSM phone that works with a centralized Wi-Fi controller and lightweight access points.
Motorola’s contribution was to be an adaptation of the CN620, the CN622, adapted to work with the Cisco wireless VoIP technology, as well as Motorola’s Wireless Services Manager, which manages hand-off and ports advanced VoIP features to the cellular network. Cisco was to provide its CallManager IP PBX and the Wi-Fi access points. Unlike the Avaya/Proxim solution, which was specific to 802.11a in 5GHz, the Cisco version was to work with 801.11a or 2.4GHz 802.11g, and be based on SIP.
Now Motorola has confirmed that the Cisco deal has been cancelled, blaming carrier uncertainty. It said the development process was so long that the market had moved on, and the company had decided to skip launching a second generation CN620 with Cisco, in order to move directly ‘ and alone ‘ into full unified communications. With Ericsson and others storming into this space (see separate item), this could prove a good decision, but the loss of Cisco as a partner is less encouraging for Motorola, which does not count the large enterprise as its natural heartland outside the handset world. While its mobile phones are widely used in the large companies, and it has added business focused features such as Wi-Fi support and push email at a similar rate to Nokia, the Finnish supplier has recognized more clearly that in order to take a place high up the enterprise value chain, it needs to offer full mobility systems, including middleware and development tools, and to partner with the strategic suppliers on the server and networking sides, such as IBM and Cisco.
“This was an industry first, and the initial device didn’t include features that were important to cellular carriers only,” said Motorola. “For the next round, we’ll be much more tightly integrated with them. We were really focused on enterprise needs with the first product. We focused on enterprise needs, figuring that the carriers would say that was great… Not so much.” Motorola is likely now to focus more heavily on UMA, of which it is a major supporter, and cellco requirements, rather than SIP, although its promised unified communications devices will support Cisco as well as other vendors’ PBXs.
It is not clear what will happen to the Cingular Wireless trial of the CN620, nor the SCCAN (Seamless Converged Communication Across Networks) Forum, the industry group that Motorola set up last summer to put the Avaya/Proxim work into the standards process and to offer interfaces openly, in order to boost uptake and try to create a de facto standard for enterprise VoWLan/cellular convergence.
SCCAN was joined last May by three Wi-Fi switchmakers that had been particularly interested in voice and the hand-off and quality of service issues associated with it. These were Chantry Networks, now owned by Siemens, Meru Networks, which claims to offer superior QoS to the Wi-Fi standard extension, 802.11e, and Colubris, which also has a separate alliance with Avaya. No new members have been added since the initial formation of the group.