The mobile operator landscape is being thrown up in the air again in the Americas ‘ not just in the USA this time, but also south of the border, as Carlos Slim’s America Movil empire is broken up to avoid even worse changes imposed by the regulator. The US antitrust regulator is likely to be taking a hard line too if, as expected, it soon adds a Sprint/T-Mobile merger proposal to its current list of reviews, along with AT&T/DirecTV and Comcast/Time Warner Cable.
The long ‘will they won’t they’ saga of Sprint and T-Mobile USA may be nearing a conclusion, with the US’s third and fourth cellcos said to have hammered out a merger agreement ‘ though one which is sure to face a lengthy and difficult review process.
The major owners of the two operators ‘ Sprint’s parent Softbank of Japan and T-Mobile’s Deutsche Telekom ‘ have reached a ‘basic agreement’ to merge, according to Japan’s Nikkei. Its unidentified sources said Softbank would buy more than 50% of T-Mobile’s shares, mainly from DT, which still owns 67% of TMo even after it merged with MetroPCS. That would leave DT with about 15%, though it has been widely expected to seek a complete exit soon, and would value TMo at about $32bn.
The Japanese firm, which believes the merger is the only way to create a viable competitor to Verizon and AT&T, would pay cash and use stock swaps to reach the estimated price of over $16bn, and is said to have lined up credit from eight financial institutions, including Japan’s top three banks plus JPMorganChase and Deutsche Bank.
More difficult than the financing will be the regulatory process. The companies, particularly Softbank’s CEO Masayoshi Son, have been lobbying the FCC and Department of Justice for months, preparing the ground for the inevitable scrutiny of any deal which would reduce the number of mobile carriers in the US still further.
Softbank will be well aware that AT&T’s own bid for T-Mobile distracted the carrier for about a year of reviews, before finally failing. However, it argues that the US needs a more powerful third player as a counterweight to the rising power of the big two, and that the competitive landscape must be seen in terms of all mobile, telecoms and media services, not mobile alone.
This will be relevant as the regulatory authorities are also examining proposed mergers between AT&T and DirecTV, and between the two leading cablecos, Comcast and Time Warner Cable. Verizon last week denied interest in Dish. CEO Lowell McAdam told CNBC that Dish had ‘some great spectrum’ and that ‘anything around spectrum is always of interest to us’, but made it clear that the interest would not stretch to acquisition. ‘I haven’t seen a scenario yet that owning a satellite company makes sense to us … We could do some interesting things but buying the whole company doesn’t make sense to us, at least as we sit here today,’ he said.
Verizon has been the slickest operator when it comes to recent M&A, making two hugely significant deals, both of them far less concerning to regulators than its rivals’ proposals. First it acquired AWS and other spectrum from four cable operators, which will now be the basis of its second-stage, capacity-driven LTE roll-out. Then it recently bought out Vodafone’s 45% stake in Verizon Wireless, giving it full control of its most valuable business.
However, Softbank remains hopeful. In June, Son told a journalists that he had seen ‘new movement’ in his preliminary talks with regulators, implying that they were softening their approach, but he will not be deluding himself that this will be an easy process. It is already reported that he has had to ask banks to commit financing for a longer time than usual, which will incur higher fees, because of the expected length of the approval process. Sprint is asking its own banks for about $20bn, while Softbank is seeking a similar amount, Bloomberg said. The funds would also be used to refinance some of TMo’s debt, purchase spectrum at upcoming auctions, and fund operations.
Whether or not the two operators end up merging, they reportedly plan a more limited joint venture anyway, to bid in next year’s incentive auction of 600MHz broadcast TV spectrum, the US’s biggest sale of new frequencies since the 700MHz digital dividend transaction. According to Bloomberg sources, the JV would have its own management team, though one of the partners would have ultimate responsibility for any spectrum acquired, if they do not end up as a single company.
In May, the FCC voted 3-2 for 600MHz rules which will prevent AT&T and Verizon from acquiring the bulk of the airwaves, and will reserve up to 30MHz for carriers which currently hold less than one-third of available sub-1GHz spectrum in any market, making a cap of about 45MHz. Only the big two own more than that in low frequency bands currently, and neither Sprint nor T-Mobile owns more than around 20MHz in any market, so could still bid on the reserved airwaves as a combined entity in most areas.
Also planning to bid in the auction is Dish Network, whose need for a spectrum and network partner, to make its mobile broadband roll-out plan viable, is currently being thwarted by the mergers of its potential allies (notably Sprint/Clearwire). Dish chairman Charlie Ergen has commited to ‘meaningfully participate’ in the auction. Its SVP, Jeffrey Blum, wrote in an FCC filing: ‘The incentive auction offers opportunities for competitive providers and new entrants to bid on and win much-needed low band spectrum, which will facilitate the deployment of mobile broadband services.’ Dish will also take part in the sale of AWS-3 spectrum, scheduled for November.
Dish is in an increasingly tough position, if it sticks to its goal of building an LTE network to add a quad play to its satellite-TV services. That would help it to keep up with the activities of the major cablecos, and the big two telcos, in bringing together TV, broadband, WiFi and cellular networks. But as the cablecos found before Dish, when they had a now-abandoned plan to roll out LTE in their own spectrum, there are many barriers. The established mobile players have more spectrum, greater mobile brand awareness, more expertise and, of course, an established foundation of customers and base stations. Dish could end up with an odd collection of frequencies, which has impact on device costs and choice ‘ its existing mobile satellite licences, plus AWS-3 and 600MHz ‘ and little activity in WiFi, unlike rivals like Comcast. What it really needs is to ride on a partner’s more mainstream spectrum, and on its infrastructure, a deal it should have done with Sprint. That opportunity was lost when Dish overplayed its hand by bidding for Clearwire and Sprint in opposition to Softbank, rather than seeking a deal with the Japanese firm, which would probably welcome a new partner in its US network and a revenue stream for Sprint’s Network Vision infrastructure.
Dish might still have done such a deal, replacing the quartet of cablecos ‘ which used to have spectrum sharing and MVNO agreements with Sprint before they defected to Verizon. But if Softbank pursues T-Mobile, the window will probably close for Dish. There will be enough to do to merge the third and fourth cellcos’ networks, hosting as much as possible on Network Vision, and to appease the regulator, without bringing Dish into the mix too.
That may leave the satellite TV company selling on its spectrum assets and settling for offering wireless services purely through a conventional MVNO and/or WiFi. It may also see Dish looking for a merger partner of its own, though Verizon has repeatedly denied the inevitable rumors that it is interested, and there are few other candidates left. Dish faces being the wallflower at the ball if the current trio of proposed mergers all goes ahead, so unsurprisingly, it is lobbying against them. It has submitted an official FCC filing expressing concern over the Comcast/TWC, and AT&T/DirecTV plans, and calling for a deep level of scrutiny, saying the two mergers present ‘serious competitive concerns for the broadband and video marketplaces and therefore should be denied’. It continues: ‘The ability for Dish and other non-dominant players to compete in the broadband and video markets will be impacted by how the Commission responds to the mergers before it.’
South of the border, America Movil’s billionaire chairman Carlos Slim has acknowledged the inevitability of dramatic restructuring, and will break-up his company in its home base of Mexico, in advance of imminent new antitrust legislation.
Those laws will almost certainly place stringent restrictions on America Movil if it has not made its own moves to reduce its market dominance. The largest operator in the Americas, with 272m wireless subscribers, America Movil will now divest some assets to an independent company, reducing its market share in Mexican landlines and mobile phones to below 50%, from 80% and 70% respectively now.
It will also separate its cell towers from its other businesses and give up its right to acquire control of satellite-TV provider Dish Mexico. Without these measures, the Mexican Congress would likely impose the harshest penalties every suffered by Slim’s empire. Movil has lost about $17bn in market value since president Enrique Pena Nieto took office in 2012 with pledges to increase more competition and boost the Mexican economy.
The operator may fetch about $8.6bn by selling assets and will need to divest about 21m wireless users and 4m landlines to reduce its market share below 50%, Martin Lara, an analyst with Actinver, told Bloomberg.
Slim is also to acquire AT&T’s 8.3% stake in America Movil (which includes 24% of the voting shares) for $5.6bn, helping the US firm to ease the regulatory passage of its proposed $49bn acquisition of DirecTV. In June 2013, AT&T sold 7.5% of its stake in Movil for about $564m. The Mexican giant owns TracFone Wireless, the largest US MVNO with more than 25m customers.
The firm has also been expanding tentatively in Europe, with footholds in Telekom Austria and The Netherlands’ KPN. It has announced it will pay €743m ($1bn) to increase its stake in the former carrier, to 50.8%, as it looks to reduce its reliance on Mexico amid the new regulatory environment. Slim told Reuters that Central and Eastern Europe still has ‘plenty of mileage left in it’, and he aims to use Austria as a platform for future growth there. However, it will not expand in Europe at any cost ‘ a bid last year to take control of KPN failed because the offer was considered too low.
Dish and LightSquared settle some differences:
Dish also failed in its attempt to buy bankrupt mobile satellite venture LightSquared, but Ergen holds over $1bn in debt in the firm. The two companies have been in dispute, with LightSquared owner Harbinger Capital trying to send Ergen to the bottom of the creditor list, claiming it amassed the debt in secret. Ergen withdrew a full takeover offer ‘ the only one received in the Chapter XI auction ‘ at the last minute, for undisclosed ‘technical reasons’. The dispute was settled late last week, which will remove one barrier to LightSquared emerging from bankruptcy. The new agreement will replace a planned $1.3bn in funding for the company’s bankruptcy exit that was to have been raised in the market by JPMorganChase. Instead, Ergen will get a $1bn claim, a $316m reduction on his previous one, which will roll into a new loan for LightSquared once it exits Chapter XI, at which point Ergen will provide an extra $300m. Some Harbinger insiders expressed concerns that a competitor was being invited into the LightSquared capital structure, and questioned whether that might affect the federal lawsuit the firm is filing against the FCC for rejecting its LTE network amid concerns of GPS interference.