Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 July 2014

Chromebook vital for Intel, dangerous for Microsoft

Contrary to many expectations, the PC is not dying rapidly. In certain segments, devices which retain the key features of the PC ‘ large screens, physical keyboards, Intel processors ‘ are holding their own very well against tablets and large smartphones, as illustrated in Intel’s strong quarterly results, in which ‘ as in the last quarter ‘ PCs were an unexpected highlight. However, the low power, low cost PC-like device is where the growth lies, and Intel will have to battle to keep its dominance of that. The Chromebook, Google’s reinvention of the cloud-attached netbook idea, is responsible for a large amount of the buoyancy in the PC-like market ‘ Dell has sold out of its only model, for instance. But the Chromebook clearly lacks one hallmark of the traditional PC, the Windows operating system ‘ something Microsoft pledged to address, saying it was ‘not ceding the low end to anyone’. To keep ahead of a revived Microsoft proposition, possibly including the axing of licensing fees, the Chromebook will need to get even cheaper, and that may naturally turn vendors away from Intel processors and towards low cost ARM-based alternatives.

The Chromebook, then, having been a niche item for most of its life, is now a useful bellwether, indicating both the survival of demand for a large-screened device with a keyboard, and the shift towards the thin client model, where that device is largely an appliance running a browser and cloud services. Chromebooks have accounted for 35% of all US commercial/enterprise laptop shipments to date in 2014, up 250% on the same stage last year, according to analysts at NPD, and the Google-driven devices make up 6% of overall consumer laptop sales in the period.

Keeping its platform in a leadership role during that shift will be critical for Intel, and indeed for Microsoft, though the latter could well, eventually, give up the fight on the client OS, and still gain a powerful role by delivering its cloud applications to all kinds of end points (see separate item on Nadella’s manifesto).

The importance of the new incarnation of the PC was very clear in Intel’s second quarter financial report, in which mobile losses continued to mount, but PC revenues held up surprisingly well. Overall, the company reported record quarterly microprocessor shipments, and added $1bn to its year-ago revenue figure, turning in $13.8bn for the quarter. Operating income was $3.8bn, net income $2.8bn and earnings per share 55 cents.

Intel did not give exact processor shipment numbers, but credited that business with its strong figures, and particularly singled out Chromebooks and its low power Bay Trail system-on-chip. Slow to get the power-efficient SoC right in the past, Intel was in danger of ceding not just the handset market, but all the emerging new post-PC form factors, to ARM-based rivals. However, Bay Trail and other upcoming SoCs have finally given the company an offering which can genuinely go up against ARM in the low power game.

“With the ramp of our Bay Trail SoC family, we have expanded into new segments such as Chrome-based systems, and we are on track to meet our 40m unit tablet goal,” CEO Brian Krzanich said in a statement. “In addition, we hit an important qualification milestone for our upcoming 14nm Broadwell processor, and expect the first systems to be on shelves during the holidays.” The 14nm shift, together with 3D transistors, will put Intel ahead of the field in terms of process, indicating the advantages of its control of its own production, and enabling it to reduce power, size and cost of chips further.

Other upcoming chips for the year include Cherry Trail for tablets, which will ship by the end of the year, and Broxton, the next generation low-power Atom chip. Next year, Intel will release Skylake, for PCs and tablets.

However, the mobile and communications group continues to struggle. Its revenue was down 67% on Q114, and 83% year-on-year, to just $51m, a drop in the ocean for a company which has often acknowledged that mobile expansion is critical to offset the decline of the PC. The group lost $1.1bn in the quarter and has lost $2bn already this year.

Intel has come very late to the smartphone party, and despite some recent design wins and a much improved offering, it still has important disadvantages compared to Qualcomm, notably the lack of a fully integrated processor/modem solution for LTE ‘ essential for low cost, low power handsets.

On the results call, CFO Stacy Smith recognized the urgency of the situation, saying that, if Intel cannot integrate mobile connectivity into communications within 3-4 years, it will be locked out of critical segments of the market. Many would say Smith was being optimistic on the timelines.

Krzanich said on the call: “I believe, over time, we can make this a profitable business. We have some ground to make up in moving LTE to Category 6 and having our products designed for this segment. As we turn into SoFIA [the all-in-one SoC family], you’ll see a family of product really targeting this space and that’s how we become profitable.”

Intel president Renee James told the recent Fortune Brainstorm Tech conference that the company had greatly underestimated the impact of the iPhone and other smartphones. “We didn’t anticipate that these devices would become general purpose computing devices,” she said. “Apple gave us the guiding light and we missed that ‘ or were slow to it.” She insisted, however, that ‘this company has a culture of reinvention and we are in that phase’, especially pointing to the IoT, where Intel may have the opportunity to leapfrog the mobile-driven generation of platforms and gain an early lead in its successor.

The repeated missteps in mobile mean that post-PC devices like Chromebooks, tablets and Intel’s own ultrabook designs are shouldering a heavier burden in the company than expected a couple of years ago, as is the emerging internet of things (IoT) platform, where the giant has come up with a differentiated offering and coherent sales strategy at a far earlier stage than it did in mobile devices. IoT, whose importance was recognized by Krzanich when he created a dedicated division around the segment, saw its revenues rise by just over 10% year-on-year, to $539m, already 10 times higher than the mobile platform.

There were similar revenue increases for other key groups. PC Client was up 6% to $8.7bn ‘ notebook volume was up 9%, including Chromebooks, and even good old desktops were up 8% in volume and suffered a less severe unit price decline than their portable companions (2% versus 7%, also partly the impact of the post-PC designs). Meanwhile, the data center division’s revenues were up 10% to $3.5bn and the software and services group up 3% to $548m.

Looking forward, Krazanich expects revenue to increase 4% in the third quarter to $14.4bn, and gross margins to increase to 66% as Intel’s costs are driven down more aggressively even than selling prices. That pattern of rising margins will certainly be hard to sustain in the mobile world, or in Chromebooks, which are highly price sensitive, and we are likely to see Intel tightening its ties with low cost Chinese partners, particularly Rockchip, with which it is designing and co-selling a variant of SoFIA. We have seen how critical it is that Intel holds onto the Chromebook, despite its processor-neutral approach ‘ Samsung’s Exynos mobile processor is already used in some low cost models. While high end variants like Google’s own Chromebook Pixel may have Core i3 or even i5 CPUs, Celeron and, in future, Atom, are more likely choices, and even those can be easily outdone on price by companies like Rockchip and MediaTek.

Rockchip recently showed off a prototype Chromebook running its RK3288 ARM Cortex-A17 processor and MediaTek has just added a new ARM-based board to Chromium’s open source repository, codenamed Moose. Such offerings could drive low end Chromebooks down to the price of cheap tablets, further widening the choices in this low cost post-PC space. If device makers like the Chinese chips, they could adopt them to launch models priced as low as $150 (the cheapest option currently available is $199 and runs on Celeron).

For Microsoft, this is bad news because consumers are being offered a large screen and keyboard (the reason for many to cling to notebooks rather than move to tablets) at ultra-low prices, and for those who don’t want to move entirely into the cloud, Google is increasingly adding support for Android apps. While Microsoft’s medium term approach looks likely (if CEO Satya Nadella keeps his nerve and his common sense) to be to support any client operating systems, and push its cloud-based assets such as Office 365, for now it is defending Windows’ place from top to bottom of the device market assertively. Windows Phone is still with us (though its role may be reduced in the upcoming reorganization), and Microsoft recently did the unthinkable by forgoing licensing fees in order to make it more competitive with Android. The giant may well do the same for low cost PCs as it defends itself against Chrome and Android.

Last year, Microsoft ran a US advertising campaign with the tagline ‘Scroogled’, setting out Windows’ strengths when compared to Chrome OS. Now its COO Kevin Turner is telling the Microsoft Partners’ Conference: ‘We are going to participate at the low end. We’ve got a great value proposition against Chromebooks, we are not ceding the market to anyone.’ The main elements of the proposition are compelling for anyone accustomed to the traditional PC ‘ support for native apps, desktop apps and, of course, Office, as well as better offline and peripherals support. With low cost laptops available around $249, not far off the Chromebook floor price, Turner is even looking ahead to $99 laptops running Windows 8.1.

In the end, the consumer will decide which experience he or she prefers. Most Microsoft partners are hedging their bets with both device types ‘ Dell, Lenovo, Acer, Asus, HP and many Asian providers. And as the margins dry up on low end PCs or post-PCs, and certainly if Microsoft cancels licensing fees, the clear question is ‘ why does it continue to battle for the low end PC and the mobile device, especially if the main reason customers stay loyal is for Office. In that case, why not abandon its client-side heritage at last and accelerate the process of reaping richer cloud service rewards on every operating system?