Qualcomm has enjoyed a surprisingly long and scarcely challenged period of dominance of the LTE modem market, at least in smart devices where its ability to integrate with the application processor has been hard to beat. How much longer can its leadership be sustained, as it faces new challenges from MediaTek, Samsung and, eventually, Intel?
Specialist players such as Sequans and Altair are carving out interesting markets in the LTE-only markets, and if they can continue to drive down power consumption, they are well placed for some internet of things applications. But the volumes currently remain with 3G/4G handsets, and the downward pressure on prices in that sector has dictated a rapid move towards highly integrated SoCs, the area where Qualcomm excels. It has seen off some potential challengers ‘ Nvidia appears to have given up on its LTE/Tegra combination, built on its acquisition of Icera; Broadcom is selling off the LTE modem business it briefly acquired from Renesas; Texas Instruments and Freescale long ago moved away from smartphone basebands.
Those exits highlight how hard it is to compete in this market, with its powerful incumbent and its unforgiving price pressures. The latter creates a situation in which a successful player needs to generate high volumes to make up for falling margins, but also needs to keep up with a breakneck pace of change, squeezing design cycles and the opportunity to maximize the return on a piece of R&D. The technical challenges of supporting the latest LTE and LTE-Advanced capabilities, and integrating the modem with other connectivity and with the processors, are considerable, and expensive.
Only a few firms have the financial and engineering strengths to cope with this unpromising landscape, and the sheer difficulty is seen clearly in Intel’s struggle to deliver an integrated LTE SoC, even though its CFO admitted on its results call this week that without such a product, Intel could not succeed in the handset market (see separate item).
When Intel’s LTE SoC, SoFIA, does appear in products next year, it is likely to be a threat to Qualcomm’s massive LTE market share (over 90% at its peak and still well over 80%). Intel is creating strong partnerships, notably with Rockchip in China, and has existing modem business and channels via its purchase of Infineon Wireless.
The more immediate concerns for Qualcomm, however, come from Samsung and the Chinese/Taiwanese base of chipmakers, which are starting to move upwards from their traditional stronghold at the featurephone end, and into LTE smartphones.
Samsung made its most serious play ever for the LTE smartphone chip space this week, with the introduction of two 4G mobile platforms. Previously, the Korean giant has included its own LTE and multimode modems in selected Galaxy models for the US and its home country, but it has mainly relied on external suppliers, especially Qualcomm. However, like Apple, the company’s handset division is keen to be more self-sufficient in key components, to reduce costs and increase control of its supply chain (see separate item). It is already its own biggest customer for mobile displays and has its own memory chips and its Exynos processors. It still uses Qualcomm processors in some models, especially where it wants full integration, but it will now be aiming to squeeze the US firm’s share of its chip purchases significantly.
It will also, for the first time, be a competitor to Qualcomm in pitching for business with other device makers, though competitive conflicts may keep it out of most handset makers’ devices, pushing it towards makers of other products such as connected cars or home gadgets.
The two new platforms are the quad-core Exynos ModAP, an integrated multimode LTE modem and apps processor built in 28nm; and the Exynos 300 LTE-Advanced modem. Both are based on CEVA’s DSP (digital signal processing) cores and the latter will appear in devices next year, while the ModAP is available now.
In addition, Samsung introduced its Exynos RF IC series, a single-chip multiband multimode RF transceiver with analog IQ interface to the 2G/3G/LTE baseband. This is more interesting than the brief press announcement indicated, as it sees Samsung extending its reach into many areas of the handset’s array of chips, to increase its control of the whole device. This is also one of Qualcomm’s important strategies ‘ as well as increasing its connectivity capabilities, especially in WiFi, via its acquisition of Atheros, the firm last year unveiled its first significant RFIC offering, the RF360, aimed at multiband LTE ‘worldphones’.
The other firm which will be giving Qualcomm executives sleepless nights right now is MediaTek, which is moving rapidly up the food chain into high end SoCs. This week, it announced the MT6795, which ticks all the hot boxes for premium mobile processors ‘ octacore, 64-bit and LTE-Advanced. The SoC has eight ARM Cortex-A53 64-bit cores clocked at up to 2.2GHz each, and instantly becomes MediaTek’s new flagship with world-first support for a mobile 2K display, as well as 480fps, 1080p full HD Super-Slow Motion video. However, analyst Will Strauss of Forward Concepts believes the offering is not a fully integrated single chip, but rather a stacked application processor and modem.
For connectivity, the MT6795 supports 802.11ac WiFi,B luetooth, FM, ANT+ and GPS/Glonass/BeiDou. Initially it supports LTE Release 9 Cat-4, in TDD and FDD modes, but executives talked up the roadmap to LTE-Advanced releases too. The firm is working with VIA Telecom on a CDMA/LTE version to target Verizon, in particular, but the chip will be aimed first at China as the modem has not yet been certified by US and European carriers.
The next concern for Qualcomm will hanging on to its multimode LTE modem crown as more rivals pile into this space, including Huawei’s HiSilicon, Marvell, Intel and Samsung, with MediaTek, Spreadtrum and ZTE expected to join the party soon.
While all this will put pressure on Qualcomm, eating into its share and forcing it to reduce prices, the real casualties of moves like Samsung’s are those companies which entered the LTE modem and SoC game but failed to achieve sufficient early momentum ‘ Broadcom and Nvidia being prime examples. ‘Qualcomm still enjoys over 95% of the multimode LTE market, even with new entries announced in 2014,’ Strauss told EETimes and his figures for the first quarter of this year indicate that Qualcomm has 94% share of multimode FD-LTE modems, followed by Samsung with 3%.
And new figures from Strategy Analytics say that Qualcomm recorded a fivefold increase in tablet app processor sales during Q114, in a sector which grew by 30% year-on-year overall to hit a value of €674.4m. In that, Apple leads with 30% of revenue, thanks to the iPad’s dominance, with Qualcomm second on 18% and Intel third on 11%.
Senior analyst Sravan Kundojjala said: ‘Qualcomm maintained its tablet applications processor momentum in Q1 2014 and scored multiple high profile tablet design wins with its Snapdragon 800 family of chips.’ MediaTek was also seen to be making strong progress.