Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 November 2012

Apple and Google could seek truce, but Samsung refuses

In another significant sign that the Apple/Android patent wars could be nearing a truce, it seems that the firm is pushing for arbitration to settle its differences with Motorola Mobility. The Motorola cases have added importance for the whole industry since the firm was acquired by Google, the real target of Apple’s ‘thermonuclear’ patents war, though the search giant has also suggested it favors arbitration.

Last week, Apple surprised the industry by announcing a settlement with HTC, though hopes that this might be a blueprint for other agreements were dashed when Samsung took a hard line, saying it had no plans to negotiate with its arch-rival. Of course, Samsung is in the strongest position to push Apple to the edge, and its hardline statements may have been posturing. But while that battle may drag on, the mobile sector would be relieved if Google/Motorola joined HTC at the negotiating table.

Bloomberg discovered a court filing that indicated that Apple and Motorola are discussing going to arbitration to resolve their disputes in the US and elsewhere. The filing, made by Apple, said: ‘The companies have been exchanging proposals on using binding arbitration to reach a licensing agreement over patents that are essential to comply with industry standards on how phones operate.’ It added: ‘Apple is also interested in resolving its dispute with Motorola completely and agrees that arbitration may be the best vehicle to resolve the parties’ dispute.’

This is the clearest indication yet of a new strategy under Apple’s new CEO Tim Cook, who has repeatedly hinted that he wants to end the IPR battles. Of course, he will hold out for favorable terms for Apple, but he shares none of predecessor Steve Jobs’s belief in using IPR and battalions of lawyers not primarily to collect licensing revenues, but to stop competitors selling their products and ultimately trying to cripple them as iDevice challengers.

Google had originally raised the issue of arbitration a few months ago in a court hearing, and the firms general counsel Kent Walker said in a letter to Apple last week, which was filed with the court: ‘We have long sought a path to resolving patent issues and we welcome the chance to build on the constructive dialogue between our companies. While we prefer to seek a framework for a global (rather than piecemeal) resolution that addresses all of our patent disputes, we are committed to reaching agreement on a license for our respective standard-essential patents.’

The Samsung-Apple war rumbles on though, and in the latest development, Samsung has won a review of a previous reversal at the US ITC (International Trade Commission). In its US battle with Apple, the Korean firm has so far been the major loser after a federal court in San Jose handed the iPhone maker a billion dollar deal. However, the Galaxy maker can smell blood, and based on its rising smartphone power and some victories elsewhere ‘ including at the US Patents Office ‘ it has said it will not negotiate with Apple over a settlement. That statement ‘ which may be posturing, but reflects the company’s new confidence ‘ came in the wake of Apple’s agreement to make a deal with fellow Android antagonist HTC, signalling a new flexibility in its ‘thermonuclear’ IPR war against the Google OS.

In the latest twist, Samsung has gained a review of a preliminary ITC decision that Android did not infringe four of its key patents in the iPhone and iPad. The trade agency, which has the power to block imports of devices which infringe on patents, said it will review ‘in its entirety’ the original decision, made in September. This is usual practice at the ITC, which will make its final ruling on January 14. Samsung originally filed its accusations at the Commission in June 2011 in response to similar claims by Apple.

‘We remain confident that the Commission will reach a final determination that affirms our position that Apple must be held accountable for free-riding on our technological innovations,’ said a Samsung spokesman.

Apple’s own ITC case against Samsung is also under review. It won the first round in October, when Judge Thomas Pender decided that the Korean firm infringed four Apple patents, including one for the design of the iPhone and one for touch-screen technology co-invented by Steve Jobs. The Commission is scheduled to announce its next steps in that case on January 9.

And Samsung is, understandably, taking a keen interest in the terms of the Apple-HTC settlement, which the Taiwanese firm’s CEO, Peter Chou, recently said had been wildly exaggerated by some analyst and media estimates (some had pointed to fees of $200m to $300m in 2013). On Wednesday, Apple was ordered by federal judge Paul Grewal in San Jose, where Samsung is appealing the $1bn reversal, to disclose its HTC licensing terms, though this will not be published beyond the firm and its attorneys. Samsung had demanded this on the basis that it was relevant to Apple’s request for an injunction against some of its devices in the US. The filing says it is ‘almost certain’ that there is crossover between the Apple-HTC settlement and some of the patents Samsung is disputing with Apple, and adds that the HTC deal may undermine Apple’s claim that Samsung’s patent infringement cannot be rectified by licence payments, leaving it with no option but to pursue an import ban.

In another important patents battle, between Microsoft and Motorola Mobility, oral arguments have now closed in a case before US District Judge James Robart. This could set important precedents on the licensing of standards-essential patents, as well as billions of dollars of royalties potentially being at stake.

Many Microsoft fights revolve around its own claimed IPR in Android, which have led to licensing deals with a string of smartphone makers. But this one is about the level of fees the Windows giant should pay Motorola for patents which are part of the 802.11 Wi-Fi and H.264 video encoding standards.

Any case involving Motorola has added weight for the Android industry these days because of Google’s ownership. The decision could help set guidelines in the thorny issue of how standards-essential patents should be licensed, and it could affect future settlements Motorola might make over Android IPR. The handset maker is now the only significant stand-out against Microsoft’s claims to IPR in the Google OS.

The case concluded after six days of testimony, with 18 hours allowed on each side. Judge Robart has set a deadline of December 14 for both sides to deliver their closing arguments in the form of post-trial briefs and will make a final ruling in the spring. Motorola is demanding fees of up to $4bn for its use of its IPR, which is included in Windows and Xbox, based on a level of 2.25% of the product price. Microsoft has said it is ready to pay a royalty, but below that figure.

The case could help establish rules for what counts as ‘reasonable’ in the Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) guidelines set for licensing standards essential patents.

Finally, Apple is still building up its patents armory. It has acquired 1,024 patents from the Rockstar Consortium, of which it is a member. Rockstar bought thousands of IPR assets from Nortel Networks out of bankruptcy court last year, but according to Business Insider, the group has been quietly passing the patents on to Apple over the past six months. Other Rockstar members are
EMC, Ericsson, Microsoft, RIM and Sony and it paid $4.5bn for a 6,000-strong portfolio in an auction in June 2011. Apple put up $2.5bn in the deal, which gave it access to the IPR, but this does not give the same leverage, of course, as full ownership, especially when using patents as weapons against rivals in litigation.