Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 November 2012

Orange follows Telefonica in taking on Skype

Orange is the latest cellco to take the ‘if you can’t beat them, join them’ approach to over-the-top challenges to their voice cash cows. Several carriers have launched their own applications to compete with Skype and WhatsApp, some ‘ like Telefonica’s Tu Me and T-Mobile USA’s Bobsled ‘ able to run on other carriers’ networks too. Orange is the latest to make this move with the launch of Libon.

This will offer high quality voice, visual voicemail, text and other communications services over its own and others’ networks. It is first offering its app for iOS, entering the over-the-top space rather than clinging entirely to its own network-based voice/text offerings, or merely partnering with Skype et al to try to get a share of the brand glory, customer appeal and even revenue (as seen at Verizon and 3, among others). And Android version of Libon will debut next year.

Like a true OTT player, Orange will try to generate revenues by offering paid-for premium options, notably an hour of international calling, full voicemail transcription and other features. And it will harness its R&D capabilities, superior to those of nearly all web apps players, to ensure Libon stands out from the crowd. Its labs are testing a product called On Voicefeed, which can customize voicemail messages for specific callers or groups.

Although Libon has high definition VoIP and visual voicemail, it lacks Tu Me’s photo sharing and location sharing features, which set it apart by integrating into social networking behaviors, even ahead of Skype in some respects.

With these services, cellcos are potentially cannibalizing their own base, and the rules of competing in the OTT world are very different ‘ though one imperative is common, to achieve scale as quickly as possible to make the business case viable. Orange R&D’s Giles Corbett, who heads the Libon team, said in an interview: ‘Either you get scale quite rapidly or you don’t. It’s got to be millions very rapidly, and growing into tens of millions.’

Scale relies on the free services, of course, and on the carrier’s brand power, while revenue will come from premium services ‘ tough to sell, but perhaps less so when they can be bundled with existing deals, another advantage over pure OTT players. Orange is likely to offer the premium features as value-adds for its conventional subscribers and the operator’s low cost French subsidiary Sosh will be offering a trial of ‘unlimited free international calling to landlines and mobiles in European countries via Libon’. Indeed, any Orange unit can take Libon and create its own propositions around it, Corbett told GigaOm, requiring a level of technical integration and billing capability not available to the web majors.

He said in the interview: ‘Carriers need to remain relevant. Orange will do anything to remain relevant in that communications experience, to maintain the relationship with the end user so they remain loyal to Orange’ All we’ll see is a transition away from people billing for minutes to people billing for access.’ Cellcos need to remember that their role is to provide ‘outstanding communications services’, however that is achieved.

Some providers are pinning their hopes in this respect on enhancing network-based services so they are irresistibly better than OTT and so attract users to pay for at least some of their voice/messaging services. The main engine for this approach is RCSe (Rich Communications Services Enhanced, the GSM Association platform based on IMS). This adds many added value features to traditional voice and text, and is receiving a major boost from LTE. Many carriers, including Orange and Telefonica, will keep their options open with a mixture of RCS and OTT services, as well as alliances with Skype or WhatsApp.

Indian cellco Reliance Communications recently announced a ‘WhatsApp Plan’ for GSM subscribers in an exclusive deal with the web player in India. It offers unlimited WhatsApp and Facebook usage to all prepaid GSM subscribers with no data charges. But like so many operators dabbling with OTT services ‘ their own or a partner’s ‘ the main objective is merely to fend off the tide of competition, not to lead the mobile disruption themselves. Their best ‘ though unexciting ‘ bet is to apply their traditional skills in pricing and charging to the new services. This was seen recently when 3 Hong Kong launched the WhatsApp Roaming Pass, which gives subscribers unlimited access to the service for HK$8 (US$1) a month, without that counting towards their data caps, and also provides daily passes for unlimited WhatsApp access in many countries round the world. This could be the future of mobile data plans, giving consumers affordable access to their favorite applications while helping carriers dilute the effect of those apps on margins and user loyalty. Rather than trying to create services which outdo those of the OTT players ‘ rarely a strong point for cellcos ‘ they can play to their strengths by adding value in terms of attractive packages instead. Many users would pay for unlimited access ‘ toll-free ‘ to a set of much-used applications, especially if international access were included, keeping data caps manageable.