Apple turned in record revenues and iDevice sales, but its stock continued its recent nosedive, falling by almost 10% after its quarterly results were announced on Wednesday night. This was because, as Wall Street had feared, sales growth was down at its lowest level since 2009, the revenue figure was below analyst forecasts, and Apple offered a downbeat projection for the current quarter. That is increasing the pressure on Apple to do two things ‘ bring out a killer product which creates a new kind of demand, as with the original iPhone; and announce a convincing strategy for emerging economies, which would nevertheless not kill its still enviable margins. This will be a tough double act to pull off, and will depend as much on the supply chain control for which CEO Tim Cook is famous as reviving flagging belief in Apple’s innovation skills. While entirely new platforms must be considered for the future, tapping into cloud and multiscreen trends, in the short term the response to both the challenges above is likely to center on the growing variety of form factors in the tablet category.
All these factors emphasize the fears that Apple’s winning streak is ending. Those fears drove its stock price, once more, below the $500 level ‘ still a price most companies would kill for, but this is a firm which, only a few months ago, was predicted to hit $1,000 in the near future. The price fell to $463.49 in after-hours trading, from $514.01 just before the results were revealed.
Cook, on the analyst call, betrayed impatience with the poor response to the firm’s highest ever quarterly sales, up 18% year-on-year at $54.5bn. ‘No technology company has ever reported these kind of results,’ he said and faced up to the biggest criticism of Apple under his leadership, that it has ceased to innovate. “Apple is in one of the most prolific periods of innovation in new products in its history,’ he insisted.
Net profit for the quarter was $13.1bn, roughly flat with the year-ago quarter. International sales accounted for 61% of revenue. Gross margin was 38.6%, down from 44.7%.
However, the company forecast that its sales would decline by over 20% sequentially in the current quarter. CFO Peter Oppenheimer offered projections of $41bn to $43bn, which would still be a 5% to 10% increase on the year-ago period. However, the predicted dip would represent a sequential fall of 21% to 25%, and would fall short of analyst expectations of $45.6bn – although of course there is always a dip in the first calendar quarter after the boost from the holiday season.
And that boost was clear to see at Apple, especially as the firm had suffered around the middle of 2012 as users held out for the iPhone 5 launch. In calendar Q4, it sold a record 47.8m iPhones, up 30% year-on-year and 78% on the previous period, which had largely lacked a new smartphone model. The vendor also shifted 22.9m iPads, up from 15.4m a year earlier. In decline were Macs and iPods, reflecting the crisis in PCs and standalone media gadgets ‘ Mac sales were down to 4.1m, from 5.2m a year earlier, while iPods fell from 15.4m to 12.7m.
By region, Apple will be relieved that Chinese growth picked up, although it is still expected to see falling market share in the country for Q412. Greater China revenues were up 67% year-on-year to $6.8bn. The largest market remained the Americas, up 15% to $20.3bn, while Europe was up 11% to $12.4bn. Asia outside China remains the clearly under-tapped region bringing in just $3.9bn, up modestly at 10%, indicating Apple’s ongoing challenges in India, in particular. That figure excludes Japan, where revenue leapt by 25% on expanded carrier deals and product range, to $4.4bn. Oppenheimer said iPhone sales doubled in China during the quarter and Apple opened four new stores in the country. It will also invest between $2-3m in opening a new retail store in Indonesia this year, according to local reports.
Cook was evasive about recent reports that Apple has reduced orders of iPhone components, possibly because of misjudged demand forecasts. ‘Even if a particular data point were factual, it would be impossible to interpret for our overall business. Yields can vary, supplier performance can vary ‘ there’s an inordinately long list of things that would make any single data point not a great proxy for what’s going on,’ he said.
The big debate around Apple is whether it should chase the mass market with lower cost iPhone and iPad models. Last year, Franklin Templeton Investments cut its holdings in Apple, citing saturation in the key US market and lack of a strategy to sell lower cost devices in China, India and other major emerging markets. Portfolio manager George Russell told a conference: ‘We trimmed on a few occasions last year. We are concerned about their lack of a strategy in the lower end phone which tends to be sold much more in the emerging market. The US is pretty saturated.’
Apple’s former CEO John Sculley added his weight to the debate in a Bloomberg TV interview last week. Despite presiding over one of the worst periods of Apple’s history, he felt free to offer advice to current leader Tim Cook, saying Apple needs to overhaul its supply chain to meet demand for cheaper smartphones in emerging markets.
Apple is already sending out signals of its own. Cook said on a recent visit to China that he expects that to overtake the US as his firm’s largest market soon ‘ yet Apple lags behind Samsung and Lenovo in smartphones in the country, partly because of the lack of a deal with the biggest cellco China Mobile.
Already, it is pushing its supply chain to enable it to create cheaper devices and so maintain margins on offerings like the iPad mini. And it has abandoned its old strategy of exclusives and premium smartphones, rolling out the iPhone 5 on a record scale ‘ to 100 countries by the end of 2012, and via a wide range of channels including prepaid carriers. Walter Price, managing director at RCM Capital Management, told Bloomberg: ‘They have had this luxury of skimming the cream of the market, and those days are ending. Revenue growth is definitely moderating and margins are definitely going down.’
All this contributed to a fall in the average selling price, especially of the iPad ‘ this fell by about $100. This was because of the mini, but also because of the decision to sell a lower cost iPad 2. The latter is likely to have more impact on margins, as the mini was designed for the mass market and has a highly efficient bill of materials which is thought to preserve much of Apple’s traditional margin.
Considering factors such as the decline of the PC sector, ‘the underlying performance of the business is much stronger than the 5-10% year-over-year growth implies, and we remain very confident in our business and our new product pipeline,” Oppenheimer said. And of course, the larger and more valuable a company is, the harder it is to find the same growth percentages. Jack Ablin, chief investment officer at BMO Private Bank, commented: ‘It’s a gigantic company, so incremental growth is just that much more difficult.’
Although Apple is currently still largely living on the product designs and pipelines built under the stewardship of previous CEO Steve Jobs, Cook needs to do more to instil confidence that he can build on that legacy and continue to innovate, not just rely on past glories and the famous brand. Nobody doubts that he is a master of the supply chain and of organization, but sadly these skills ‘ just as important to success as design and marketing flair ‘ are perennially underrated by Wall Street analysts. However, they are witnessed in his realignment of Apple’s suppliers, and its increasing control of its own components ‘ both ongoing processes initiated when he was still a very powerful COO, and continued since. They were also seen in his undersung, but significant, restructuring of Apple’s management and business units last year, which hinted at much-needed efforts to adapt to the world of the cloud.
However, Samsung has an iron hand on its supply chain too, and increasingly a tighter organization in its device business, with improved focus on brand, user experience and software. Apple is all about design and Cook needs to show his company can still think out of the box when it comes to form factors and new experiences that users really will crave. Walter Piecyk, head of research at analyst firm BTIG, told Bloomberg: ‘People are concerned about how quickly sales are falling off after the initial product launches and whether the company can deliver new and interesting products to reignite growth.’
But Wall Street is nothing if not confused in its thinking about mobile technology. It calls for innovation and the new breathtaking design that will change the rules as the original iPhone did. Two generations of iPhones which were merely extensions of the previous ones are boring the observers, even though the iPad, though not new in concept, did help to make a formerly niche category into a new way of working.
But it is also loud in demanding that Apple chases market share and the main sources of device growth, in emerging economies. This is a constant source of debate ‘ should Apple dilute its margins and its brand values with cheap and cheerful products or stay in a large premium niche, always wrongfooting its rivals by bringing out a compelling new design for the high end, just as they thought they were catching up? The latter speaks more truly to Apple’s heritage and strengths, but this is not the desktop era when it was content to present the Mac as an exclusive alternative to the PC, yet one that would always have limited market share. Mobile devices are not premium products as PCs still were then, and they move from exciting new form factor to commodity in a matter of a year. So to have any power at all Apple does need to chase the mass market, and that ‘ as Nokia painfully knows ‘ is the only way to maintain the kind of economies of scale and channel relationships that make a mobile device business viable.
Apple has to tread a difficult tightrope here, diversifying its product range for different user bases ‘ which risks confusing the brand message. The key, in our opinion, is not to bring out a commoditized range, but to apply its skills of innovation to a wider range of form factors. There are already signs of this in the iPad strategy, where most of its experiments with multi-model strategies will be carried out, before the core iPhone product is meddled with. The decision which was most risky for Apple was not to launch the iPad mini but to offer cut-price iPad 2s. The latter commoditizes a flagship product, piling on pressure to bring out a new top end model quickly ‘ even before the rumored summer launch date ‘ to keep the gadget snobs with the deep pockets from drifting off to Galaxy Note or the new Sony Xperia tablet. The mini, by contrast, has a different set of components, designed to maintain a good deal of margin, and is really a new product sub-category of its own. By making it slightly bigger, in price and size, than the host of 7-inch Android slates, Apple managed to do what it needs to do to keep its power ‘ reinvent the form factor, and change the rules just slightly.
Cook said he was unfazed by fears that chasing mass markets would hit sales of the high end products. He said on the conference call: ‘In terms of cannibalization, I see cannibalization as a huge opportunity for us. One, our base philosophy is to never fear cannibalization. If we do, someone else will cannibalize it. We know that iPhone has cannibalized some iPod business, we know iPad will cannibalize some Mac, that doesn’t worry us. On iPad in particular, we have the mother of all opportunities because the Windows market is much, much larger than the Mac market. It is clear that it is already cannibalizing some. I believe the tablet market will be larger than the PC market at some point, and I still believe that. The iPad mini could have been a much lesser machine if Apple wanted to protect the iPad. Or the same difference with the iPad to the MacBook. But, no. Cannibalization was accepted. Apple is taking a long view.’
Much of that thinking relies on taking a common design philosophy and then harnessing supply chain flexibility and control, to apply the philosophy to products in multiple segments and form factors. But Apple needs to take just one step further. It really needs a whole new iPhone to chase the huge volumes of China, India and Indonesia ‘ one with the famous user experience tweaked and optimized for constant messaging, BlackBerry-style; for cloud services; and to work well with sub-optimal connections. The entry level smartphone space is where the growth will lie over the next two years, but there is very little real innovation in form factor or user interface here ‘ at least until the new breed of handsets with new operating systems like Firefox OS come out. These threaten to redefine the low end smartphone experience, and that would seize the initiative from the traditional vendors, and potentially place some power back with the carriers, which are the main brands and routes to market in many emerging economies. Of the traditional vendors, Nokia has done the most work to reinvent the entry level smart device, with its Asha product, which crosses over the smart/dumb divide and packs a huge amount of functionality and innovation into a sub-$100 package. If only the Finnish giant had stuck to its guns and developed a low end operating system it would be in a strong position, since it understands the huge emerging economies, where it has long been a leader, far better than its main rivals. But for now it is stuck with an ageing OS, Series 40; a dying one, Symbian; and one that is wholly unsuited to rewriting the entry level mobile rules, Windows Phone. Coupled with its reduced buying power and brand impact, Nokia is not in a position to be the company that brings the new smartphone buyers ‘ in their many millions ‘ a next generation platform rather than a cheap and cheerful version of the models enjoyed in the west. Apple, Samsung, ZTE and the others are being lazy about this challenge, but it is the most important one. Apple showed signs of recognizing the logic when it brought out the mini, which really is a new design in many ways, rather than just a shrunken iPad. And Cook’s abilities put it in a strong position to manipulate its supply chain to support lateral thinking on components and huge cost efficiencies.
The iPad mini’s pricing does not make it an entry level product like a $99 Android slate but it shows that Apple still has some smarts when it comes to defining customer segments and designing products to fit ‘ its key ability during its periods of strength. A really new mass market iPhone and iPad, coupled with a completely different top end iPhone, would dispel the gloom around Apple quickly and refresh the core product range, though it really needs to innovate beyond the existing platforms and show a convincing cloud platform ‘ more important than plugging away at physical TVs or other home media devices. With the tablet in control of all the screens and embedded devices in the home, and an improved set-top box, Apple does not need to make every gadget itself.
In other words, there are signs of change afoot but Apple has a long way to go to recover its reputation as a definer of markets. It also has massive reserves of value, cash and market share to support it through a period of doldrums, so no cause to panic yet. But strong demonstrations of new thinking need to be seen as early as this spring, not waiting for the traditional holiday season party, otherwise the loss of confidence and stock value will go from a surprising to corrosive, and with Samsung in the ascendant, Apple will gradually lose the advantages it trades on above all, its reputation for invincibility and constant innovation.
iPad mini eating its larger brother’s lunch?
The company does not break down its device revenues, but sources at screen supplier Sharp suggest there may indeed be a shift towards the smaller tablet. They claim that the Japanese firm has almost halted production of screens for the 9.7-inch iPad.
Sharp is not the only supplier of iPad displays, but is increasingly central to Apple’s supply chain as the device maker loosens its ties with vendor/arch-rival Samsung. Sharp’s iPad screen production line at its Kameyama plant in central Japan, has fallen to a minimal level, just enough to keep the line running, sources told Reuters. They said there was a gradual slowdown in orders for the larger displays from the end of 2012 as Apple managed its inventory.
Possible reasons for the adjustment include a shift to the iPad mini; seasonal factors; a switch to another supplier such as LG, also an Apple screen vendor; or preparation for a new iPad with a different screen size.
Speculation is centering on the impact of the mini. The other factors seem less convincing – Apple would presumably already have planned for normal seasonal changes after the holiday period; it has been trying to increase its reliance on Sharp, which has overcome early glitches in its iPad display production; and a new iPad is unlikely until mid-year. A change in the balance of iPad sales, however, is supported by other sources. Recently, Macquarie Research forecast that large iPad shipments would fall by almost 40% in the current quarter, compared to Q412, to about 8m units, but total tablet shipments would show a far smaller decline because of the strength of the mini version.
Analaysts at BNP Paribas think the iPad mini will eat into sales of the full-sized iPad, with the mini accounting for 60% of total shipments in the current quarter.
iOS gains share:
Despite market jitters, some statistics still show Apple holding up well against rivals, especially in its strongest market, the US. The latest figures from Kantar Worldpanel ComTech show that, in the fourth quarter of last year, the iPhone won 51.2% of all US smartphone sales, while Android scored 44.8% and Windows Phone just 2.6%. Over the past year, 36% of iOS sales in the US came from users defecting from other platforms and in 2012, 19% of Android customers converted to iOS, up from 9% in 2011. The trend was particularly strong at Verizon, unsurprisingly given that it launched its iPhone far later than AT&T. 59% of the carrier’s iPhone buyers last year had moved from other brands, compared to 15% at AT&T.
On a worldwide basis, Android is still number one, with strong territories including the UK, China, Spain, Australia and Germany, according to the same report. However, ‘clearly the rate of growth it experienced over the past year is beginning to slow as easy wins from first time smartphone buyers begin to reduce,” said Kantar analyst Dominic Sunnebo in a statement.
Windows Phone is gaining ground in Europe, winning almost 6% of UK sales in Q412, up from 2.2% a year earlier, while in Italy its share of sales rose from 2.8% to 13.9%. “It has been far slower than Microsoft would have liked, but Windows Phone is now starting to gain respectable shares in a number of key European countries,” Sunnebo said. “However, its performance in the Chinese and US. markets remains underwhelming. As the two largest smartphone markets in the world, these remain key challenges for Microsoft to overcome during 2013.”