As we went to press, Nokia announced its Q412 and full year figures. The highlights are here, more analysis in the next edition.
Nokia turned in its first profit in seven years and there were hopeful signs for the Lumia flagship range, but the Finnish firm reported a full year loss and, for the first time in its 143-year history, said it would not pay a dividend.
While shareholders reacted with disappoimtment, sending the share price down 5.2% to €3.31 on the announcement, many analysts were pleased with small but clear signs of turnaround, and even with the lack of a cash payout to investors. Two world wars may not have stopped Nokia offering a dividend, but many saw that decision now as a sign of CEO Stephen Elop’s determination to do whatever it takes to get the balance sheet back in order and return to sustainable growth.
Elop has cut over 20,000 jobs in his bid for a leaner, more competitive Nokia focused on three key businesses ‘ the Lumia Windows Phone smartphones; the mass market handset business; and the smallest unit (but consistently the star of the show), the location and commerce division centered on the Navteq mapping platform.
Nokia’s Q412 net income was €202m, or five eurocents a share, compared with a loss of €1.07bn a year earlier. This was far better than expected, with analysts predicting a loss of seven cents. But net sales were down 20% year-on-year to €8.04bn and slightly worse than forecast. For the full year, revenue fell 22% over 2011 to just over €30bn, and made a €2.3bn loss. The results included a $250m quarterly payment from Microsoft for ‘platform support’ (using Windows Phone).
Nokia’s net cash rose to €4.4bn at the end of the fourth quarter and saving €750m of that reserve by forgoing a dividend will ‘ensure strategic flexibility’, the firm said.
Lumia’s sales rose to 4.4m units in the quarter, in a total of 86.3m handsets. The Lumia performance was better than expected, though dwarfed by Apple and Android shipments of course (Apple sold 47.8m iPhones in Q4). Smartphone revenues fell from €10.8bn to €5.4bn for the year and Nokia sold 35m units, half the 77m figure of 2011. Non-smart handsets fell less steeply, from 340m to 301m units.
A fall in total cellphone shipments was expected, given the faster than expected decline of the legacy Symbian platform ‘ one of Elop’s most important miscalculations was his insistence, when Nokia adopted Windows Phone two years ago, that Symbian still had a five-year healthy life ahead. In fact, its sales have fallen off the cliff long before Lumia has been in a position to fill the gap. Only 2.2m Symbian-powered devices sold in the final quarter of 2012. ‘We expect our Symbian devices to account for a significantly smaller portion of our overall Smart Devices volumes in the first quarter 2013 and going forward,’ Nokia said.
This makes the Asha high end featurephone Nokia’s most important product for volumes, and for keeping a placeholder in emerging economies, where the firm is traditionally strong. The risk for Nokia is the time it will take to massage Windows Phone into a sufficiently low end smartphone to fill the Symbian hole in India and elsewhere and we are likely to see Asha being promoted to address that challenge and fend off Android with full smart capabilities.
Worrying signs came from North America, where Nokia sold only 700,000 units, and China, where sales fell 69% year-on-year to 4.6m. The US has always been the company’s weak spot, but it was hoped that Microsoft’s influence on US consumers and carriers would assist in a breakthrough. So far, despite a high profile Lumia launch by AT&T, this has not materialized. ‘US volumes are very weak,’ Mikko Ervasti, an Evli Bank analyst in Helsinki, told Bloomberg. ‘US ramp-up is not going as expected.’
By contrast, Nokia has often been the market leader in China, but is suffering from the decline of Symbian and competition from Android, led by Samsung and local suppliers like Lenovo.
The picture is of a firm which has returned to profit on the back of swingeing cost cuts, and has got its cash situation under control, but now needs to prove it can generate profit from organic revenue growth too. So far, that is not happening, because of the painful transition from Symbian to Windows Phone, the difficulty of making an impact on the Android/iOS axis, and fierce competition at the low end from Asian vendors.
Meanwhile, for the second quarter running, the Nokia Siemens joint venture topped expectations. It turned in a Q4 operating profit of 14.4% of sales, after reporting its first quarterly sales increase and profit since 2011 in Q312.
Elop said in his statement: ‘We are very encouraged that our team’s execution against our business strategy has started to translate into financial results. While the first half of 2012 was difficult for Nokia Group, in Q4 2012 we strengthened our financial position, improved our underlying operating margin in Devices & Services, introduced the Here brand [a cloud-based mapping platform] to expand our mapping and location experiences, and drove record profitability in Nokia Siemens Networks.’