Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 August 2007

AT&T said to be close to deal with Broadcom as Qualcomm suffers two setbacks

AT&T and even Sprint Nextel were rumoured last week to be close to signing patent deals with Broadcom, as Verizon Wireless already has. The speculation reached fever point as Qualcomm failed to obtain a presidential veto of the pro-Broadcom decision by the International Trade Commission (ITC), in the two chipmakers’ precedent-setting patent dispute. Qualcomm also suffered a negative decision and a savage statement from the judge in another dispute with Broadcom, in which the CDMA giant was claiming royalties on the H.264 patent.

Qualcomm still has some appeals pending on the ruling, and is seeking an immediate stay on the ITC-imposed ban on import of all new 3G handset models containing the technologies at issue, which have been ruled to infringe Broadcom power management patents. The ban officially took effect on April 7. Once Verizon backed away from full support of the Qualcomm case, making a direct deal with Broadcom in order to safeguard its supply of advanced cellphones, the chip company’s chances of any reversal of the ITC judgements were fatally compromised, though Sprint Nextel officially remains fully onside.

When the US Trade Representative Susan Schwab, representing the president, announced last Monday that she would not intervene in the ITC case, Broadcom’s general counsel David Dull said in a statement: “This decision strengthens the intellectual property rights of all US companies, not just Broadcom, and sends a clear message to all those who would seek to escape the consequences of their patent infringement.”

The carrier that stands to lose most from an enforcement of the ITC ban is Sprint Nextel. Verizon has made its own arrangements and AT&T, being a GSM/UMTS operator, is less dependent on handsets based on Qualcomm chips. Sprint says it has been testing a workaround for the relevant patents, and still maintains that this is its favored approach ‘ and one that would be a valuable lifeline for Qualcomm. However, it is uncertain how far the third largest cellco will be able to withstand pressure to play the safe game and settle with Broadcom, with the workaround as yet undemonstrated, and with Sprint locked in a race with Verizon Wireless to deploy the most advanced and available services using EV-DO Rev A. Qualcomm has also been developing workarounds with Asian handset partners.

Schwab’s prepared statement indicated that a second carrier had reached a settlement with Broadcom, though this is more likely to be AT&T than Sprint. T-Mobile USA is not urgently affected as it has not yet built out its 3G networks. Schwab also pointed to the possible Qualcomm/Sprint workarounds, arguing that, despite claims that a ban would constrain the wireless industry and deprive public safety of essential equipment, the negative impact would be reduced by potential workarounds, as well as Broadcom’s offer to license its technology on a royalty-free basis for public safety applications.

Sprint claims it has already put its workaround into effect and will continue to import handsets, although Qualcomm has admitted that it would expect Broadcom to raise legal challenges to such solutions and to Sprint imports. Sprint is appealing the ITC ban separately from Qualcomm.

While Qualcomm petitions the federal appeals court, CEO Paul Jacobs issued a statement, saying: “We will pursue all legal and technical options available to us to minimize the impact of the ITC order on consumers, our customers and the entire wireless industry.’

In another setback, Qualcomm acknowledged a federal judge’s finding in San Diego that the company had waived its rights to enforce two patents related to the H.264 video compression standard. The judge said that Qualcomm had deliberately concealed two patents from a standards so was ineligible to sue Broadcom for violation of those patents. The judge also said that Qualcomm had failed to produce thousands of documents relevant to the case during trial. Qualcomm apologized for ‘errors’ but said it would appeal the decision.

Meanwhile, it said recently that it needs to wait for the outcome of ongoing legal actions and other decisions before gaining a clearer view on its cross-licensing negotiations with Nokia. ‘Looking forward regarding Nokia, there are some important cases that will be heard this year,’ said Qualcomm president Steve Altmann in the recent quarterly results call. ‘In the arbitration filed by Nokia in 2005, we expect a decision in the coming weeks. In September, the first of our patent infringement cases against Nokia’s GSM products begins in Germany, followed by the UK case in November. Nokia’s case in Germany alleging patent exhaustion as a bar to our infringement claims against Nokia’s GSM products likely will be significantly delayed. The trial of a similar case brought by Nokia in the Netherlands is scheduled to begin in September. In addition, the stay of our action against Nokia at the ITC has been lifted and a trial will take place in September of this year.’