Now that the US 700MHz picture is becoming clearer, with the FCC publishing rules for the upcoming auction of this valuble mobile spectrum, the likely bidders are stepping up pressure on vendors to have suitable equipment ready when licenses are awarded early next year. Some operators expect to be starting to build networks as early as the start of 2009.
‘One of the things I lose sleep over is whether the technology roadmaps will slip, and I will have to deploy an interim solution before one of these 4G technologies is ready,” Stagg Newman, CTO at Frontline Wireless, said in an interview with EETimes. Frontline hopes to gain a license under a public-private initiative with public safety interests.
The WiMAX community is, predictably, being the most vocal about the new spectrum, although 700MHz is not an official WiMAX Forum profile. Some vendors such as SOMA Networks already focus on this band, and regardless of Forum rules, majors like Intel regard the spectrum ‘ especially since the FCC insisted on a degree of open access in at least one-third of it ‘ as a huge opportunity to prove the credentials of all-IP WiMAX as a fully mobile technology in frequencies that will show it off to its best advantage.
WiMAX’s major advantage, especially over the LTE option, is the relatively advanced progress of its roadmap, but this makes it vital that it does not let the lead slip ‘ and that WiMAX friendly providers succeed in gaining some of the licenses, against the deep pockets and savvy auction techniques of the major carriers. This could lead to one or more internet majors bidding directly for licenses ‘ Google has, of course, mooted this possibility, and Intel may also be a contender, both companies aiming to lease their rights to providers that will support their preferred technology and/or model, but might not otherwise be able to afford the licenses. A variation on this theme comes from another likely bidder, NextWave Wireless, whose major acquisitions of AWS and 2.5GHz licenses are also geared to wholesaling to providers that will support its technology ‘ inits case, its WiMAX-like system on chip platforms and ‘end-to-end solution’ from spectrum to chips. And the existing WiMAX-friendly operators may well aim to increase their spectrum holdings with licenses that are well suited to rural coverage and mobility ‘ notably Sprint Nextel and its increasingly complicated set of partners, including Clearwire and the leading cablecos, which have their own license acquisition venture, SpectrumCo, too.
All these potential spectrum holders will be looking for network options that will be sufficiently developed by the trial phase in mid-2008 to support their business models. Otherwise they will be at a severe disadvantage to Verizon Wireless and AT&T Mobility, regardless of FCC liberalization or the manoeuvrings of the internet players. These two giants will also be weighing up their technology choices, assuming they bid in a big way for 700MHz licenses. AT&T has shown no real indication of moving away from its HSPA strategy, but will be waiting until 2010 at the earliest for any form of LTE for new frequencies. Since it is also forging ahead more rapidly than its rivals into all-IP services and IMS, it could look to a multi-network strategy that could encompass any IP network, including WiMAX.
Verizon’s choices will be both more simple and more significant for the future balance of power in the industry. The US’s second largest cellco has been the most avid supporter of CDMA as a future, as well as current, platform and in return gained significant influence over the shape of its development by Qualcomm and 3GPP2. As it, too, moves to all-IP, it could implement a parallel technology in new spectrum that it might acquire, especially if it sees this approach reaping dividends for its nearest CDMA-based rival, Sprint Nextel. Any such decision could sound the death knell for the future, OFDM-based version of CDMA2000, Ultra Mobile Broadband (UMB), and Verizon’s recent backing away from supporting Qualcomm in its legal battle with Broadcom may hint at some distance between the two close allies. In that event, Qualcomm’s own other option would be to acquire spectrum itself, to build a UMB-based network for lease to other carriers, as it has already done in another portion of 700MHz, using its MediaFLO mobile television system.
Qualcomm says that adapting current CDMA technologies, and UMB, for 700MHz is a ‘high priority’ and chips will ship early next year. It will add 700MHz to quad band EV-DO Rev A and Rev B chipsets in 2008, and UMB by June 2009, it claims. WiMAX companies are engaged in similar attempts, but all the players will have a tough job delivering systems in time that will live up to carriers’ high expectations of 700MHz. This is a difficult band because of its constrained capacity, with developers being forced to separate transmit and receive channels by as little as 12MHz in some cases, as well as supporting wider channels than are common in other cellular systems. Developers will also have to take into account the relatively complex requirements of some operators, particularly given the rules that mandate public safety applications in parts of the band.