Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 April 2020

Auction delays will disrupt but not derail 5G roll-out plans

Among the delaying factors which the COVID-19 crisis is imposing on 5G, as well as restricted availability of labour and general investor nervousness, are delayed standards processes and auctions. The former may not make significant difference, if the 3GPP sticks to its new timetable, just three months later than the original one. Most operators have not yet deployed all the elements of current standards, notably the Release 15 5G core.

The impact of delayed auctions will depend on the country and the band. In markets where 3.5 GHz spectrum has already been awarded, operators have enough to be going on with in terms of 5G roll-out. Some of the sub-GHz licences that are due to be auctioned this year would not be used for commercial 5G for another year or two – because they still have to be vacated by broadcast incumbents in some cases, or because most MNOs will rely on 4G for their main coverage network for some time to come.

The auction delay which is least likely to cause problems for operators is India’s. The operators have been begging the regulator, TRAI, to postpone the sale, as well as to reduce high reserve prices. They have recently been hit by a perfect storm of a price war, sparked by new entrant Reliance Jio; the cost of 4G expansion; huge court-imposed fines; and rising debt mountains. This means they are in no financial position to invest heavily in 5G spectrum, let alone build it out soon.

They do not have a long breathing space – TRAI and the Ministry of Telecom say the auction, originally planned for this month, will not now proceed before August. The delay may be extended however, especially as it is not entirely down to COVID-19, but also to the precarious financial position of two of the top three operators – Bharti Airtel and Vodafone Idea, both of which have threatened to sit out the auction if the dates and reserve prices were not changed (Vodafone has even warned it might exit India completely).

The auction, when it happens, will offer a total of 8,300 MHz of 4G and 5G spectrum, including 4G options in the 700 MHz, 800 MHz, 900 MHz, 1.8 GHz, 2.1 GHz, 2.3 GHz and 2.5 GHz bands, and 5G spectrum in the 3.3-3.6 GHz range.

In Europe, auction delays have been announced in a number of countries, including Austria, Spain, Portugal and France.

Austria’s Telekom-Control Commission (RTR) has postponed the country’s second 5G auction, scheduled for this month, because of federal restrictions put in place amid the  pandemic. The sale was to have included spectrum in the 700 MHz, 1.5 GHz and 2.1 GHz bands.

RTR said that it was too early to set a new date, but expects this to be some time in 2020. It said it did not expect the delay to affect 5G build-out since operators already have plentiful capacity after the earlier 3.5 GHz auction.

Spain has also put off its 700 MHz auction from June 30 to an unspecified new date, which will depend on when current emergency measures, in one of the worst-hit nations by the coronavirus, are lifted.

Neighboring Portugal’s auction of 700 MHz, 2.6 GHz and 3.6 GHz spectrum, planned for a date between April and June, was suspended by the National Communications Authority (Anacom), in response to pressure from major operators amid the unpredictability of the coronavirus situation.

France’s regulator, ARCEP, has also delayed an April auction until an unspecified new date. The sale would have included 310 MHz of spectrum in the 3.4-3.8 GHz band in four blocks of 50 MHz, with the remainder in blocks of 10 MHz each. The government had hoped to raise at least €2.17bn ($2.38bn) from the sale, with the four MNOs –

Orange, SFR, Iliad and Bouygues – all expected to bid.

Even in the USA, the FCC has pushed back the auction of priority access licences in the 3.5 GHz CBRS band, from June until July 23.

Meanwhile, Vodafone UK is taking a bolder approach with its government than merely asking for a deferment of auctions. Instead, it has written to the government asking it cancel the next auction – which has already been put on hold temporarily – altogether and release the spectrum at its reserve price. This, it argues, would allow operators to bolster their 5G networks more quickly, while removing the uncertainty about the prices they should pay at auction, given the uncertain effect the pandemic will have on the economy.

A few auctions have gone ahead in recent weeks. Hungary’s 5G spectrum sale raised almost twice what was expected, generating US$399m from Vodafone, Magyar Telekom and Telenor.