The smart building mantra has been circulating for a generation now but major constructors are still often failing to provide the basic connectivity infrastructure to support the relevant processes. Partly as a result, smart building services, particularly security, lighting and HVAC (heating, ventilation and air conditioning), have emerged as unconnected siloes employing separate protocols with their own wired or wireless communication links.
Buildings in turn have disjointed connectivity, often with fiber up the risers, along with copper whose life is continually extended by ever more sophisticated interference mitigation techniques. Multiple wireless protocols such as Zigbee and Z-Wave, each optimized for particular use cases, coexist side-by-side without communicating, like ships in the night.
But under the auspices of 5G, constructors have an opportunity to install unified infrastructure fit for emerging smart home applications that can benefit from synchronization and integration at both the physical and application layer. It is best to regard 5G here as not just the next round of cellular transmission technologies but as a more complete blueprint for future communications infrastructure at the access level.
Of course, the WiFi community will have something to say about that, and indeed, it is more correct to say that the future of connectivity in and around buildings will revolve around WiFi and cellular in tandem, as they migrate respectively to WiFi 6 and 5G. But more than that, these new infrastructures will also encourage higher data and application level integration around common application programming interfaces (APIs) and other standards.
One key initiative springing to mind here is Project Haystack, an open source program to develop common structures and exchange mechanisms for data generated by IoT services in buildings, cities and manufacturing plants. Factory automation, energy control, HVAC and smart lighting are focal points of Haystack.
The move towards common building infrastructures has been compromised by proliferation in wireless protocols especially, but this has been driven by individual use cases having different requirements, as well as natural competition between alternative technologies. So alongside the demand for higher capacities and bit rates demanded by high definition video, as well as ultra-low latencies for interactive conferencing and other time-critical processes, there are also proliferating use cases for low bandwidth and low power applications.
This means there will be a continuing need for wireless transmission at different bit rates and power levels, but this does not necessarily mean having to support diverse and incompatible protocols. Indeed, the trend is towards unification around 5G and WiFi as those two themselves cater for more diverse requirements within their increasingly diverse standards sets. This is especially the case for 5G as it caters more for low power and also indoor requirements. In all cases there is a three-way trade-off between power, bit rate and range.
It is worth briefly then considering the technologies and standards that have evolved for low power radio communications. The first two to gain much traction, emerging over 20 years ago in the late 1990s, were Zigbee (IEEE 802.15.4) and Z-Wave from Danish firm Zensys, acquired in 2008 by Sigma Design, a maker of systems-on-chip for media and smart home devices. Both were beacons for the early IoT, establishing healthy niches in the industrial sector especially for communication between hubs, sensors, lighting, locks and other security devices. But neither ever fulfilled their full early promise to become major wireless standards like WiFi, and have somewhat withered on the vine in terms of new growth as other more modern protocols have emerged.
Zigbee is still knocking around, while Z-Wave’s status as a modestly successful protocol was confirmed by Sigma Designs’ selling it to Silicon Labs for $240m early in 2018 (though at the same time going into liquidation). While Z-Wave is hovering around the unlicensed 900 MHz band reserved for scientific and industrial processes, and has avoided frequencies used by other more popular wireless technologies, Zigbee suffered from overlapping with WiFi’s lower 2.4 GHz range and tended to come off second best whenever interference had not been properly mitigated.
Both Zigbee and Z-Wave are short range as well as low power and low bit rate. More recent additions in this zone are Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) and Near Field Communications (NFC), which have distinct use cases. BLE is really a more advanced successor to classic Bluetooth, providing comparable bit rate and range at reduced power consumption. It operates at 1Mbps with potential to reach 3Mbps with an enhancement, far higher than Zigbee at 250Kbps or Z-Wave at up to 40Kbps. But BLE operates in the 2.4 GHz frequency range, so also suffers from potential interference problems with WiFi.
NFC operates at very low distances for secure transmissions, for example between active power devices like access control card readers and static devices like smart cards. As such, NFC operates at the ultra-low frequencies of 13.6 MHz, so is not part of the 5G/WiFi discussion, but of course has a role to play in buildings for secure access control.
One other outlier worth mentioning because of its growing role in smart buildings is LiFi, which uses light for carrying data. This has been galvanized by the rapid progress in LED light technology, allowing high speed data communication at low power between devices in a room or open area of a building, although it does not always require direct line of sight because it can exploit optical reflections off objects.
LiFi is increasingly being considered part of the 5G stable because of its potential for extending cellular connectivity in dense urban environments where line of sight can actually become a cause of interference for wireless RF signals. With a bit rate of 8Gbps and ability to operate even when lights are almost too dim to be visible to the human eye, LiFi has a major role to play both within buildings and in cities for deployment with smart lighting. LiFi also has the advantage of not contending with WiFi and 5G for spectrum, so the bandwidth it provides is entirely additive.
Meanwhile, low power wide area (LPWA) protocols have evolved in parallel, with the main contenders being LoRa, Sigfox and NB-IoT. These all enable low power, low bandwidth communications, via a star topology, mostly operating at frequencies below 1 GHz that vary by region, an exception being one of the three bands for NB-IoT in Europe at 1.8 GHz, and a new LoRa implementation in 2.4 GHz.
5G has not yet encroached on this territory as the 5G successors to the 4G LPWAN standards are not yet finalized. In the meantime, the LPWAN technologies, especially LoRA and the LTE standards (NB-IoT and LTE-M), have had time to dig in and will be hard to dislodge in the short term. This is a key point because 5G will not quickly sweep away all existing technologies in buildings and instead will need to coexist with LPWANs options, integrating with them so they can be considered part of the same larger technology set.
Prospects of LoRA surviving as a distinct standard within a larger 5G stable are also enhanced by its take-up among other operators or service providers beyond the big MNOs, including cable companies, TV broadcasters, ISPs and some fixed-line telcos. For many of these, LoRA has become a legacy technology for large scale IoT deployment and that has increasingly penetrated indoors. The same goes for many private enterprise deployments, for which the appeal of LoRa has been increased by its combination of range and acceptable indoor performance, with superior ability to penetrate thick concrete walls compared to WiFi, and cellular.
This comes back to the 5G ambition to cover all use cases, frequency ranges and levels of power and bit rate. It will seek to address not just ever-increasing demand for high data rates but also greater resilience and ubiquitous coverage indoors. In the indoor environment in particular, expectations have risen significantly in the past few years in all three key areas – bit rate, range and power consumption.
In the 3G and 4G eras, a single radio transmission at a given frequency had to meet indoor requirements from outside, leading to a rising chorus of complaints over availability and quality for voice calls as well as data – which helped ensure WiFi’s adoption in homes and offices. In later 4G, and now 5G, generations, there is a rising tendency to deploy separate indoor networks in their own frequencies, using small cells or distributed antenna systems (DAS).
DAS was first considered mainly for large venues where public WiFi was the alternative, such as airports, large hotels, shopping malls, campuses and stadiums. In those environments, 5G DAS may sometimes evolve to displace WiFi and meet most communication requirements, but for smaller premises, including many lower tier enterprises and homes, 5G will coexist with WiFi.
Indoor coverage has been an increasing focus of the major 5G-related standards initiatives, especially those driven by operators such as the O-RAN Alliance, whose primary objective is modernizing the RAN architecture so that it can embrace software defined networking and virtualization, achieving agility and efficiency improvements through use of commodity hardware.
For indoor coverage, cellular operators are meeting the same challenges that fixed line broadband providers face with WiFi – meeting demands for reliable and ubiquitous coverage at very high bit rates. As with WiFi, this is creating demand for new network design and management tools that optimize both indoor configuration and interaction with the outdoor infrastructure. These new tools need to handle increasingly dense urban networks both indoors and outdoors, while meeting at the same time demands for high bit rate and low power communications, even if the latter is met by the likes of LoRA.
The challenge is being addressed simply because around 80% of all mobile data is now consumed indoors, whether inside the home or in public locations. Yet probably no more than 3% of buildings have dedicated indoor cellular networks, and far lower than that in homes. Operators need to take this challenge in hand as they roll out 5G.
If they meet this challenge, one sector where 5G has perhaps greatest scope for establishing more ubiquitous indoor/outdoor connectivity is in factory automation and process control. Such environments often comprise multiple buildings on a large site and progress in Industrial IoT (IIoT) has, as a result, been held back by lack of integration between indoors and outdoors for the higher performing processes.
This is one focus of the 5G NR Standalone version, which eschews the need for 4G control technology and as a result enables lower latencies and in some cases higher bit rates. This will provide improved support for high performance industrial use cases such as machine control, robots and unmanned vehicles, as well as for interconnecting subsystems such as vision that still require low latency between them. The aim is to displace existing disjointed WiFi networks at such sites where latency is a choke point, so there is contention rather than cooperation.