Huawei has been straining at the leash to establish its credentials as a responsible and trustworthy maker of 5G infrastructure, a world leader in mobile security. With this objective the company has just staged a webinar entitled 5G Security – A Shared Responsibility. China was not mentioned even in the Q&A afterwards, yet was the elephant in the room underlining the urgency of the messaging from Huawei’s perspective, given the huge efforts on the part of the US to dissuade other governments from letting the company into their 5G networks.
The success of such warnings will rest on judgements over China’s future intentions and actions rather than assessment of Huawei’s security credentials, which judging from the webinar are impeccable.
The company’s CTO Paul Scanlan was keen to stress that its leading 5G technology and IT personnel were in constant contact with their counterparts at the other major manufacturers in the sectors – Ericsson, Nokia and China’s own ZTE in particular – with all pulling together and trusting one another on the security front. He did not indicate whether this close relationship had been compromised at all by the current US/China trade-off, but US hostility has been, if anything, amplified by the coronavirus crisis, which was itself another elephant in the room during the webinar.
The focus was on 5G’s enhanced security compared with 4G’s, and the extent to which it is sufficient to counter the expanded threat landscape. The latter is being driven especially by the vast growth in IoT devices, being connected at the rate of at least a million a day globally. Huawei’s conclusion is that 5G networks will be more secure, but only with concerted efforts across the whole ecosystem from governments down through operators, regulators and infrastructure makers to end users and application developers. This caveat was made in the context of the observation that could equally well have been made 30 years ago – that the biggest threat vectors were users themselves and, in the case of 5G, their apps.
As Scanlan noted, apps can readily download bits of malware or Trojans embedded in their code, no matter what firewall protections are employed. The challenge then is to identify and mitigate or snuffle out any resulting threats. Machine learning will play a role by being trained on what is normal in the hope that it will quickly identify any unusual patterns of traffic or activity that indicate a breach is emerging.
The underlying message from Huawei then was that 5G cannot solve all the world’s security problems, but can at least keep its own house in order by addressing threats associated with the new capabilities it brings and use cases it enables. As one example, Huawei’s chief security officer (CSO), Andy Purdy, highlighted the improved roaming encryption, which makes it much harder to eavesdrop user identity and location data from base stations. Under 4G, when handsets connect to base stations the user’s identity is authenticated but without encrypting that data. Subsequent voice or text data is encrypted in 4G, but it has meanwhile been possible to obtain the user’s identity and location.
5G steps up from 128-bit to 256-bit encryption, which enhances protection against direct attacks on that, but more significantly encrypts the user’s identity and location, while also transmitting all that end-to-end from device to the core through the base station via SSL (Secure Socket Layer) tunnels. This almost eliminates the base station vulnerability and also, as Scanlan was happy to note, means even the equipment manufacturer cannot see the data. The implication was that Huawei could not furnish that data to the Chinese government even if it wanted to, once the equipment had been deployed in the field, with only the operator having visibility.
Huawei also highlighted the security associated with slicing, which is new with 5G to divide a given network into multiple logical partitions serving different use cases or services. A key security challenge there is to ensure isolation of each slice such that compromise of one does not expose others. Huawei indicated how this has been addressed by breaking down each slice into each domain it handles, such as client devices, the access network, backhaul and core network, along with the holistic whole including the links between them.
Huawei did enough in the webinar to convince any doubters over its security commitment, but unfortunately can do little to win over those wary over putative future actions by the Chinese government. The problem for Huawei is that absence of evidence, in this case that its relationship with the Chinese government is a threat, is not evidence of its future absence.