When new spectrum at low frequencies becomes available, the world gets excited about new mobile broadband applications like mobile television, but the users to benefit most immediately are often those in rural areas, waiting for a wireless technology sufficiently efficient to bring them basic mobile data coverage or simple fixed broadband. So while the major players talk LTE and television in the wake of the US 700MHz auction, some smaller cellcos at least plan to deliver what was initially one of the key goals of the spectrum sale, improved rural access ‘ until this was swept aside by a flood of Google talk about open access. Similarly, the WiMAX community talks, in its public statements, endlessly about mobile broadband and 4G, but the near term usefulness of the technology is demonstrated most effectively by an innovative roll-out (albeit in a non-standard profile) in the 450MHz band in India.
Low frequencies support large cell sizes and so allow operators to cover large, sparsely populated areas more cost effectively than the usual cellular frequencies (though they cause all kinds of difficulties of interference in urban areas). So despite the focus on 4G, there are still high hopes that the major 700MHz license winners will turn some of their spectrum to the more mundane, but still essential, task of improving the US’ dismal record for broadband availability in rural areas. When the FCC was devising its auction rules, it was under heavy pressure to set some bandwidth aside specifically for this purpose, perhaps by offering it exclusively, or at reduced cost, to rural operators. This campaign was derailed by the open access and other debates, but some rural specialists did manage to gain spectrum anyway, and one of the largest, CenturyTel, is already talking up its plans for underserved areas.
The operator has not specified the technology it will use, but plans to use its new licenses to create a broadband wireless overlay network feeding less densely populated areas in its existing wireline footprint ‘ once its spectrum is cleared of its existing incumbents, the TV broadcasters, which should happen next year.
‘While it is too early to discuss financial and operational details, we are acquiring spectrum that overlaps our core ILEC and fiber transport networks,’ CEO Glen Post said in a statement. ‘This should enable us to utilize our existing operations, including our current distribution and technical support infrastructure, to cost effectively deploy wireless services, both in our existing markets and in selective contiguous markets, where we believe profitable growth is achievable.’
This is a reversal of CenturyTel’s exit from wireless in 2002, when it sold this side of its business to Alltel, although the former did subsequently embark on an MVNO to offer own-branded voice services, using AT&T’s network.
It seems that WiMAX would be the logical choice for the operator, since it has no plans to become a conventional mobile carrier, but rather to fill gaps in its network and support nomadic usage with a primarily fixed wireless model. WiMAX is well tested in such scenarios and most early deployments have focused on broadband to the home or small business, rather than the mobile applications that hit the headlines. Although 700MHz is not an official Forum profile as yet, there are several vendors that offer equipment built to the WiMAX standards in this frequency, including SOMA Networks, Telsima and Airspan.
CenturyTel paid $149m for A Block and B Block metro and economic area licenses covering roughly 53% of the operator’s local exchange territories in the West, Midwest and South (most of its coverage in Arkansas, Louisiana, Ohio and Montana as well as portions of its territories in seven other states). While AT&T and Verizon paid premiums for licenses in major metro markets, CenturyTel paid a lower average of 70 cents per MHz per pop for its rural spectrum.
Whatever its fate against LTE in the truly mobile broadband market, WiMAX is proving its viability rapidly in the fixed and nomadic wireless segment, where there is huge demand, with basic access and VoIP set to drive the bulk of operator investment for several years in most of the major growth territories, such as the Indian subcontinent, parts of Africa and south east Asia. A recent report from the World Economic Forum highlights WiMAX’ strength in this respect, singling out the technology as continuing to “leapfrog past copper wire” in developing countries.
“In the context of having to apportion chunks of finite spectrum, WiMAX is appealing because it holds the promise of increased sharing,” says the report, compiled by French business institute Insead. “Rural connectivity is promised as long as power supply is available, PCs are given, local languages are used in developing content and people are provided with training in using PCs.”
The WEF particularly pointed out deployments in India and the Wateen/Warid/Motorola project in Pakistan, which could expand over 17 countries, mainly in the MEA region. One vendor that is very active in India is Telsima, which is based there and in Slovenia as well as the US, and the company last week demonstrated its WiMAX technology operating over 50 kilometer distances in fixed mode, in the 450MHz band. Regardless of the profiles supported by official Forum certification, smaller vendors like Telsima, which sell heavily to traditional broadband wireless access and rural operators, are keen to explore the potential of any available frequency, including unlicensed or lightly licensed options often ignored by the majors.
Telsima’s demonstration took place in a 3MHz channel, delivering 6Mbps throughput over 50 kilometers, under near-line of sight conditions. It was carried out in Slovenia, aiming to spark commercial interest in using sub-1GHz frequencies (450MHz is widely available in eastern European countries, but to date CDMA450 has been the main technology option, supporting lower data rates than WiMAX. 450MHz versions of NextWave’s TD-CDMA, Qualcomm’s Flash-OFDM and even UMTS have also targeted this space at various points.)
Burcak Beser, chief technology officer of Telsima, said: ‘These lower frequencies perform better in wooded and hilly environments because of their superior wave propagation characteristics enabling large sectors and wave diffraction around interfering objects such as hills and buildings. Rural areas in global markets, where the subscriber density is lower, are therefore more efficiently served using these sub-GHz frequencies. Of particular significance in our system demonstration is the excellent connection quality; sustaining modulation rates of 64QAM in the downlink and 16QAM in the uplink in a WiMAX system configuration suitable for wireline replacement voice quality services.’