Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 April 2008

Microsoft-Murdoch-Yahoo combination could be the face of the future

The Microsoft-Yahoo takeover bid saga continues to twist and turn, with Google turning every development to its own advantage. The outcome will help to shape the internet landscape in the mobile world as well as everywhere else, and so the possible intervention of Rupert Murdoch’s giant media group News Corp, owner of MySpace, presents interesting new possibilities. Microsoft and Murdoch are said to be in talks about jointly bidding for Yahoo, in order to make the deal more attractive to the internet company’s board, which has so far rejected the $44bn-plus offer, leading Microsoft to threaten to go straight to shareholders, initiating a hostile takeover attempt. However, the weekend saw reports that Yahoo was on the verge of an alternative merger deal with fellow internet portal AOL, part of Time Warner.

Whether or not the Microsoft-Murdoch alliance becomes a reality, such partnerships ‘ between software houses, internet portals and media groups ‘ will become more and more common, especially in the mobile world, where the lines between content, applications and network delivery are very blurred, and all three interest groups are fighting for the best position in the value chain, going through many of the debates that the PC internet market held in the wake of the dotcom boom and bust.

So a Yahoo-Microsoft-News Corp partnering might, in theory at least, bring complementary strengths and create a truly modern powerhouse that would be hard to challenge in the mobile web, reflecting as it would all the key aspects of the emerging business model. It would also remove a possible Yahoo escape route ‘ in February, Yahoo was reported as negotiating with News Corp to combine MySpace and other Murdoch online properties in return for a 20% stake in the enlarged Yahoo.

By contrast, a merger between Yahoo and AOL looks like the tying together of two tired and injured lions. The former has a strong streak of innovation in the mobile internet world, but needs greater resources and creative thinking to reap the full rewards of this against the challenge of Google (and Nokia, though we still think Nokia is a logical partner, not enemy, for Yahoo). AOL, meanwhile, has been late and hesitant in addressing the mobile world, and is suffering huge challenges in its traditional PC territory, which would not bode well for its ability to be the fire that sets Yahoo alight once more.

According to Wall Street reports, the proposed AOL-Yahoo deal would see AOL parent Time Warner paying a large wad of cash for a 20% stake in the combined entity. Such a transaction would value AOL at $10bn and would exclude its declining ISP activities. Yahoo would then use the Time Warner cash to buy back millions of its own shares in the mid-$30 range, to bolster its holdings and boost stock prices.

If this deal is formally proposed, it will provide shareholders with an alternative to Microsoft and strengthen the Yahoo board’s defences. The company has already built one wall against Microsoft, announcing last week a pact to outsource at least some of its web search advertising operations to Google. Google, almost certainly prevented by antitrust considerations from bidding for Yahoo itself, has however put various cats among assorted pigeons since Microsoft made its initial offer in February, and has reportedly suggested a series of ways to support Yahoo and so protect its independence (including helping finance counter-bids) ‘ thus preventing the Google nightmare of facing a combination of its two largest internet portal and online advertising rivals, and of strengthening its arch-enemy Microsoft overall.

As regards the advertising outsourcing agreement, this will go through various trials to see whether it increases Yahoo’s revenue ‘ and if so, this would demonstrate the board’s contention that Microsoft’s bid is underestimating the company’s value, especially in terms of its potential growth. The first test is scheduled to run for two weeks over about 3% of requests to Yahoo’s main US search engine. Last month, Yahoo admitted Google search ads generated more than 60% than its own on average. Yahoo would then focus on its more profitable display ads, leaving some or all the search ads to its rival.

Microsoft reacted with the specter of antitrust probes. ‘Any definitive agreement between Yahoo and Google would consolidate over 90% of the search advertising market in Google’s hands,’ it said in a statement.

Meanwhile, with any News Corp-Microsoft deal still vague on detail, Yahoo was continuing with business as usual, seeking to reinforce its arguments about its own growth potential and strong strategic focus. It has agreed to acquire web analytics software developer Tensa for an undisclosed sum, another in a series of purchases to bolster online advertising, this one targeted at supporting online marketing campaigns across its various networks, including an initial trial with 150,000 smaller businesses.