Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 November 2005

Beset by cablecos and ISPs, should Bell operators split networks and services?

History will look back on the first week of November 2005 as a pivotal one for US telecoms. The mergers of Verizon with MCI, and SBC with AT&T, were finally approved by the FCC, and Sprint Nextel formalized its long awaited alliance with four major cable operators, the three transactions signalling a major consolidation of power around the two largest Bell operators and Sprint, the company that is increasingly looking set to be their nemesis. The Bellcos – like incumbents everywhere, and despite an FCC that seems increasingly in favour of a telco-cable duopoly – are under huge pressure and need to figure out a way to use more than just their market weight to stay ahead. In a world of virtual operators and free IP-based services, they need to ensure that their key differentiator ‘ their ownership of infrastructure ‘ is put at the heart of the business model as it has been at Sprint Nextel.

While control of the wired and wireless pipes becomes concentrated in the hands of a few, the opportunity to compete against the Bell operators ‘ Verizon, SBC, BellSouth and Qwest – at the access end of the network is unprecedented. The attack on the incumbents is many pronged, (with WiMAX an almost universal factor) – from the agreement that Sprint and the cablecos would use the former’s planned broadband wireless network to offer an alternative access system; to the rising involvement of competitive service providers such as Earthlink in metrozone schemes; to the prospect of internet companies like Google also building their own networks. Most anarchic of all is the Microsoft response to all that, the concept of an entirely carrier-free spontaneous network based on mesh connections between Wi-Fi device users.

It is clear that, even with the broadband explosion, a territory can only support so many physical networks profitably, especially as access becomes a basic requirement for life rather than a luxury in the developed economies. In some ways Google’s apparent desire to own its own infrastructure is an old fashioned strategy, though it may save it from some fees payable to the telcos. Service provision and network ownership will become more and more separated, with consumers increasingly intolerant of any attempt to restrict their choice of which services they can use on their IP networks and devices. But the freedom to roam that has characterized the internet has a far more savage effect when implemented on the wireless networks, because of the physical limitations on their capacity. A company that has invested hugely in creating a network, whether using 3.5G technologies or WiMAX, now faces the prospect of that network being swamped with traffic that generates no revenue to the carrier beyond a flat monthly charge, which itself will come under increasing downward price pressure.

So there are two stark choices for a major network owner, whether a multinetwork company like SBC or a wireless-only giant like Vodafone. One is to tear down the walls around the garden, but make that garden so attractive, through ease of use and range of services and content, that users choose to linger anyway, even at additional cost. This is the basic approach of Vodafone Live! But the greatest risk to that model is that it can be emulated by the MVNOs (Mobile Virtual Network Operators), which may prove equally successful at creating a unique and appealing customer experience, but only have to lease their network capacity rather than building it.

The second choice is to become a carrier’s carrier like the backbone providers of the wired internet. A highly logical argument can be made for Sprint Nextel to do just that, moving out of end user, branded services and filling its networks to capacity through its MVNO partners. As in other utility sectors such as transportation, the owner of the network and the service operator become separate entities with completely different models and competitive pressures.

Even without taking that step, network owners know they must find a way to generate revenue from their basic asset, their infrastructure, independently of their own services business. Some of the most telling comments from a telecoms CEO in recent months came from SBC’s Ed Whitacre last week, in an interview with Business Week. He knows that ownership of pipes, as well as coverage achieved with those broadband lines, is the real differentiator that Bellcos and cable operators have against new challengers ‘ even if the access portion of those pipes will start to lose some value as wireless options become more practical for alternative providers to create their own networks. But at the backhaul, the power lies with the large network owners, and the Bell operators are ensuring that they concentrate most of that power in their own hands, through the new mega-mergers.

In the internet model, Whitacre believes competition is ‘still about scale and scope. It’s about owning the assets that connect customers. The assets that probably can’t be duplicated except maybe by the cable companies. We have that, Verizon has that, BellSouth has some of that. The cable companies have it.’

He acknowledges the threat from Verizon in wireless and from cablecos across the whole SBC business, but refuses to recognize the danger from the internet plays ‘ Google, Vonage, MSN and so on. His aggressive stance is that those service providers will have to start paying fees to the network owners to deliver their offerings. ‘How do you think they’re going to get to customers? Through a broadband pipe. Cable companies have them. We have them. Now what they would like to do is use my pipes free, but I ain’t going to let them do that because we have spent this capital and we have to have a return on it. So there’s going to have to be some mechanism for these people who use these pipes to pay for the portion they’re using.’

In other words, the Bell operators need to focus their efforts on their cable competitors, while recognizing that a cable-telco monopoly is better for them than a truly open internet services market where the war is on many fronts and often against agile new business models. They need to maximize revenues from their pipes and make it unattractive for any challengers to bypass those pipes using platforms such as metro mesh or WiMAX. This makes ownership of the backhaul networks even more important since all the new networks will need to reach a point of presence at some point and, beyond a certain distance, and barring major new infrastructure build-out, that will mean paying a fee to a telco. Access networks may be up for grabs, but the Bellcos can ensure that they control the long lines ‘ hence the purchases of MCI and AT&T, moves that will increasingly squeeze out independent fiber owners that might have provided a fair market option for new access providers.

Ownership of infrastructure has become essential for the majors as demand for bandwidth explodes. In the world of the big internet pipes, consolidation is setting in among the wholesalers ‘ Level 3 is buying Wiltel in the US for instance ‘ as the big bandwidth consumers increasingly try to become self sufficient. So Verizon now has UUNet/MCI, SBC has AT&T, while BellSouth recently formed a long lines alliance with Sprint Nextel. Meanwhile, others are trying to enter the network ownership game as well, with Qwest expanding, Google looking to create a network and Comcast also talking about building a ‘private internet’.

All this goes to the perpetual dilemma of telecoms ‘ why should a few companies bear the huge burden of creating a network capable of carrying the services end users demand, and be forced to let others use that network freely to snatch revenues? If the ability to access those services openly is perceived as a basic right of the citizen, should the delivery systems not be provided by public authorities, like roads, even if private services can run on top of them? This, of course, is the logical extension of the thinking behind the municipal broadband initiatives in the US and elsewhere, and calls in countries such as the UK for at least some 3G spectrum to be reserved for public sector ownership.

But these are not the most immediate threat to the Bell operators, nor will any new approach to infrastructure be able, in any short timescale, to challenge the incumbents’s massive network build-outs. The threat to consumer service revenues from internet providers offering VoIP and other flat rate, well price options is real but the Bell companies have the advantage of time on their side, thanks to their huge market share, the lethargy of the consumer public and their ability to bundle different services, a key factor in customer attraction and retention. Far more urgent is the threat from the cablecos, which have many of the same advantages and are further ahead, of course, with adding television to their triple plays than the Bells’ fledgling IPTV plans allow.

The Bellcos need to move aggressively, now that Sprint Nextel has become the agent enabling their largest challengers for the broadband triple play market, the cable operators, to go on the warpath. The long awaited collective MVNO deal that Sprint has signed with Comcast, Time Warner Cable, Cox and Advance/Newhouse Communications is an even more frightening thing to the Bell companies than expected. It has a term of 20 years, with mutual exclusivity for the first three, and involves an investment of $100m by Sprint Nextel and another $100m from the combined cablecos. Not only will they add a cellular CDMA EV-DO service to their bundles via a conventional MVNO, but they will look also to include the planned broadband wireless platform, to be created in Sprint’s 2.5GHz spectrum, in the mix, and to develop mobile devices that integrate cable, cellular and WiMAX/Wi-Fi capabilities. Like some DSL-oriented convergence programs like BT’s Fusion and plans by BellSouth, this will offer a single interface, access mechanism, voicemail and directory across the wireline, wireless and cellular systems, allowing for a seamless interface between home and mobile voicemail and email, digital video recorders and digital cameras. Sprint Nextel CEO Gary Forsee pursued one of his favourite themes, the use of broadband wireless to enable the ‘third screen’ in addition to the television and PC. ‘The new Sprint-cable partnerships will forever transform what used to be merely a cellphone into an indispensable third screen in customers’ lives,’ he said.

Behind the rhetoric, the idea is real, and it holds far more immediate terror for the Bell operators than the activities of the ISPs, even if those prove more disruptive to the telecoms world in general in the end. SBC and Verizon, once they finalize their mergers with AT&T and MCI, will have unrivalled infrastructure assets and powerful bargaining chips when facing new access providers. Regulators will decide the scale to which they can generate wealth from their pipes, but will never deprive them of that altogether, as long as they face genuine competition in the access portion. Maximizing revenue from the lines will be critical to support the Bell’s plans and this is the business they do very well ‘ while adding valuable international and enterprise revenues from their new acquisitions. In consumer services, their incumbent status has made them far less adept. With the cablecos leapfrogging them towards a mobilized triple play, and the internet players getting aggressive, they will need something far more creative than just seeking to block, or charge for, open IP applications and content.

The smaller Bells step up broadband wireless

The two smaller Bell companies, BellSouth and Qwest, both see WiMAX as a way to expand their infrastructure cost effectively and, eventually, move out of their own territories to provide nationwide services.

Qwest will roll out its own WiMAX-based broadband wireless service next year alongside a nationwide consumer VoIP offering, according to chief technology officer Balan Nair.

Qwest currently offers consumer VoIP in select cities in its 14-state territory and this will be extended to the same footprint currently covered by the operator’s business access and voice plans, OneFlex Hosted and Integrated Access.

Qwest has been trialling WiMAX in northern Denver, Colorado and sees the main priority as being an improvement in video performance. Real time video streaming stretches the limits of the shared bandwidth architecture of WiMAX, Nair told the Telecom 05 conference recently. “You need much better compression schemes to make real time video work. But if you want to be in the consumer business, you’ve got to have video.’

Another critical factor for consumer WiMAX will be subscriber units priced below $100, said Qwest’s director of engineering, Aamir Hussain. He believes the units will reach this price range in 2007.

BellSouth is expanding its broadband wireless service, based on pre-WiMAX technology from Navini, rapidly now, with New Orleans its latest target.

The operator is aiming its service in the ravaged city mainly at small businesses, particularly those seeking to rebuild their operations or help with restoration efforts. Conventional infrastructure was heavily hit by Hurricane Katrina in the summer and there has been new focus in the region on communications options that do not require phone lines, with Intel shipping in pre-WiMAX base stations shortly after the disaster to help restore connectivity rapidly.

The BellSouth Wireless Broadband service for small businesses offers a 1.5Mbps download for $69.95 a month. There are also two residential options, ‘Lite’ at 384Kbps downstream, and ‘Ultra’ at 1.5Mbps.