Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 November 2005

Cellco consolidation wave goes global in scale

The consolidation of Europe’s mobile carriers, keenly anticipated since the telecoms bubble burst and soaked the 3G carriers’ multibillion dollar dreams, is now well underway, with Telef’nica , Vodafone and the French and German incumbents in pole position. These four will engage in a series of acquisitions and divestments ‘ as illustrated last week by the Spanish bid for UK cellco O2 ‘ but the battleground is no longer confined to the 3G heartlands of the European Union. These large players, and others such as the Scandinavian majors, are increasingly looking for global position as their home markets saturate and as alternative and converged carriers muscle in on their wireless territories. So we see Vodafone selling out in Sweden but investing in South Africa and India, and T-Mobile, Norway’s Telenor and others looking ever more enthusiastically at Eastern Europe.

Vodafone has backed away somewhat from its old ambition to establish its brand in almost every world territory and, with its investors currently averse to its characteristic bold acquisitions, is more focused on increasing the minority stakes it holds in many operators in emerging economies to position itself well in the most promising future bases. It is to spend up to £1.35bn ($2.4bn) to raise its stake in South Africa’s Vodacom to 50% from 35%, giving it equal status with incumbent fixed line operator and co-owner Telkom.

Vodacom, South Africa’s largest mobile operator, has 17m customers and a year-on-year subscriber growth rate of 39%. Of its users, 16m are in its home country, with the remainder in Tanzania, Lesotho, Mozambique and the Democratic Republic of Congo. Gaining at least a half share in the outfit is vital, given the likely growth potential for the underdeveloped African communications market ‘ especially since Vodafone has an existing agreement with Telkom to use Vodacom to expand throughout sub-equatorial Africa. The combined mobile and fixed line subscriber base in Africa had risen to just under 100m by the end of lat year, with 68% being mobile, and with projections that mobile subscribers could reach 140m in the next five years.

India is, of course, another likely goldmine that the established international operators are keen to tap into ahead of locally based challengers. A week before the Vodacom deal, Vodafone had agreed to pay £820m for a 10% stake in Bharti, India’s largest mobile phone operator, and indicated it was interested in further increasing that stake. The UK giant knows it needs to move swiftly in such countries, where it will not be manoeuvring solely against its traditional adversaries but against operators from Asia and other regions that are equally interested in gaining strong growth platforms. Latin Americas largest carrier, Mexico’s America Movil, for instance, has recently expressed interest in entering Europe. And China Mobile, the most outwardly focused of the Chinese players, has expressed strong interest in India, though denied recent stories that it was set to acquire mobile carrier Reliance Telecom. However, the potential threat from such rivals may push Vodafone into agreeing too easily to taking minority stakes, which could land it ‘ as it has in Japan and France ‘ with a fight to buy a larger stake from reluctant fellow shareholders, and in the mean time, inadequate control of the operation. Singapore’s SingTel, for instance, holds a 31% stake in Bharti and has indicated it would like to increase this, making the company an unlikely springboard to launch ‘Vodafone India’.

Some of Vodafone’s forays into Africa, Asia and eastern Europe are likely to be funded by sales of holdings in more slowly growing markets. This has started in a small way with the divestment of Vodafone Sweden for €1.04bn, but larger decisions face the world’s largest cellco ‘ notably whether to stick to the long uphill struggle that it faces in Japan, and whether to maintain the status quo in the US, where it co-owns Verizon Wireless. A move to pull out of Verizon, perhaps in order to buy another US carrier that Vodafone could control and own-brand, looks less likely than it did last year when the UK company put in a failed bid for AT&T Wireless (a move that, if successful, would have forced exit from Verizon Wireless). Verizon, on track to snatch back its crown as the largest US mobile operator from Cingular, is a major cash generator for its parents and with Vodafone’s attention shifting to emerging economies, that financial support may be well worth the downside of not having ‘Vodafone USA’.

Vodafone has been, like its rival T-Mobile, casting acquisitive eyes over the eastern European countries with their promise of rapid economic growth and relatively undeveloped infrastructure. This year, it completed a £2.3bn deal for the 79% stake it did not already own in Mobifon of Romania, and took full control of Oskar Mobil, the Czech Republic’s third largest operator. In March it agreed to acquire Canadian-based Telesystem International Wireless’ operations in the Czech Republic and Romania for about $3.5bn. Vodafone also may get a chance to increase its 20% stake in Polkomtel of Poland, though 20% stakeholder TDC of Denmark may also be keen to increase its holding in this fast growing nation.

The chart shows the complex web of ownerships that are behind the mobile operators of this region, especially the EU accession states and the highly promising market of Russia and its former satellite state neighbors such as Ukraine.

Of course, the consolidation in western Europe’s saturating markets will lead to the demise of many smaller players. Once the 3G licenses had been purchased in most territories, it has been received wisdom that most countries would eventually support just three carriers, with Vodafone the likely universal factor. While O2 has long headed the shortlist of likely takeover targets ‘ attractive in user base and product terms, but too dependent on a single country ‘ other midtier cellcos will be looking to ensure they stay on the list of survivors. Mobile arms that are still owned by fixed line incumbents, rather than having been cut loose as O2 was by BT, have a huge advantage in being able to punch above their weight in the cellular market, and with convergence the name of the game, many fixed line operators will be looking to snap up more wireless assets. France Telecom’s purchase of Orange was one of the boldest examples of this but the pattern will not be broken soon. Swisscom, one of the most aggressive of the smaller country players, falls into this group and is currently seeking to acquire Ireland’s Eircom. Rather like T-Mobile, Swisscom has so far used sidelines such as Wi-Fi hotspots to move out of its home nation, but is now looking to run full operations outside Switzerland. Cash rich and debt free, it does however labor against being confined to a mature and slowing market and has lost several of its recent attempts to broaden its base, being defeated in the battle for Cesky Telekom by Telef’nica and for Telekom Austria by political opposition. Eircom shares closed up 16% at €2.42 ($2.91) on confirmation of the approach from Swisscom, and rose by 22% in a week, giving the company a market capitalization of about €2.6bn at the end of last week.

The deals:

Telef’nica has agreed to acquire UK carrier O2 in an all-cash deal for $31.6bn. The deal will be entirely funded with debt from a $32.8bn bridge facility underwritten by Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, and the Royal Bank of Scotland. The companies also expect to save $351.8m by 2008 from economies of scale. Telef’nica said it plans to retain the O2 board and the company’s branding. O2 will contribute 24.6m customers to Telef’nica ‘s 145m (fixed and mobile).

Expectations were high that there would be a counterbid from Deutsche Telekom, which has been in merger talks with the UK company before, but this has been ruled out by the German operator, although France Telecom could still emerge as a competitive bidder.

Although, unlike Deutsche Telekom, Telef’nica has no geographic overlap with O2, the UK company would bring it instantly enhanced profits, greater handset and equipment purchasing power, and broader territory ‘ despite the statement in September by CEO Cesar Alierta that he was not interested in O2 because it did not fit his criteria for ‘selective value creating acquisitions’. It would also face fewer regulatory hurdles because Telef’nica does not operate in the UK or Ireland already.

O2 would be subsumed into the parent company rather than the cellular arm Telef’nica Moviles because the former has a bigger balance sheet for an all-cash deal, according to Alierta.

Telenor will buy Vodafone’s Swedish unit in a deal valued at €1.04bn (£704m), making the Norwegian incumbent number three in a market whose saturation levels make scale a necessity. TeliaSonera, Tele2 and 3 are the other 3G operators vying for a population of just 9m. Net proceeds to Vodafone after assumption of debt will be about £660m. This is one of the first times Vodafone has sold a wholly owned asset.

The Predators

Vodafone Revenue $60.7bn
Famous for its daring acquisitions but under current CEO Arun Sarin has been held back by shareholder hostility to further big adventures. Greatest speculation surrounds whether it will seek a wholly owned subsidiary in the US (it dropped out of bidding for AT&T Wireless, losing to Cingular, and a similar deal would mean exiting its high growth joint venture with Verizon, Verizon Wireless, or buying out its partner).

The strategy of achieving a majority owned, Vodafone branded service in every major territory has been diluted somewhat and there are persistent question marks over its continuing presence in Japan. Its main focus now is on taking pole position in markets that will see rapid growth in the coming decade, such as parts of sub-Saharan Africa, China and India.

Likely targets: Increased stake in China Mobile, Russia, increased stake in Bharti in India, rapid expansion plans based on the Vodacom brand in southern and central Africa. CEO Arun Sarin has also singled out Poland as a short term prospect.

NTT DoCoMo $41.9bn

DoCoMo, whose acquisition history in the US and Europe has been dogged by poor results, is now on the expansion trail again, but is likely to look to Asia this time. The giant will particularly target markets frequented by Japanese travellers in order to boost its global roaming revenues and start to build a pan-Asia footprint in competition with other majors like SingTel. DoCoMo’s targeted countries, it said last week, are China, the Philippines, South Korea, Hong Kong and Taiwan. It already holds stakes in Hong Kong’s Hutchison Whampoa (24.1%) and Far EasTone Telecommunications in Taiwan (4.9%). Earlier this year it was said to be in talks with Korea Telecom.

China Mobile $23.3bn

China Mobile is the most outwardly focused of the Chinese telcos and is likely to seek a pan-Asian footprint over the coming decade. It made its first acquisition outside mainland China recently when it agreed to acquire Hong Kong’s fourth largest carrier, CR Peoples Telephone.

The larger company denied reports that it wanted to acquire part of India’s Reliance Telecom last summer but is known to be in talks with several Indian players and has expressed interest in investments in Pakistan, Yemen and Uzbekistan. It lost to Emirates Telecoms earlier this year in bidding for a 26% stake in state-owned Pakistan Telecommunication. There has also been talks about acquiring state-owned Uzbekistan Telecom. China

Likely targets: possible intensified cooperation and roaming with its shareholder Vodafone, which is relatively weak in Asia and struggling in Japan.

Telef’nica

The Spanish converged carrier’s geographical focus is usually on Latin America, where it is the largest provider following the purchase last year of many of BellSouth’s activities in the region. However, it is currently shifting its acquisition strategy to focus on ‘opportunities’ rather than specific geographic regions. The change of emphasis was illustrated earlier this year when it made its bid for Cesky Telecom but passed on a chance to take Brazil’s Telemig Celular Participacoes, despite its location close to many other Telef’nica operations.

After O2, the Spanish giant claims to have not interest in further European acquisition – despite talk that it would seek to take over the Netherlands’ KPN. Instead it will focus on filling in gaps in its huge Latin American holdings ‘ a bid for a Colombian carrier is next on the agenda ‘ and looking towards Africa and the Middle East.

‘We are looking for what provides a better return in a visible period – three to five years, not 20 – and which is significantly greater than the cost of capital,’ said the telco. ‘Our Latin American chapter is completed and we only have some footnotes left to be filled.’

Likely targets: Eastern Europe, Turkey, western Asia.

SK Telekom

Most of SKT’s acquisition activity has been of smaller carriers in its home market in South Korea, but in the past year it has been showing signs of global ambition, most interestingly with its joint venture in the US, SKT-Earthlink, which has already announced an MVNO cellular service called Helio and also plans broadband wireless access offerings to enter the converged market.

SKT has started to expand more widely in its own region, for instance through its joint venture, SLD Telecom, in Vietnam, and has also engaged in talks with Tata of India.

Likely targets: Joint ventures rather than outright acquisitions, in India, China, south east Asia and the US.

Deutsche Telekom/T-Mobile

Deutsche Telekom’s ambitions for its mobile arm, T-Mobile, remain mainly close to home, as witnessed by various holdings in eastern Europe and the recent deal to buy Austria’s Tele.ring from Western Wireless. It was expected to seek to buy O2 but now the more interesting questions surround what holdings around the world it will cling onto ‘ notably, will it keep its growth engine, T-Mobile USA, for the long term despite the need to upgrade its network and acquire spectrum for larger market coverage?

Ones to watch:

Acquisitions are not all ones-way traffic in emerging economies. Companies from Russia, Turkey and elsewhere are also becoming predators. Some examples:

Alfa Group, Russia:
Russian investment group Alfa is looking to create an empire across its home country and neighboring states such as Ukraine, and also in Turkey, and this is bringing it into conflict with Scandinavian expansionists, which also see these regions as their natural home. While Telef’nica is considering taking a stake in Turk Telecom, Finland’s TeliaSonera has upped its interest in Turkcell to 64.3% following a deal with Cukurova Group, under which it purchased a 27% stake for $3.1bn.

The attractiveness of Turkcell was shown by a claim by Russian investment group Alfa that it would trump TeliaSonera’s offer to Cukurova, intensifying an existing and bitter business conflict between the Finnish operator and Alfa, which are in dispute over ownership of a 25% stake in Russia’s third cellco, MegaFon. This dispute has held back the potential for Alfa ‘ part of the group controlled by Russia’s second richest man, Mikhail Fridman ‘ to merge MegaFon with the number two mobile operator, Vimpelcom, which it controls, to create a market leader.

Another ambitious venture is Egyptian firm Orascom, which earlier this year acquired Wind Telecommunications in Italy from conglomerate Enel in a €12bn ($14.45bn) deal.

Wind was transferred to an investment fund owned by the founder of Orascom Telecom Holdings, Naguib Sawiris, whose idea is to merge Orascom’s African and Middle East holdings to create a pan-Mediterranean telecoms firm. The company also has operations in Pakistan.