The shock waves sent out by the launch of Free Mobile services in 2012 continue to reshape the French telecoms industry. Two groups, Altice and Free’s owner Iliad, are battling to dominate the emerging quad play market and disrupt incumbent Orange, and the by-product has been a vicious mobile price war. Altice has already acquired the country’s second MNO, SFR, and has now made an offer for the third one, Bouygues Telecom.
However, on Tuesday, Bouygues’ board unanimously rejected Altice’s unsolicited offer to acquire its telecoms subsidiary and insisted this was well placed to continue to compete on its own. This looks like an attempt to provoke a better offer, or a rival bidder (perhaps a revival of old merger talks with Iliad/Free?) Bouygues could hardly be called well positioned – it has come under huge pressure from the price war, forcing it into swingeing cost cuts; and when wireline and wireless networks are considered together, it has the least powerful platform.
Nevertheless, the board was determined to make the most of the assets it does have, saying in its statement: “The telecoms market is at the dawn of a new era of growth driven by the exponential development of digital uses.” It cited Bouygues’ spectrum portfolio, advanced 4G network, growing fixed broadband base, and the launch of its Android TV service.
It also pointed to the high risk that an Altice deal would be derailed by competition authorities, saying the offer does not provide “a fully satisfactory response regarding this important matter”, nor regarding the implications for a merger of this year’s 700 MHz auction (see separate item).
Awareness of the risks, as well as eagerness for the deal, may be seen in the reportedly generous price Altice offered. Neither party has commented on this, but Reuters sources indicated it was around €10bn ($11.3bn) in cash – which would be a high offer for a company which has made losses since Iliad/Free’s market entry, and which Paris analysts have been valuing closer to €6bn. The value of the whole Bouygues group, which also includes construction, road transport and other businesses (not included in the acquisition bid), was €11.3bn before the news of the Altice offer.
This rejection is unlikely to be the last word on the matter, nor the last deal to be done in France. Shares in Altice, Numericable-SFR and Bouygues leapt by as much as 20% on the news of the offer, and fell again by as much as 11% on the rejection. Investors are looking for consolidation to reduce costs and ease the price wars which are making it tough for any operator to be profitable in France. Cost savings from a Numericable/SFR/Bouygues merger are estimated at about €850m a year, according to Reuters.
Iliad’s launch of disruptive, low cost mobile tariffs – enabled by a wide roll-out of WiFi homespots and femtocells connected to its residential cable lines – has completely changed the rules of the game in the previously rather stagnant French mobile market. The consequent price wars have driven SFR and Bouygues to see new owners with deeper pockets and the fixed-line reach to enable a quad play. SFR has been merged into Altice’s Numericable unit, the group having defeated Bougyues in the battle to win the former Vivendi subsidiary.
A possible deal for Bouygues to be acquired by Iliad/Free also came to nothing, and recently the company’s chairman, Martin Bouygues, has said he no longer wishes to sell. So the Altice move may be just an opening one in an interesting three-way tournament between the three maverick men who run so much of France’s telecoms and media business – Bouygues himself, Altice’s Patrick Drahi and Iliad’s Xavier Niel (especially if he decides to make a counterbid).
However, any deal involving any combination of these would certainly attract scrutiny from the French government and European antitrust regulators. It would reduce the number of MNOs from four to three and potentially lead to significant job losses, and less competition for spectrum licences in the upcoming 700 MHz auction (the government has already targeted revenues of €2.5bn from that sale, which takes place later this year, and have earmarked the funds for military use).
While reducing the number of players in a market is still a concern for competition authorities, in recent months the European agencies have been more inclined to allow such deals, in the interests of creating stronger players with the ability to fund new networks and services – and also because assessing competition in mobile or fixed-line siloes is becoming anachronistic in a world where European operators are all converging on the quad play space. In the mobile market, France would simply revert to its pre-Free situation of having three MNOs, but when the whole broadband/mobile/TV picture is considered, it would be one of the most consolidated markets in Europe, with Orange, Numericable and Free dominating all forms of service.
The French government had already indicated hostility to a potential Altice-Bouygues deal because of concerns about the impact on employment and communications infrastructure investment.
At the least, the new partners would be required to make divestments, and Altice has already pre-empted that, entering talks with Iliad about selling on a portfolio of Bouygues assets to be incorporated into Free.
Martin Bouygues may have gone off the idea of selling his telecoms arm, but the company’s options are limited. Despite the board’s confidence, going it alone will be challenging in the current climate, even after the company’s ongoing reorganization is complete, since it lacks sufficient fixed-line reach to build a convincing alternative to those of Orange, Numericable/SFR and Iliad/Free; and if it continues to lose money and market share, its future purchase value will fall.
Stephane Beyazian, an analyst at Raymond James, told Reuters: “The board will need to consider that they may not achieve a better value for this asset, even assuming that the ongoing restructuring plan is successful.”
Of course, France is not the only European country where competition regulators are working overtime in the telecoms sector. In the UK, two large deals – BT’s acquisition of EE and Hutchison Whampoa’s of Telefonica’s O2 UK – are under review, while in Denmark, Telenor and TeliaSonera are keen to merge their local subsidiaries.
The European Commission has issued a statement of objections to this deal, and the two companies have responded this week, insisting that their merger would not hurt competition in Denmark.
“We firmly believe the merger will ultimately be beneficial for competition and Danish consumers,” they said in a joint statement. “We will continue in a constructive dialog with the Commission to make sure all concerns are properly addressed.”
They added: “Competition in the Danish mobile market is fierce and will remain so in the future. Combining Telia and Telenor in Denmark is about creating a company with the scale and the capacity to better invest and compete on price, quality and innovation. Delivering on this requires investments and if we look back on recent years this has been a challenge.The status quo would lead to a continued drop in investment.”
There would still be three MNOs in the country post-merger, which would be in line with consolidation permitted recently in larger countries like Germany. However, the EC is looking closely at this proposal and opened an in-depth investigation in April. Its issues seem not to be about having just three MNOs, but about a structure where the two smaller players,
TDC and Hutchison 3, might face too large a gap between themselves and the enlarged leader. They might struggle to compete effectively, lacking just that scale to invest which Telia/Telenor claim they need. That, the EC warned, could lead to “higher prices and less innovation”.
It has not made its statement of objections public, though it is clear from the operators’ statement what it must contain. The Commission will now press the firms to offer more concessions to address its concerns, according to Reuters. As in other markets, like Ireland and Germany, where the number of MNOs has been reduced, these concessions could include guaranteed network access for more MVNOs. One EC concern is that there will be fewer sources of wholesale capacity. The deadline for the EC’s final decision is September 2.