Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 June 2015

Does one report burst the smart home bubble? AT&T hopes not

Service providers have increasingly looked at offering more services to their customers, as a way of reducing churn. The premise is simple: it’s harder to cancel a triple play, or even quad play, package than it is to end a single-play offering. With smart home products and services, those operators have the chance to sell a far stickier platform to their subscribers – as it’s harder to return a set of connected door locks or a HVAC system than it is to ship a set-top back to a provider.

So the smart home looks like the next logical step for the likes of Comcast, AT&T and Sky. A bundled subscription offering can remove the current bottleneck – customer reluctance to pay an upfront fee – and can quickly provide enough options to allow a home to become smarter quickly, with enough flexibility to be tailored to suit future shifts in taste or need. What’s more, additional device sales or leases simply add more to the ARPU for these homes – all while reducing churn.

But not long after the term smart home became at least vaguely familiar to consumers, a report from Argus Insights suggests that a combination of hype-fatigue and under-delivery of promised improvements has shrunk consumer demand for smart home products by 15% in the year since May 2014.

Argus has a solid industry reputation for accurate sales predictions, although it is working with those awkward abstract qualities like ‘buzz’ and ‘positive sentiment’, and not – at this early stage in the market – a vast database of numbers. The consequent lack of concrete numbers and measurements is a little detrimental, but the argument makes sense on paper.

One point to keep in mind is that neither Google or Apple has yet launched in this space – though their respective Nest/Android and HomeKit platforms are (apparently) imminent. These will undoubtedly benefit from large press events and coverage, which would surely increase the social media that Argus measures, as well as introducing new potential customers to the concept of the smart home and so raising demand.

Nonetheless, the main thrust of the Argus argument is that early adopters have got what they wanted from their smart home devices, and that they are no longer buying the equipment in such volume, while the market has not done enough collectively to create interest from the average buyer.

As such, demand has dried up after the geekiest enthusiasts feasted on the offerings from Nest, Ecobee, Philips Hue, Wink, and Lutron, but that enthusiasm hasn’t shifted across to mainstream consumers – as yet, at least.

Argus reports that this decline in interest is seen across all classes of devices, and that it is not a particular application that has dragged the total demand down. In terms of other IoT responses, wearables and big data were the most popular conversations on social media – with home automation and the connected car the least mentioned per month.

Apple’s entrance into the wearables arena might have caused a big spike in those mentions, but it’s worrying for operators that home automation is in last place – given that that the perceived quality of life improvements afforded by a few hundred dollars spent on smart home devices seem the much more attractive proposition than wrist-mounted notifications and step-counting.

Nonetheless, consumers are voting with their wallets and tweets, perhaps suggesting that cheaper and more visible devices are both easier to buy and show to your friends and family. It’s much harder to show off your new remote control air conditioner at the water cooler than it is your new smartwatch.

Similarly, it’s far easier (and more fun) for a consumer to begin using a Fitbit or Jawbone than it is a Nest. For the wearables, pairing the unit with a smartphone and registering an account are the only real obstacles, but for the thermostat, a higher upfront cost and then a few hours of DIY installation or the services of a paid installer are required before you can begin remotely controlling your radiators.

Key to the cost issue is of course the price of the entire system. Those happy with a bit of DIY stand to save hundreds or thousands of dollars, compared to the cost of a custom installation. On that topic, smart homes have been around for at least two decades – but a system that would have cost you tens of thousands of dollars in the 1990s can now be implemented for single-digit thousands, thanks to the falling cost of electronics and the increasing capabilities of software.

So as the price of these devices continues to fall in the coming years, it stands to reason that a bit of marketing will help renew consumer interest in the smart home.

Another driving factor will be the shake-up seen in the pay-TV markets, as consumers increasingly adopt over-the-top platforms instead of cable or satellite as their main source of content. Those pay-TV providers will have to find something to recoup that potential lost TV revenue with, and the ‘smart home-as-a-service’ model seems particularly lucrative.

In the US, far more so than in Europe, home security is a feature for which many users will pay a premium. To that end, the pay-TV operators are perfectly positioned to sell home monitoring and security cameras to end users, with the installed set-top box or home gateway as the WiFi-enabled cameras’ link to the cloud storage, and live feeds found in apps that let users check in on the status of their home.

For many US operators, partnerships with the likes of ADT, a specialist home security company, have been the most straightforward way to provide a trusted security platform, but others (like AT&T) recognize the better margins that can be achieved by controlling the device ecosystem entirely and not allowing users to add their own devices to a home platform. While sounding a little anti-consumer, such an approach should also enable better uptime and reliability, as the operator will be more familiar with the devices and their behavior.

AT&T is meanwhile pushing ahead with the expansion of its Digital Life unit, and says that it will have released a new app and user interface within 30 days. The current implementation centers around a WiFi and Z-Wave hub (with cellular redundancy), with monthly subscription packages that bundle devices and the cloud services that power them.

While not cheap, these services are certainly valuable to some owners. For example, the Water Control package costs $250 up front with a $10 monthly charge. That package includes 3 temperature and water sensors and a shut-off valve, but for $250 plus the monthly fee that provides leak notifications and ambient temperature monitoring, a homeowner could avoid thousands of dollars of water damage in the case of a burst pipe.

That’s an expensive proposition, but the trade-off is potentially disastrous. Similarly, alarms and cameras might help deter a burglary, but combining these separate packages begins to create a service with a rather high upfront cost and a hefty continuous monthly charge – and likely a low triple-digit installation fee.

Choosing all the basic home automation options and the home security package brings the monthly charges up to $70, with the total equipment charges at $600. Once you start adding extra devices, such as a touchscreen controller, smoke alarms and a carbon monoxide detector, you can easily get the package to nearly $1,500 – although the monthly charge seems capped at $70, on top of the broadband, home phone and TV package of course.

But AT&T has recognized that the headstart afforded to it by the expectations of home security, which have driven the development of Digital Life, will enable it to sell the products overseas.

This saw AT&T license the platform to Telefonica in Europe back in September 2014, with the first tests taking place in London or Madrid – pending the approval of regulators. We have yet to see the results of this trial, but it is interesting nonetheless to see if AT&T can successfully white-label its smart home-as-a-service platform outside of its home market.

Elsewhere in Europe, Deutsche Telekom plans on expanding its own Qivicon smart home platform to the UK and the Netherlands this year, but back in the US, AT&T faces competition from both fellow telco Verizon as well as Comcast. Elsewhere in the IoT, AT&T has a sizeable M2M portfolio, as well as its Drive Studio connected car initiative – obvious plays for its cellular networks, as those wireless units require connectivity that AT&T is all too happy to provide.