Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 December 2007

Cable hesitant, wholesale in and satellite out as bidders line up for 700MHz

The bidders are lining up for the US 700MHz auction, with Google still the most prominent candidate from the open internet community, and the cable and satellite sectors divided in their intentions.

Bidders have now entered a quiet period, but statements were issued last week from a number of players that had been assumed to be involved, either saying that they were not planning to bid, as both Comcast and Time Warner Cable made clear, or in some way qualifying their involvement.

Jamie Townsend, an analyst at financial research house and Rethink partner JRPG, thinks that Comcast and TWC dropping out will drop the likely auction level for Blocks A and B even though Cox Communications has declared itself still in the game. He also goes further to suggest an entire scenario analysis for the auctions, stating that Google may only be an early round bidder for Block C, and that either Verizon or AT&T will emerge victorious there. He also adds that, while Frontline Wireless will make bids for Block D, it is unlikely to win.

He asks the question, and we echo it – just how is US Big Cable going to get into a quadruple play if it cannot convince itself that it is worth buying its own spectrum? In the last auction, AWS, the main four cablecos formed a venture, with Sprint, to bid for licenses, but in the end SpectrumCo withdrew from the bidding and Sprint left the group, which now appears to be dormant.

Given that their MVNO + deal with Sprint (Pivot) is uncertain and working badly, the cable majors might be looking around for a way to control their own destiny. But given that quad play services are non-existent at present in the US, and that a new partner may emerge, post-auction, desperate for the kind of customer acquisition capability that the cable operators can give, then a sit and wait mentality may well be reasonable. It may even be that Cox is carrying the torch for all of the US cable operators and will use anything it acquires as a US umbrella to replace Pivot, which it can charge out to all the cable operators.

On November 30, Google said it would participate in the auction but made it clear that it would not partner anyone else, which is seen as Google just pushing up the price, and doing so in order for the FCC to remain happy about the open access provisions that it placed on the spectrum. Once Google feels that the price is high enough it will fall away, according to the Townsend theory, and it’s a reasonable one. Google wants the open access thing to work out, but it has no desire to use up all its cash, nor to run a network, unless it has to.

Frontline has repeatedly said it would bid for Block D, which has public safety requirements attached to it, but if either Verizon or AT&T turns their sights on Block D, for instance after missing Block C, Townsend thinks things will get too hot for Frontline. Frontline says it wants to build out a 4G network, and will effectively pay for it through a commercial service sold to public safety organizations, and then get anyone else on board that it has room for. Frontline is likely to have been attracted to the low minimum bid on Block D at $1.33bn, but Townsend reckons this could end up going for not much less than the more expensive minimum bid Block C.

As for satellite, Direct TV has made it clear it will not bid, and though Echostar has kept quiet so far, it also appears likely to sit this one out. On the mobile satellite side, MSV (Mobile Satellite Ventures) said it will not participate in the auction, but said it wants to be the satellite operator of choice for the winner of the hybrid commercial/public safety D Block license. FCC rules require that satellite capacity be built into to at least one handset operating in the D Block.

Another mobile satellite player, Terrestar, plans to bid more directly, with a plan not dissimilar from Frontline’s, to combine terrestrial/satellite services for public safety and commercial use with a wholesale model to support emerging smaller operators. Terrestar recently chose Nokia Siemens to supply it with its first all-IP system, the basis for a planned wide range of consumer, business and public safety services using its hybrid spectrum rights across north America (see Wireless Watch September 10 2007). Unless the incumbent cellcos win the bulk of the spectrum, there is likely to be a strong showing for the wholesale approach among winners, with Google and other internet players already committed to this to encourage alternative and disruptive providers, and with wholesaling almost essential to support a mobile internet model profitably in the initial years.

Also opting out are Sprint and Clearwire (both rich in 2.5GHz spectrum), while flat rate operator Leap Wireless appears to be in the running. A merger plan between Leap and its direct competitor MetroPCS recently fell through, and both companies need to expand their territories in order to sustain growth in their aggressive low cost model. Both also acquired significant new holdings in the AWS auction. Leap told the SEC it filed’through an indirect wholly owned subsidiary’to compete for licenses and also that Denali Spectrum License, an entity in which it has a non-controlling indirect interest, also filed applications. Unsurprisingly, AT&T and Verizon Wireless will both participate in the auction. The deadline for 700MHz applicants’ upfront payments is December 28. The FCC will conduct the auction largely in the dark to guard against anti-competitive behavior. The agency will announce high bids at the end of each round, but will not release names of winning bidders until after the auction ends.

White space spectrum:

Although Google plans to bid for 700MHz licenses, it is also looking at other licensed and license-exempt options, and is still investigating the ‘white spaces’ of unlicensed bandwidth that sit between spectrum currently licensed to television broadcasters. While past efforts by Google, Microsoft, Philips and others for prototypes that run on the white spaces were largely rejected by the FCC on the grounds of possible interference, , Google has since decided to go it alone with its own tests. The company presented results of an “initial phase of ongoing trials” around white space technology that it says demonstrates that digital televisions and wireless microphones can exist side-by-side without interference.