One of the key trends in Europe as operators look to reduce operating costs and devise profit models for 3G and 4G is the pooling of infrastructure resources, from sharing cell sites to full RAN sharing. The UK has been a flagwaver for this approach, but as with other emerging wireless business models, India is setting the pace. Vodafone, which has already engaged in a RAN sharing venture with Orange in its home country, is now joining forces with two other majors in India to merge their infrastructure operations and form the world’s largest independent tower company.
The UK cellco’s Indian arm, Vodafone Essar, is working with Bharti Airtel and Idea Cellular, to share 70,000 tower units in a venture named Indus Towers. Bharti and Vodafone ‘ which had previously floated the idea in June – will each have a 42% stake, while Idea will hold the remaining 16%. The two larger partners will contribute 29,400 towers each with Idea bringing in 11,200. ‘The idea is that Indus will be a truly independent tower company, where no player enjoys a majority stake. We are looking at listing Indus Towers at the earliest, but it is for the new board of this company to set the timeframe for this,’ said Bharti Airtel’s joint managing director Akhil Gupta.
Bharti Infratel, Airtel’s already spun-off tower unit, will retain about 20,000 towers and continue to run these for its parent. These sites fall outside the 16 markets on which Indus is focusing ‘ on the basis that these are the 16 markets in which Vodafone Essar and Bharti both operate, while Idea provides services in 11 of these 16 at present, and Bharti is nationwide. If Vodafone and Idea get pan-Indian footprints in future spectrum allocations, Indus could be extended to the whole country.
Such collaborations will be highly significant in India, which is in a race against time to extend its inadequate telecoms infrastructure to keep pace with its economic growth and support its goals of greater social integration and a more prominent role in the world economy. Lower costs will support more rapid time to market for universal GSM services and, after next year’s spectrum auctions, the start of 3G and WiMAX. The three operators, which are the top three GSM providers in the country, said Indus would achieve significant scale benefits, and help them undertake ‘a significant roll-out of telecom infrastructure to propel the mobile sector towards achieving India’s teledensity and rural coverage goals within the next few years’.
India added over eight million new wireless subscribers in October, taking the country’s mobile base to over 217m.
Approaches to infrastructure sharing:
There are various approaches to network sharing open to operators, notably:
‘ site sharing (including transmission but with independent radio designs);
‘ RAN sharing, with sites, node-B and transmission shared, and a virtual radio network controller;
‘ Sharing of the complete network through a joint venture, depending on regulatory permission;
‘ Roaming, including split coverage
The MVNO and wholesale routes are also extreme means of network sharing, where one operator owns the entire infrastructure and charges lease fees.
The main objectives of sharing for the operator are to save on capex and opex; to speed roll-out, especially in rural areas; to improve access to sites, especially to improve coverage in sparsely populated regions; to improve margins, also especially in rural areas; and meanwhile to preserve the ability to differentiate its services and brand (not possible in the joint venture scenario). There are also cases where operators without a 3G license may share the risk and reward of network building with a licensee, where the regulator permits this.
The disadvantages – or point at which the operator might move away from a share to an individual system – only really cut in when usage is high and capacity reaches a ceiling, limiting the cellco’s ability to deliver quality of service or new applications. This is a problem that is unlikely to affect most 3G roll-outs for some years, given the slow initial uptake and the standard’s relative spectral efficiency, plus the increasingly real options of offloading commodity traffic not just to GSM but to Wi-Fi or, in future, WiMAX.
Within the shared RAN category, there are several approaches, and Ericsson has been a pioneer in defining these and offering options for up to six operators. The main routes, as outlined by the Swedish giant, are common shared network; geographical split network; and shared UTRAN. Like Nokia, it estimates initial infrastructure savings of about 40% from RAN sharing, with most savings to be gained in the build-out and coverage phases. At this early stage, there is cost splitting in most parts of the network – the core, the active RAN (base stations, network controllers and so on), and the passive RAN (site, tower, cables and antennas). Once the capacity phase is reached the savings are mainly in the passive RAN, and so are similar to those from simple site sharing, and at this point, operators may look to divorce their networks.
In the common shared network approach, the operators deploy a completely shared RAN and partly shared core. Each carrier owns its individual home network, which contains all functions related to subscriber data, billing and interconnection with other networks, allowing for independent services and tariffs. Operators can add individual coverage to the shared network using handover as supported by the 3GPP change requests standard, approved in 2001.
In the geographically split network, each operator has their own W-CDMA system with national roaming enabled. Handover is also supported by the change requests standard within 3GPP 99 and the networks are interconnected by the Iur interface to support soft handover.
The shared UTRAN solution provides for the W-CDMA network to be physically shared but logically, each carrier has its own RAN. Each operator has its own core and its individual cells with their own carrier, frequency and Mobile Network Code. This option is based on the Virtual Radio Network Controller features allowing different core networks to be connected to the same physical RNC using the 3GPP standard Iu interface. This option is often used where regulators do not permit fully shared RANs. It also provides for more simple migration to individual networks in future.