Mobile operators in developed markets are caught in a painful cleft stick. Many of their problems lie in regulations that were devised when they were pioneers in a new sector, rather than incumbents in a rapidly maturing one. But as they campaign for those regulations and market norms to be changed, in fact, a new breed of operators and business models has already stepped in to address the problems ahead of them. So last week we heard Deutsche Telekom’s CEO Rene Obermann calling for European authorities to adopt more relaxed rules on technology neutrality in mobile bands, and on consolidation or infrastructure sharing among cellcos. His demands make sense as many western European countries approach mobile saturation, but in fact, it may well be new carriers with more efficient networks and internet-oriented business models that take commercial advantage of a less regulated environment. Similarly, a year ago ‘ when he was head of the T-Mobile cellco division ‘ Obermann led the call for an end to handset subsidies in Europe, arguing that this would enable operators to reduce tariffs. Yet the no-subsidy model will more likely be achieved by new, open access approaches that favour user-purchased devices, as Sprint Nextel has realized in the US. European mobile operators are deeply threatened by a world of full technology neutrality and open network access to all devices, since it would rob them of their control. So Obermann’s calls may prove to be a case of ‘be careful what you wish for’ ‘ and the cellcos that actually profit from the new world of the mobile web will be those that can adapt their behaviour to mirror that of the internet players, not those that seek to twist old regulations in order to sustain the traditional order. In this respect, the cheerleaders are currently Sprint in the US and, surprisingly enough given its former hostile approach to open mobile internet, 3 in Europe, both of which are embracing the principles of the ISPs, such as flat rate data tariffs and open browsing, to rise to the challenge of the new operators.
3 UK was one of the first to accept the inevitability of the end of the walled garden, and introduce something close to a full internet model on to its 3G network (see Wireless Watch November 20 2006). It now offers its X-Series broadband internet service in several of its European markets, which includes the combination that will be essential to all operators in mobile broadband – of flat rates; bundling of different content and media; multiple platform support including television; and web 2.0 functions and payment models. Following the trend for cellcos to get close to internet players, the offering was launched in partnership with most of the big movers of the mobile internet – Skype, Sling Media, Yahoo, Google, eBay, Microsoft and Orb, as well as handset makers Nokia and Sony Ericsson. 3 says it aims to extend core applications and functions from the broadband internet model to the handset, with a new pricing model that also borrows heavily from the PC internet, offering flat monthly fees.
Such an approach will be the way that cellcos hit back against alternative wireless operators that are using Wi-Fi and WiMAX to provide mobile broadband with multimedia at flat rates, replicating the PC experience on smaller devices.
Now, with Vodafone and others following 3’s example, the 3G-only operator is set to be disruptive again, announcing cut rate HSDPA services before some of its rivals have even rolled out their network upgrades. This is typical of 3, which has recovered from its early poor start in 3G markets on the back of aggressive price cutting, leveraging the efficiency of UMTS and the lack of a legacy 2G network to keep its operating costs low and pass on the savings to customers. Cheap voice calls may not have been what the operators dreamed of using 3G for, but they certainly attract users, who can then be lured to boost their ARPU with the mobile internet offerings.
3 is looking for a similar pattern in HSDPA, and is set to spark the first mobile broadband price war in the process, starting in the UK on September 3. According to news service Unstrung, 3 will price its 2.8Mbps HSDPA service at £10 ($20) a month for 1Gb of data, up to £25 for 7Gb, and the USB modem is likely to be free for existing subscribers or otherwise about £79 with a one-year contract. The lowest rate in Europe is currently about $40 per month for 1Gb, while T-Mobile UK’s laptop data service starts at $57 with modem. This will not only undercut other HSDPA operators such as Vodafone, but will also take 3 a step closer to a wireless-only quad play. The carrier claims its HSDPA modem will be fast enough, and support sufficiently good indoor penetration, to compete with wired broadband services from multiservice operators like Orange.
3 is throwing down the gauntlet to operators who wish to preserve the myth that mobile data spectrum is a scarce resource and so mass market pricing is non-viable ‘ although once again, it is likely to use the efficiency of its 3G network in voice delivery to balance its costs on data, and to tie the HSDPA contracts into higher margin voice deals. The operator has currently deployed HSDPA to cover 50% of the UK population and will cover 85% by year end.
The cellco, although from a traditional telecoms heritage as part of the Hutchison group, has realized that its chances of keeping up with the more established players in its European markets lie in borrowing the tactics of the internet providers. This means it has taken on itself the role of the snake in the grass, breaking the solidarity of the cellcos in insisting on maintaining certain myths ‘ that data is a premium service, that users do not want open internet access from handsets, that flat rate pricing is unsustainable.
Gradually the other operators are having to make similar concessions, but Obermann’s comments, which can be taken to represent the views of many of the large cellcos, show how grudgingly this will be done, and how the operators will continue to try to reshape regulations in their own image. He is calling on regulators to make it easier for Europe’s mobile operators to consolidate, either through merger or through sharing of infrastructure and other resources, as margins come under intense pressure. ‘Regulators should accept there is a need for more efficient use of capital resources for both economic and ecological reasons,’ he said. ‘Regulators should allow network consolidation. Over time that would be useful as would moves to allow a more efficient use of spectrum.’
The CEO pointed out that there are 30 owners of mobile companies in Europe and 70 networks (including the large Wi-Fi hotspot systems), and that this is ‘overcrowded’. Yet in many countries there are still major hurdles to consolidation or acquisition ‘ as Swisscom and Telecom Italia have discovered ‘ and rules remain in place to tie certain spectrum bands to certain technologies.
The latter issue demonstrates the dilemma for the large spectrum owners. Technology neutrality, which is likely to become a reality in many countries in the 2.5GHz auctions, to be held from next year, opens the door for new operators – potentially armed with new and cost-efficient technologies such as WiMAX plus no legacy business – to come in and steal market share, and make the sector even more crowded. This would be welcome to consumers and would eventually spark consolidation through force of market pressures, if the regulators really do allow these to operate. But without neutrality, the cellcos will be forced to stick to a policy that has so far proved economically disastrous ‘ of adopting UMTS and its successors in the 3G bands, whether or not it is suitable to the market and business model.
When mobility was a new industry, mandating technologies such as GSM, and supporting handset subsidies (which other countries like Korea banned) stood Europe in good stead, stimulating rapid growth by creating a single market for device manufacturers and offering low cost phones to consumers. Now, the tactics are backfiring as the operators look to data and multimedia services to attract additional subscribers, only to find it hard to make a profit when they have to invest so heavily in the infrastructure and devices to support those applications.
Infrastructure sharing ought to be fairly non-controversial and moves towards this are already underway ‘ T-Mobile shares some of its networks in Germany with O2, while Vodafone and Orange plan to do the same in the UK. Consolidation is starting too ‘ T-Mobile is purchasing Orange Netherlands and T-Ring in Austria, Telefonica has bought O2 and so on. The logical extension is that, as in wired networks, a few super-operators will gradually emerge, controlling the networks on a wholesale model, an approach that also lends itself to the internet model and has been heavily promoted in the US by parties like Google ‘ though not officially mandated.
Obermann pointed to this, saying: ‘In the long run, I believe mobile will be increasingly driven by scale… and that over time, you will see global consolidation.’
Subsidies will be a thornier issue. While consolidation may temporarily reduce competition, a wholesale-driven model, along with the increasing relaxation of restrictions in some European nations on MVNOs, should avoid serious damage to consumer choice (unlike in the US). But for subscribers, handset subsidies are still seen as essential when selecting a mobile operator, and this will only change with a radically new approach, one that favors open access ‘ and therefore pushes the cellcos more quickly than they would like to go into the unprotected market.
Subsidies are a strong tactic in a new market where the operator needs to build the user base without the barrier to uptake of an expensive upfront gadget. They make little sense to the carrier in a mature market such as Europe or Japan.
‘Subsidy drove penetration. Now pre-pay subsidy is subsidizing low cost competitors. And it’s making tariffs too high,’ said T-Mobile CEO Obermann at 2005’s 3GSM conference. ‘We are at the crossroads between device cost and usage cost. Drop subsidy and we can cut tariffs. Customers want lower tariffs. They drive usage and loyalty. Subsidy needs to be cut, then removed.’
Obermann, like his fellow CEOs, argues that, without the burden of subsidies, operators would lower tariffs or invest more in new services. But the argument is hollow. For most users, adding a few hundred dollars to the upfront investment in a network would still be less welcome than a few cents off the tariff, even if the saving over the space of the contract were greater. And competing by cutting tariffs aggressively is as dangerous to the operator as subsidies, since there is no going back once customer expectations of a certain rate of charges are set. The main counterbalance to the subsidy in the operator’s spreadsheets should be customer loyalty, not high tariffs. The longer a user can be retained, the less significant the upfront investment in that customer ‘ yet, for all their talk of reducing churn, mobile carriers remain weak in many of the key areas that would achieve it, notably customer service.
Ironically, the loss of subsidies should actually improve that experience for phone users, since operators would lose their control over the customer. In an unsubsidized world, people would buy handsets at retail prices and roam on to any network they chose using multiple SIM cards. The trend would only be accelerated by the introduction of reasonably priced Wi-Fi/cellular handsets. Then the operators really would have to offer excellent service and applications in order to keep the newly liberated users on their networks, and that would mean more investment in customer response, content and software, and probably tariff rate wars as well.