Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 August 2007

Ericsson comes out of mobile TV shadows with MBMS/IPTV strategy

Ericsson has been keeping its mobile TV strategy close to its chest, apart from the odd snippet saying that it would back MBMS, the UMTS multicasting standard, rather than DVB-H, as favored by its rival Nokia. Now it may step into the limelight, as 3 Australia becomes the first operator to trial the MBMS service, creating a new front in the mobile TV battle.

Until now, Ericsson has provided systems for handling 3G unicast mobile TV with its Content Delivery System and video gateway products, and was widely expected to announce its multicasting features along with release 6 of its base station software later this year.

Last week 3 Australia announced the first trial of the MBMS service anywhere, but its move is likely to be emulated widely by the end of this year, making the UMTS standard a fourth major contender for international mobile TV deployments.

MBMS ‘Multimedia Broadcast Multicast Service ‘ was once predicted to kill off DVB-H, but is now at least a year behind it, (perhaps two as far as commercial implementation is concerned). DVB-H and other systems which rely on the creation of a dedicated network in different spectrum ‘ MediaFLO, DVB-SH and to some extent T-DMB being the others – were all quick to move to implementation around the world. But that is unlikely to mean that cellular operators won’t adopt MBMS broadly now that the time is ripe, a market that Ericsson intends to lead.

The Swedish giant’s recent acquisition of Tandberg now looks to be part of a move to create a unified IPTV/Mobile TV platform, which would use the Ericsson skill set in advanced IMS implementations.

At the IBC show in Amsterdam next month, Tandberg will show off its encoding system for mobile TV, a very different affair from its current run-of-the-mill H.264 HD encoding. The new system was announced it March, one month after Ericsson bought the company. Tandberg, with Harmonic, had carved up the encoding market for IPTV, cable and satellite, along with Motorola and Scientific Atlanta, but was unlikely to make much impact on mobile TV without a large partner. There just isn’t as much encoding power required for mobile TV, so standard hardware systems, rather than specialist hardware, are just as likely to be at the center of a standalone mobile TV encoder. The exception will be equipment for large telcos that want a single encoding suite creating digital video outputs for a variety of handheld and fixed devices , hence the Ericsson/Tandberg IPTV/mobile TV approach.

But with around 80 global trials for one form of mobile TV or another stretching back to 2004, and each one of these likely to lead to a service, requiring up to 25 mobile TV channels plus regional variations, MBMS ‘ and so Ericsson and Tandberg ‘ is very late to the mobile TV game ‘ so how are they going to prevail, especially with Europe mandating DVB-H as the technology of choice for mobile TV?

Well, easy, is the answer. Most mobile TV has resided to date on streaming servers delivering data as very low bit rate streams on top of a switched cellular service. To do that mobile operators have had to allow TV streams to compromise the amount of voice that any one base station can support, with maximums of around eight concurrent TV viewers per base station before either the backhaul is full or the voice capability of the base station suffers. And that’s with appalling video quality due to a low data rate.

It has always been understood that unicast streams would one day be relegated to the video-on-demand element of mobile TV, once better ways to deliver QVGA video were established. Companies like Orange in France and the Sprint PCS and Verizon VCast streaming services in the US have many unicast streaming channels (Orange has 63 at last count). But it makes sense that as soon as there is a better way to get the more popular channels to customers, then a number of strategy changes will happen.

First the most popular channels will be broadcast on the new separate networks, with some of this being delivered to view later, in the form of clipcasts, data files delivered in the spare capacity of a DVB-H or MediaFLO network. Then the less frequently viewed content can be relegated to two forms of VoD, streamed and file delivery. There will need to be an upgrade to the quality of handsets and more storage will have to be put on them anyway to add DVR functions, so unicast delivery can be higher quality files being delivered when the network is not busy, rather like P2P delivery in the internet. Some VoD content could also be streamed, but most people would be watching the higher resolution, more popular channels.

Some people believe that this leaves no room for MBMS and that there is an either/or strategy for MBMS and DVB-H, but there is another view. DVB-H in particular is a protocol and a solution that favors a broadcaster. It comes out of the DVB Project, and it always considered its job providing technology suitable for broadcasters, and we feel it has done this. Installing a DVB-H service can be done in a number of ways, but many of them reuse existing antenna, power cables and towers that the major TV networks already have in place. Because of this, all round the world, adoption of DVB-T for digital TV has almost automatically meant the eventual adoption of DVB-H by an individual broadcaster or by a consortium which has a broadcaster in it.

But that leaves content selection and negotiation, and most likely advertising sales, in the hands of the broadcaster and the cellular operator asking the question ‘What’s in it for me?’. Most of these services require a cellular operator to carry out the marketing and in some case the subsidy of handsets, so there is some ARPU for the cellco, but there’s little future for that operator’s existing content relationships or a chance to get a piece of the potentially lucrative mobile TV advertising market.

Many of them will move eventually to a three-tier strategy, with broadcast TV over DVB-H, MediaFLO, DVB-SH or T-DMB; high margin top range content delivered over an MBMS service, entirely controlled by cellular operators because it uses their existing infrastructure; and unicast playing a supporting role to both. MBMS-delivered content will be contracted for by the cellular operator and any advertising that comes in against it will belong either solely to the cellco or shared with a content owner.

So that ends up with a model where MBMS is the equivalent of fixed cable TV; DVB-H takes a role similar to that of free-to-air broadcasts; and unicast runs a VoD support role for both. We call this the blended model and any software that can support this at the handset, but which doesn’t show the consumer any difference between the three sources, may have the power to become a universal open platform. Finally, if you add placeshifting (as 3 already offers in some territories) you have a four-tier strategy from a single device.

It would be very hard for the European Commission to come down hard on Ericsson, which is a big European market leader, and also on any operator using MBMS from Ericsson, if it was also using DVB-H in parallel. We believe that Ericsson will work to a position where it can support this and will be pushing a ‘cost of ownership’ message that will persuade operators that, as a software upgrade, this service will be easy to run as long as each operator can dedicate a spare 5MHz of spectrum to it. MBMS doesn’t even need dedicated spectrum as it can switch itself on as a TV channel begins to be watched, taking up no more bandwidth when additional people also watch the same channel, just telling their handsets which spectrum channel to find it in. When everybody attached to one base station stops watching that channel, the spectrum that it uses is returned to the pool for voice and other activity.

It is only a strategy like this, and one that will integrate with telco-driven IPTV services that use IMS and a single encoder base for both, that will see Tandberg overtake the shrewd Thomson Grass Valley unit, which has made itself an end-to-end player in all forms of mobile TV, including encoding, without going head-to-head with Nokia to try to steal away its huge advantage in DVB-H, a technology that it virtually invented.

This analysis was originally published in Faultline, Wireless Watch’s sister service, which provides weekly analysis on key trends and business models for quad play and digital multimedia services. Please contact Linda Elisha on [email protected] for more details.

The 3 Australia trial:

The 3 Australia technical MBMS trial was held in its Sydney head office over six weeks and was run by Ericsson using four specially designed prototype handsets, Ericsson also installed equipment to simulate the content and broadcast servers on a section of 3’s network so the customer and network experience could be seen. 3 Australia has not yet said how many TV channels it managed in this set-up.

IPWireless (now part of NextWave) uses MBMS and its own TDD transmitters plugged into base stations using the 5MHz of existing unused TDD data spectrum allocated in most 3G licenses, to offer a similar system called TDtv. This system managed to fit 1Mbps for each MHz, and with 5Mbps has successfully shown 15 QVGA TV channels, so we would expect something similar from Ericsson’s system. 3 has seen TDtv working, as the system was demonstrated last October in the UK, using a MobiTV software stack on the handset, a test that was backed by all the leading operators there – 3, Orange, Telefonica O2, T-Mobile and Vodafone.

The truth is that 3 is happy to be a guinea pig for anything that might attract customers. It launched late around the world and did not have an existing customer base in GSM to rely on to shift to its 3G service, so has had to find ways to drag customers to its services in the UK, across Europe and in Australia. It will almost certainly be the first to bring this to market, as it was the first to build a DVB-H network in Italy in 2006, when everyone else was just talking about it. Expect Italy to be the first place to see a blended MBMS DVB-H service once final handset designs are ready for MBMS, which should be in early 2008.