Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 March 2006

China loses security standards bid but continues to pursue island mentality

When China backed away from a dispute over wireless security standards last year, it was widely seen as a sign that the giant economy was shifting away from its aim of creating its own standards and intellectual property base, in favor of becoming a full member of the global technology community. 2006 has seen a new hardening of its original stance, however, which seeks to make China as independent as possible of western technologies and patent fees. The country has rejuvenated its support for homegrown TD-SCDMA as the primary basis of its 3G efforts (see Wireless Watch February 27 2006 issue) and has now reawakened the debate over Wi-Fi security.

China had originally said that vendors would have to support WAPI (Wired Authentication and Privacy Infrastructure), its own alternative to the 802.11i Wi-Fi security extensions, in order to sell WLan equipment in its borders. But in order to support WAPI, non-Chinese suppliers would have to share intellectual property with Chinese partners, something that US companies bitterly opposed, suspecting Chinese attempts to reverse engineer their products. However, China backed off and retained WAPI only as an option, one that is likely to be adopted mainly for its own government systems.

Then last week, it revived the dispute, when the Ministry of Information Industry backed the establishment of the WAPI Industrial Union, which consists of 22 members, including Lenovo, Huawei and Beijing Founder Electronics, as well as China’s big four telecom operators. The aim is to promote WAPI as an international standard, an objective that was dealt a major blow a few days later when it was rejected by the International Standards Organization, leaving 802.11i the only recognized WLan security platform. Only 22% of ISO’s members supported WAPI, while 86% favored 802.11i, according to documents obtained by EE Times. Members said they were concerned that WAPI’s development process was relatively closed and that some of the underlying technology, such as security algorithms, has not been disclosed. There was also concern about WAPI’s apparent incompatibility with 802.11i and its predecessors. China had submitted its revamped WAPI proposal for fast track balloting, alongside 802.11i, in October. ISO members called for WAPI to be harmonized with 802.11i to bring China in line with the rest of the world but Chinese sources hinted this would not be on the roadmap.

This intransigence is a backward step for China and its wireless equipment makers. The country is taking an approach that has failed for several major economies before, notably India, of trying to become self-sufficient in technology. The penalty to pay for that, of course, is becoming a hi-tech island with a consequently limited role in global standards setting. In turn, that means that Chinese vendors will have less success abroad, or will have to invest in dual product plans for the domestic and international markets, hardly good news for the fast growing vendors like Huawei. Western equipment makers complain that they will have to support a separate product line in order to access the valuable Chinese market, but the same will apply to the domestic vendors. They will gain early access to Chinese patents and platforms and probably some preferential treatment at home, but that will not compensate for the burden of supporting a parallel R&D strategy, nor for the retaliatory unwillingness to buy Chinese kit that could follow in some other lucrative markets, notably the US.

China’s claim that its technologies are so superior that it will create a global market for them does not, currently at least, ring true ‘ the main wireless platforms at issue, TD-SCDMA and the security technology WAPI, have not been proven and have not attracted international interest, as the ISO decision shows. The country points to the example of GSM, which became an international system on the back of European governments’ support. But GSM was established at a time when Europe was genuinely ahead of the game in wireless, while TD-SCDMA and WAPI are both lagging the rest of the market. China would do better to bite the bullet and pay western royalties for another wireless generation and invest in producing genuinely excellent systems and intellectual property for the next evolution ‘ something it will be well within the company’s budgets and history of inventiveness to do.