Vodafone’s short term troubles are hard to avoid, with chairman Lord MacLaurin drawing further attention to them over the weekend by issuing a statement of support for embattled CEO Arun Sarin. This came amid rumors that the board was turning against Sarin, and that the potential deal to sell the Japanese arm to Softbank could fall through ‘ something that would be disastrous for Sarin, whose main short term hope of placating shareholders is offloading the troubled unit. Whatever the mistakes that have been made in Japan, however, it is very unfair that Sarin should be judged by that peculiar venture alone. While he inherited the global branding strategy of which the Japanese experience was part, he has had insights of his own that will be important to Vodafone’s ability to weather what MacLaurin called ‘changing and challenging times’. Most important has been his quiet but insistent focus on convergence, realizing that the market is headed that way and a cellular-only operator will have problems keeping up. But Vodafone has not buried its head in the sand, and as so often, the highly competitive market of Germany is where we see the first small signs of a future strategy for the fixed/mobile world.
Two significant announcements were made in Germany last week. One was the branding of the newly launched HSDPA service as ‘a genuine alternative to the fixed network’. The other was a heavy hint that Vodafone may hold on to its wireline broadband unit in the country, Arcor, possibly as a blueprint for future DSL partnerships in other countries. These will probably be essential to Vodafone in some markets, notably enterprise services and European countries where there is heavy DSL build-out. HSxPA, and possible future investments in other broadband wireless networks, could genuinely give Vodafone a single network that will deliver fixed and mobile multimedia triple play services, bypassing DSL altogether. But this will not be a reality for a couple of years and it will be hard to displace DSL and cable ‘ far better, in developed broadband markets, to work with those operators to add a mobile element to the bundle. Partnerships with wireline operators would be valuable, especially in the enterprise services market where those carriers’ footprints would better mirror Vodafone’s international reach. Surely a closer alliance with British Telecom cannot be out of the question?
On a smaller scale, Vodafone at least already has Arcor in Germany. Speaking at the CeBIT trade show in Hanover, Germany, Vodafone Germany’s CEO Friedrich Joussen suggested it was possible there would be a full integration with Arcor, in which the cellco owns a 74% stake. In the past it has planned to sell off that stake but is now expected to try to buy out its co-shareholders Deutsche Bahn and Deutsche Bank. With the value of non-incumbent DSL operators rising with the new cellco interest in convergence, there are also rumors that Telefonica and France Telecom may bid for Arcor, taking the likely price to around €2bn. In the first nine months of its current year, Arcor reported revenues up 20% year-on-year to €1.4bn.
Without wireline allies, the burden will be on HSxPA to deliver Vodafone a converged play. Launching the German service, called UMTS Broadband to reinforce the idea that this could be a DSL alternative (and to hit out at the WiMAX community’s attempts to make 802.16 synonymous with personal broadband). Vodafone Germany said it will charge €49.30 per month for the service under a two-year contract ‘without any restrictions on time or data volume’ (although the small print says there is a ceiling of 10Gb over two months).
Services will initially be available in the cities of Hanover, Frankfurt, D’sseldorf and Munich. Coverage will gradually be extended to all 1,800 German towns and cities where UMTS is already available, while the first roaming agreement for the service has been set up with Mobilkom in Austria. Where HSDPA is not available the user will be seamlessly switched to the W-CDMA or GPRS networks.
The company plans to offer a new PC data card, Mobile Connect Card UMTS Broadband, to enable laptop users to gain access to the Internet at speeds of up to 1.8Mbps. By June, it will also provide integrated laptops from Dell and Lenovo. The first handsets, from Samsung and BenQ-Siemens, will arrive around the same time.