Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 January 2006

Cisco no longer a hardware company as it spreads standards wings

Anyone who still thinks of Cisco as a hardware maker is living in a past when routers were the golden egg of the IP networking market. Cisco’s greatest asset is its understanding of, and intellectual property in, IP, with software technologies that could increasingly be applied to multiple hardware platforms. So while the giant will aggressively defend its massive market share in enterprise networks, in emerging sectors it will take a different approach. We believe it will be slower to launch hardware, but will seek control through setting standards and asserting intellectual property rights. Its real power will, like Qualcomm’s, come from its control over vital aspects of IP technology, which no vendor will be able to ignore as the carrier and enterprise worlds move towards all-IP fixed/mobile, wired/wireless networks.

This is already clear in Cisco’s advanced work on IP Multimedia Subsystem and 3G-WiMAX integration (see separate item). With both these developments, it is focusing on software and partnering with different hardware makers, rather than facing these head-on in the telco hardware market, where it lacks the market grip it has in the corporate world. But it is offering those telcos some key benefits, notably multivendor systems support and pragmatic, step-by-step routes to all-IP, which may have the appearance of openness because they run with different vendors’ switches and base stations, but which infiltrate Cisco proprietary software into the core of the network, giving it a more unassailable position than any base station even when standards take hold.

Always busy in standards ‘ even when trying to fend them off to protect its own platforms ‘ Cisco is now in a frenzy of activity and seeking to take the driving seat in a wide range of wireless platforms. As well as carrier IP networks, Wi-Fi is an important area. We have seen how Cisco has managed to make the LWAPP (Lightweight Access Point Protocol), which it acquired with Airespace, the basis of an IETF standard for managing Wi-Fi APs in a large network. Once this protocol was anathema to Cisco because it encourages heterogeneous WLans, but now the giant is looking beyond tying companies into its APs ‘ which carry increasingly narrow margins anyway ‘ and is seeking control through intellectual property and middleware. It has also managed to put Airespace technology at the heart of the 802.11r standard for fast hand-off between Wi-Fi access points, essential for voice over IP, video streaming and other applications.

Also in Wi-Fi, Cisco is being aggressive about promoting its ?? for the important metrozone mesh sector as a de facto standard and will undoubtedly work to give this a prominent place in the emerging 802.11s standard for Wi-Fi mesh.

And on the short range wireless front, Cisco has interestingly made an undisclosed investment in Zensys, developer of the Z-Wave personal area mesh technology, which it puts forward as an alternative to the IEEE’s ZigBee standard. This raises the possibility that Cisco will seek to establish Z-Wave, for which Zensys is the only silicon vendor, as a broader de facto standard, playing on its advantages over ZigBee, such as longer battery life and greater range, while attracting a more heavyweight support base.

Like Intel, Cisco knows its real power lies behind the scenes and in influencing the whole network picture from personal area to cellular. It may be the only major network hardware vendor without a WiMAX product plan, but this certainly does not mean that it is failing to take account of emerging technologies ‘ it is merely recognizing the shift in the balance of power towards the owners of core software and IP-related intellectual property.