Last week brought two long running standards sagas to a conclusion, with contrasting results. The IEEE 802.15.3a taskgroup, which was working towards a short range networking platform based on UltraWideBand, disbanded in the face of technology stalemate and the presence of a similar standard from the ECMA body. Meanwhile, the 802.11n group, focused on fast Wi-Fi, and which had faced the risk of a similar meltdown, rescued its efforts by agreeing to adopt a compromise proposal supported, however reluctantly, by all factions. The 802.11n crisis may have been handled more adroitly and with a greater willingness to compromise, but in both cases the really significant moves are coming from key chipmakers, which are increasingly pre-empting industry standards and driving, rather than following, industry bodies.
The two factions which had been proposing 802.15.3a standards – Freescale’s UWB Forum and the Intel/Texas Instruments/Sony WiMedia Alliance ‘ took the official line that they would both continue to develop their approaches and let the market decide. In reality, while there are likely to be applications for the UWB Forum’s DS-UWB approach, WiMedia has won the day and will be the only real standard. The 802.15.3a effort was fatally weakened when the WiMedia Alliance decided to create its own MAC (media access control), defying IEEE requirement to use the existing 802.15.3 MAC. The IEEE activity was then entirely doomed when WiMedia took its technology – which has the backing of most of the crucial consumer electronics vendors ‘ to an alternative standards body, ECMA, and gained ratification. That specification will now be submitted to the International Standards Organization (ISO).
It would have been highly unusual for the IEEE not to back away in the face of a rival standard, and anyway, the stalemate between the two 802.15.3a proposals could have persisted until the work had to wind up anyway, since neither side has shown the willingness to rescue the standard through compromise.
The UWB Forum and the WiMedia Alliance issued a joint statement, saying very little: “As the industry organizations dedicated to productization, we thank all contributing TG3a members and voters for their respective efforts during the past three years. However, we concur that, at this stage in UWB market development, a more prudent course of action is necessary to allow the market to move forward with the commercialization of multiple UWB technologies.”
Perhaps learning from the UWB fiasco, the 802.11n group has been far more flexible, even in the face of a breakaway group, Enhanced Wireless Consortium, being formed by Intel, Broadcom, Marvell and others last year. Rather than lose face altogether, the groups active in the 802.11n effort have instead chosen to adopt the EWC proposals, which are backed by the makers of 90% of the world’s Wi-Fi chips as well as many major vendors. Intel and its allies have, in effect, held a gun to the IEEE process, but at least key features such as compatibility with the other 802.11 standards have been preserved.
The IEEE taskgroup has unanimously confirmed the EWC’s proposal as its draft specification. It still has to be balloted, edited and accepted by the board before it is ratified, which could take at least another year. Additions created by the EWC focus on the areas of beam forming and space’time block coding, both methods of improving the reliability of data transmissions, which are also important in 802.16e. The specification also includes improved power management for handheld devices, which was originally going to be the subject of a separate 802.11 extension.
As in UWB, however, fast Wi-Fi makers have been seeking to ‘let the market decide’ well in advance of the 802.11n standard, which despite the new harmony will not be finally ratified until 2007. Chipset makers such as start-up Airgo ‘ the main loser from the decision to back EWC, since its smart antennas were at the heart of the rival submission ‘ and Atheros have been promising ‘pre-802.11n’ capabilities, with speeds of 120Mbps and more, for at least a year. And less then 24 hours after the IEEE taskgroup announced its compromise draft proposal, market leader Broadcom announced sampling of its Intensi-fi 802.11n chipset and Marvell followed with a similar announcement.
This indicates the sinister side of the growing practise of assembling groups of allies outside the standards body and then returning to present the organization with a fait accompli. It is a chance for vendors to manipulate conditions to ensure they have a technological headstart ‘ the first 802.11n chips to sample are from EWC co-founders Broadcom and Marvell, while non-EWC members, notably Airgo, have now been outmanoeuvered and will need to catch up lost ground.
However, the developments also show that standards bodies are increasingly too slow to meet evolving market requirements ‘ far from being a vendor gimmick, ‘pre-n’ products like Belkin’s Airgo-based range have been enthusiastically welcomed by the consumer public, especially in the US. More and more, we will see standards efforts merely rubber stamping developments that have already gained significant traction, in pre-standard form, in the market, or being presented with faits accomplis by the largest suppliers.
Broadcom was almost the inventor of ‘pre-standard’ behaviour in the IEEE wireless world. Its master stroke, which propelled it from the minor league to the top three in Wi-Fi chipset stakes, was to bring out 802.11g products ahead of the official standard. The strategy was widely condemned, mainly by less bold competitors, but gained the chipmaker a huge market headstart. It had spotted, with the acute timing that characterizes its approach, that the consumer market was more than ready to buy 54Mbps Wi-Fi in volume and that it would not be as concerned with standards guarantees as the enterprise sector.
Broadcom, encountering a hail of criticism of its latest attempt to leapfrog its rivals, pointed to the previous experience, saying that sampling was no more aggressive than for the 802.11g market. Indeed, with only minor changes expected between this draft and the final version of 802.11n, there will be less risk in adopting Intensi-Fi than the enhanced 802.11g offerings that came to the market last year, from Broadcom itself, Atheros, Airgo and others. These, while complying with the standard, use proprietary enhancements to achieve n-class speeds, meaning that, to achieve the full performance, customers are locked into a single platform at both ends. There is a risk of incompatibility between Intensi-Fi for 802.11n and devices based on the final standard, but this should require less technical tweaking to rectify ‘ in Broadcom’s view, a software patch should suffice.
Buying semi-proprietary and pre-standard chips and equipment will always carry risk but vendors also need to keep ahead of the game and offer new products constantly to their customer base, especially in an increasingly low margin business like Wi-Fi consumer gear, where 802.11n will mainly be relevant. Whatever the rights and wrongs, sales cycles mean that, in future, standards will be created in the market and by major chipmakers, with the standards bodies serving increasingly as talking shops for devising new blue sky requirements, and ratification units once the market has made its choice.