Ahead of their merger, slated for late 2008, Clearwire and Sprint Nextel’s former Xohm unit have set out their stall at an investor event, unsurprisingly choosing to focus on the area where they have an undisputed advantage over rivals, their massive spectrum holdings.
The merged venture will have an average of 120MHz of 2.5GHz spectrum across the mainland US, a bandwidth of which most mobile broadband operators round the world could only dream. This will give the new Clearwire a significant advantage – in terms of delivering advanced, bandwidth hungry services; and of supporting heavy levels of usage at low and flat rates ‘ over the other would-be mobile broadband leaders, Verizon and AT&T, both of which plan to deploy LTE, initially in their new 700MHz holdings.
“We believe the LTE operators will be hard pressed to find the spectrum to build a nationwide broadband network,” Clearwire’s CTO John Saw said at the analyst event. And the venture’s CEO, Scott Wolff, said this amount of bandwidth would enable the operator to deliver download speeds of between 6Mbps and 15Mbps to each user, at an affordable flat tariff, and still at a profit for Clearwire. Unlike in the voice and early data markets, where network technologies have been optimized for narrow channels and the challenge has often been to use up spare capacity, in mobile broadband massive bandwidth will be key to the difficult equation of balancing operator margins with the fast data speeds, unrestricted browsing, and flat, low tariffs that users will demand from the mobile internet. Although WiMAX and LTE are spectrally highly efficient, through their use of advanced OFDMA-based technologies and other advances, the sheer increase in volume of data and multimedia usage will still mean that operators need at least 30MHz of spectrum to make a convincing commercial case for mobile broadband in many markets ‘ and when moving into high definition mobile TV and other intensive applications, far larger swathes would be preferable, especially if these are concentrated in a single band, like Clearwire’s, to avoid over-reliance on multiband systems, or fragmentation of the network.
But of course Clearwire will have many other challenges. Verizon and AT&T are looking aggressive in their timescales for LTE roll-out, at least to the business and urban centers where all the operators will find their richest 4G pickings. With LTE likely to be the dominant next generation standard, its adopters will gain superior economies of scale once the platform hits volume, if there is not the potential harmonization with WiMAX. And while the ‘new Clearwire’ will have the flexibility, dynamism and lack of legacy that has driven the ‘old Clearwire’ in its start-up phase, it will also have to live with some of the legacy of its Sprint co-parent, plus the burden of having a relatively unfamiliar brand and unproven technology.
Digging into some detail on the new Clearwire’s plans, Wolff said it would focus on “residential broadband, residential voice, mobile broadband and mobile voice”, and later will move to differentiating services that harness the spectrum advantage, such as wireless HDTV and mobile gaming. The company is not adhering to the common line that WiMAX is really only about data ‘ even though it will “lead with data”, according to chief strategy officer Scott Richardson, it is still planning to offer services in future that take on the cellcos directly. ‘We are going to be the first operator in the US to deliver mobile voice over IP,’ he promised ‘ though there was no timescale or technological detail. Of course, there may be some resistance from the Sprint side of the parentage to offerings that could attack its own CDMA base, rather than providing additional services and revenues, with multimode devices and roaming on to wide area CDMA potentially boosting usage of its older network.
Otherwise, the Clearwire team repeated the high level targets the company set out when the joint venture agreement was unveiled. It plans to cover 100m US citizens by the end of 2010, and reach 200m by 2015. Wolff reiterated that the company would only need $2bn to $2.3bn of additional capital – on top of the $3.2bn invested by Google, Intel and the cablecos – to complete its planned network. Assuming the operator sticks to the plan to reach 200m ‘ which is well beyond what is mandated by the FCC, and so could be scaled back if the ROI looks shaky or new financing is not forthcoming ‘ CFO John Butler said the firm should be able to achieve revenues of $17.5bn by 2017 with an expected 30m customers.
Wolff also referred to Clearwire’s non-US spectrum holdings and the potential to add to revenues and global roaming through these networks and through partnerships. “We’ve got it in Canada, Mexico and throughout South America,” he said, and hinted at further bids to add to its European holdings, perhaps in the upcoming 2.5GHz auctions.