Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 June 2008

Sprint launches Qchat at last, and may spark push to talk war

So many things have gone wrong for Sprint Nextel in the past year that doubts have even arisen over some of the key areas of hope that it might turn itself around in future. One of those has been its push to talk service, which was Nextel’s killer app for years on its iDEN network, and which is now set to bridge that declining system and Sprint’s CDMA. Back at the Mobile World Congress in February, the project seemed to be delayed and in trouble, and there was even fear that it would be derailed by technical hitches and Qualcomm’s licensing headaches. But on Friday, the new service, based on Qualcomm’s Qchat technology, duly rolled out on CDMA at last, in 40 markets including most major US cities. But even as Sprint Nextel hopes to transfer some of the old Nextel PTT magic to CDMA as its ARPU and customer retention come under constant pressure, it is facing its first really credible challenge in the PTT market, from Verizon Wireless.

The delays to the new Qchat service may have eaten up most of the time to market advantage that Sprint Nextel enjoyed thanks to Nextel’s entrenched position in this application, and its deep knowledge of the market and user behavior within it. So Verizon will launch its copycat service this summer, and is likely (though unconfirmed) to target as big a footprint, or to spread even further.

The emergence of two modern services on CDMA could raise the profile of PTT as a key service with which operators can lure customers and boost revenues. Since its heyday with Nextel, PTT has been overshadowed somewhat, given the decline in availability and quality on iDEN, and the lack of any real alternative. Now that has changed, other operators may revive their interest ‘ for instance, AT&T could put proper effort behind its nascent offering ‘ and there will be pressure for carriers to work on interoperability and roaming between PTT networks.

There have been many false starts on the road to replicating the success of Nextel iDEN PTT on other networks. Sprint (pre-merger) and Verizon both tried to challenge Nextel with a PTT-over-CDMA 1X system based on Motorola’s Winphoria technology and using the CDMA voice channel, but this failed to deliver the same performance and features as the iDEN version, which was integrated directly into the architecture itself. By contrast, Qchat uses the data capabilities of EV-DO and VoIP, while the move towards deploying an IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem) would theoretically allow Sprint to meld the PTT service with other applications, as well as mediate sessions between CDMA and legacy iDEN network. Integration with IMS was one headache, since the SIP protocol on which IMS is based was far slower at initiating PTT sessions than the sub-second call initiation of iDEN. Finally, Sprint wrote a faster, but proprietary protocol to manage the QChat sessions across both networks, and even after achieving that, it took nine months to kick off trials, and another quarter before going live.

It is not clear what technology Verizon will use for its challenger. The Sprint Qchat platform incorporates large amounts of collaborative development by the operator and Qualcomm, and so is exclusive to the second CDMA carrier, but its larger rival could use another version of QChat, which is part of the Qualcomm BREW application deck.

Both operators can benefit from recent enhancements to the CDMA 1X RTT technology, the ‘2.5G’ iteration of the network, which could make PTT services more profitable. Qualcomm promised earlier this year to double voice capacity, and make room for more EV-DO data channels ‘ vital if Qchat proves as popular as the old Nextel service. The enhancement is achieved using reverse link interference cancellation technology in Qualcomm’s base station chips. This will free up enough capacity on the 1.25MHz channel to double call volume from the typical 35 sessions, says the chipmaker, and this will allow operators to reduce the number of channels dedicated to 1X, and therefore add new EV-DO carriers for broadband data capacity (EV-DO does not carry voice, except in network-inefficient VoIP form, so increasing data capacity involves sacrificing voice capacity on most CDMA networks. This problem will be solved as carriers upgrade to EV-DO Rev B, which supports VoIP very efficiently, but most operators will want to make use of their 1X networks for voice for as long as possible because of the superior economics, especially if they roll services like PTT out to rural areas).

Even Sprint and Verizon Wireless, which have made significant progress with EV-DO Rev A, are only likely to have a single 1.25MHz EV-DO channel in most markets, and the cost of deploying a second is high, and will lead to a reduction in voice capacity. When introducing a potentially high usage data service like PTT, this balancing act becomes delicate, especially for an operator like Sprint with little leeway to lose out on quality of service or margin.

Two major PTT launches in the US may drive progress with PTT interoperability across different carriers’ networks, in the same way that SMS interworking developed once the service became popular. The roll-out of Qchat over both CDMA and iDEN shows PTT can bridge two networks owned by the same carrier, though this has required significant effort and investment from Sprint, and it is unlikely to share its innovations with rivals, since it needs to treat PTT as a key differentiator, for the time being at least. Technically, Verizon-Sprint interoperability would not be a huge hurdle, if it becomes commercially desirable, since both use CDMA and both will probably use a variant of Qchat. But the other main PTT platform, from Kodiak Networks, is incompatible. This is used by AT&T, Alltel, MetroPCS and some other regional US operators, as well as some international players like Orange ‘ though PTT has never taken off outside the US as well as within it, lacking a carrier with a strong offering and the motivation to push the technology. In Europe, operators have worked with another specialist, Sonim Technologies, to develop an interoperable PTT standard, called PTT over Cellular (PoC), but while this has been given token support in Europe and parts of Asia, it has gained little traction in the US.