Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 June 2008

Operators light fire under standards as WiMAX Forum certifies wave two

Operators are taking an increasingly dominant role in developing new wireless standards, having accused vendor groups in the past of delivering them technologies that did not meet their commercial requirements. Now they are determined to guide the development of 4G, and the traditional wireless bodies are accepting the inevitable. This week, the GSMA agreed to work closely with the Next Generation Mobile Network (NGMN) Alliance, the most important operator-controlled body in this market, on future standards like LTE, an indication of how the carriers’ needs can no longer be put in second place. Supporters of LTE hope that this more explicit alliance with the technology’s potential customers will maintain the relatively quick pace of standards setting and early trials that the would-be 4G platform has so far enjoyed. This currently contrasts with the hesitant progress of the WiMAX Forum, which announced its first certified products for wave two of the 802.16e-based standard this week, but centered on a much reduced subset of the full specifications.

Operator involvement can certainly accelerate the process ‘ the Femto Forum, which is defining standards for the miniature base stations and has heavy cellco involvement, has submitted its core interface specifications to the 3GPP in record time, and it will tackle interference management next week, with a view to having a standard by year end. This is breakneck speed compared to most wireless efforts, though of course this Forum is focusing on a relatively specialized area and has fewer vendors, and less political legacy, to deal with than older bodies (though it now boasts over 100 members). The Forum’s marketing chief, Rupert Baines of picoChip, believes the deep involvement of carriers from day one has helped achieve the speedy progress, since operators are not interested in politics or even very much in technology, providing they get a functional product in a timescale that fits their commercial plans. The CTOs of key movers and shakers like O2 and Vodafone basically ‘locked us in a room and said we weren’t leaving’ until there was a standard, Baines recounts.

Many would argue that more WiMAX Forum meetings over the years should have taken this approach, since the ‘other 4G standard’ now risks losing its enviable headstart on LTE, levelling the playing field for operators looking to move to mobile broadband, especially from CDMA or wireline bases (natural markets, along with DSL replacement, for WiMAX). At the WiMAX Forum Congress in Amsterdam this week, there was progress ‘ the first commercial networks in Europe; more plans for expansion by Sprint and Clearwire (see separate item); the first certified wave two products. But the good news was overshadowed by the sense that, despite some pushes into the LTE heartland of Europe, WiMAX remains a technology that relies too much on its one flagship operator, the soon-to-be enlarged Clearwire. WiMAX has actually made good inroads in many developing markets, such as India and Pakistan, via Motorola and the specialist vendors, and these territories, and traditional applications like fixed or nomadic access, remain a strong and natural target base, where LTE will hardly roam. But the public face of the Forum remains fixated on developed markets and mobile broadband applications, and that means Sprint/Clearwire. While it maybe good to have operators heavily involved in standards and certification processes, too much influence from one carrier risks compromising the interests of less glamorous, but potentially more successful, supporters.

However, the Forum was at last able to boast of some wave two products, whose key defining feature is support for MIMO, even if many vendors were complaining that the initial certification relied on only a subset of the full wave two spec; was really geared to Sprint/Clearwire and their need to build an ecosystem of interoperable devices; that certified products could still be changed and would likely have to go through further processes to meet future ‘full wave two’ requirements. The dilemma ‘ comprehensiveness or time to market ‘ is one familiar to the wireless world, and has particularly dogged the IEEE stable of standards. The Wi-Fi Alliance adopted the route of devising interim standards en route to the fully blown specs, and currently the industry is busily shipping ‘draft 802.11n’ gear with Alliance kitemarks.

The products that have achieved initial wave two WiMAX Forum branding consist of four base stations and six mobile terminals. The vendors are Alvarion, Motorola, Samsung and Sequans for base stations and Airspan, Beceem, Intel, Samsung, Sequans and Zyxel for mobile station modules.

All passed the ‘mandatory MIMO testing protocols’ in the 2.5GHz band. This base set of protocols and the choice of band have been heavily driven by the program of Sprint and Clearwire ‘ which are to merge, possibly by year end ‘ to roll out WiMAX to a large number of markets over the coming months.

Ed Iges, co-chair of the WiMAX Forum’s certification working group, said that certification for MIMO for 2.5GHz sets the stage for the quick implementation of future profiles. Initial wave two progress was slow because of the complexities of MIMO, he said in an interview. “The challenge has been getting MIMO on the uplink,” he said. “It’s not easy to certify having multiple scenarios. What happens on MIMO is that we are adding more stress to the base station.”

The Forum will begin to accept certification applications for 3.5GHz equipment during the third quarter, with testing to begin in the fourth quarter and certification before the end of the year. The Forum estimates that more than 100 Mobile WiMAX products will be certified by the end of 2008, and 1,000 by 2011.

Meanwhile, as Sprint and Clearwire, their investors reassured by the prospect of their well funded joint venture, ramp up their roll-out plans for a national US network, WiMAX is starting to gain some inroads in potentially its most hostile territory, western Europe, where most implementations to date have been small scale and confined to nomadic services. Now the Netherlands and France have announced breakthroughs. At the WiMAX Forum Congress, WorldMAX showed off a commercial network using 802.16e in the Dutch capital Amsterdam, while Motorola announced it had won a contract from French telecoms and TV operator TDF to design and deploy several regional 802.16e systems. The areas are all covered by 3.5GHz licences won by TDF’s subsidiary, HDRR.

Of course, such roll-outs are small fry compared to the potential mobile broadband networks that will be deployed when Europe auctions 2.5GHz spectrum on a wide basis. With the UK auction ‘ where British Telecom could conceivably win a license and adopt WiMAX ‘ delayed, only two countries have sold licenses so far, and most of the activity will come in 2009 and later, by which time the natural contender, LTE, should be well on the way to commercial availability. Of course LTE is sure to hit technological and certification roadblocks too, but the operators are making it clear, via the NGMN Alliance, that they will be impatient of delays, and will be determined to drive the process forward.

So, the GSMA and the NGMN Alliance have formally agreed to cooperate to help steer the development of mobile broadband standards, and specifically to ensure that users of next generation networks, primarily LTE, can roam onto GSM, W-CDMA and HSPA networks. This is vital to the success of any mobile broadband standard, since most operators will want to interoperate with the networks that cover 80% of the world’s population, and often to deploy ‘4G’ initially in limited hotzones. The effort that will go into LTE/W-CDMA/GSM roaming could prove a significant advantage to the technology over WiMAX, which has various methods of handing off to GSM, but has enjoyed less attention from operators and vendors in terms of optimizing this roaming capability. By contrast, the GSMA and the NGMN Alliance will develop both commercial frameworks and technical platforms necessary to ensure seamless roaming across the whole GSM family of networks.

The two groups have also agreed to cooperate in other essential areas related to the development of next generation mobile broadband services, such as intellectual property rights and spectrum requirements.

‘Now is the time for the mobile operator community to bring together all the pieces that are needed to ensure that our industry can meet the rapidly rising global demand for mobile broadband services in the decade beyond 2010,’ said Alex Sinclair, CTO of the GSMA, in a statement. ‘This agreement with the NGMN Alliance will help ensure that users of the mobile broadband networks of the future will enjoy all the benefits, such as economies of scale, global roaming and interoperability, inherent in the GSM ecosystem today.’

Dr Peter Meissner, chief operating officer of the NGMN Alliance, added: ‘Our agreement is not just about liaison, it is project driven and we have clearly identified those areas where the mobile industry needs to cooperate. We are happy to share our milestone achievements in technology evaluation, trials, IPR and spectrum.’