When the Covid-19 pandemic first hit the western world, the most immediate impact on 5G was widely expected to be a rise in demand for high speed mobile broadband – to support flexible working and online entertainment, combined with delays to spectrum auctions and network build-outs.
The picture of rising demand, and lack of capacity to address it, loomed large in the early comments of operators and vendors, but in fact, the picture has been very different.
Some auctions have been postponed, such as Belgium’s (until late 2021), and disrupted access to labor and sites did push back some roll-outs. But many European operators, privately or sometimes publicly, admitted they welcomed some breathing space to firm up their 5G business plans, while some regulators, like that of New Zealand, thought creatively and replaced auctions with alternative allocation procedures. In countries where operators felt more urgency to deliver 5G, the pace picked up rapidly once initial lockdowns ended, as T-Mobile’s deployments indicate.
Meanwhile a great deal of broadband usage shifted from mobile to fixed lines as people were confined to homes, so neither the feared capacity crunch, nor the sudden sharp uptick in demand for 5G, materialized.
What did not change, however, was the demand for new spectrum. This might not be to meet an immediate overloading of 5G networks, but does relate to changing operator concerns as a result, at least partially, of the pandemic. A Rethink survey of over 50 MNOs in Europe and North America, about changes to their near term (2020 and 2021) 5G plans as a result of Covid-19, revealed an acceleration in many operators’ plans to migrate to cloud-based core and even RAN, but with an even firm focus on convincing return on investment (ROI) models than ever before.
That means delivering a wider range of services, with a wider range of connectivity requirements, to suit larger numbers of customers (especially under-tapped bases like enterprise and industrial), all at far lower cost.
All this requires a new approach to spectrum, and several changes will be accelerated by operator, consumer and regulator response to the pandemic:
- Operators want more variety of spectrum in order to build what T-Mobile calls its layer cake – a combination of low band, midband and millimeter wave frequencies to support the most cost-efficient mixture of broad coverage, high capacity and hotspots of extra-high capacity for specific locations or applications.
- They need to access different spectrum at different price points. US operators may be about to splash out on the C-band auction (see below) but overall, MNOs are increasingly resistant to paying high prices at auction for every single band, and some governments are recognizing that, with operators’ valuations under pressure from impending recession, they may have to sacrifice some Treasury revenues from spectrum in return for achieving 5G socio-economic goals.
- And they need spectrum that can be optimized for specific, high value business cases, whether that is for V2X (with the battle over the USA’s vehicular bands finally approaching resolution) or for private industrial usage (licences, for instance, that can be acquired for specific locations and then harnessed for private networks or high performance slices).
Many of the issues outlined here are showcased first in US debates and deliberations over spectrum. The latest row to split operators, the Internet industry and others in that country is over the 12 GHz spectrum (see below).
One of the USA’s landmark recent rulings has been to open up the 6 GHz band for unlicensed wireless broadband use, a development that has mainly been exploited by the WiFi industry, despite a Chinese-centric bid by the 5G sector to claim some of it for licensed use. (It remains to be seen, when 5G-Unlicensed standards are commercialized, whether there is a repeat of the largely failed LTE bid to run cellular networks in the same bands as WiFi.)
Now there are calls for other regulators, in Europe in particular, to hasten their efforts to open up 6 GHz for WiFi too. But the WiFi segment has not won all its battles in the USA – for V2X, its DSRC technology has lost out to cellular C-V2X.
In the end, the resolution of some of these long-running differences, and a more creative approach to allocating spectrum for different business models and operator types, may have been stimulated by the pressures of pandemic and recession, but in general, as we near the end of 2020, the impact on the spectrum landscape is not very different from what was expected before Covid-19 reared its head. The uses to which the spectrum is put, however, may be a different story.