Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 November 2020

MNOs ready to splash out $50bn on US C-band auction

Big names will contend with less well known bidders in the US C-band auction coming up on December 8th amid speculation it could raise $50bn. The US has come quite late to the C-band party as many other countries have already allocated spectrum in this band that was previously devoted to satellite. As a result, the auction will come close to completing the distribution of that precious midband spectrum in the US, often dubbed the sweet spot for 5G because of its combination of bandwidth, performance and range.

The C-band is allocated by individual countries, even within the EU, with the range at the bottom end varying. In Europe it is usually 3.4-4.2 GHz, in some Asian countries 3.3-4.2 GHz, and in the US 3.7-4.2 GHz. The smaller range in the USA reflects occupation of the bands just below by the country’s Department of Defense, but some of that is also being relinquished for commercial use.

Of that US C-band, current satellite users are being pushed upstairs as it were into the upper part of the band to leave the 3.7-3.98 GHz portion free for the FCC to auction off on December 8. This has attracted qualified bidders almost like vultures for this highly prized spectrum, almost the sweet spot within the sweet spot.

Along with the four MNOs AT&T, Verizon, T-Mobile US and US Cellular, we have others seeking to exploit their own infrastructures in various ways. These include the big cable companies, with Comcast and Charter Communications bidding under one name, C&C Wireless Holding Company, while satellite company Dish is coming in as Little Bear Wireless by some reports, all seeking to complement existing broadband and pay TV offerings with 5G. There has also been interest from lesser known communication brands and some renewable energy companies perhaps looking to exploit their physical infrastructure.

One reason for the US auction being later than many other countries is that satellite companies have been resisting. Clearance for the December auction only came in June 2020 when a court allowed the FCC to go ahead after finally rejecting a request by four satellite operators to delay the process further. These included Intelsat and SES, both based in Luxembourg, which had argued the reallocation unfairly benefited competitors that would gain some of that spectrum. Instead, these satellite platform operators were compensated for vacating that spectrum to the tune of $14.7bn between them.

At almost the same time as that court ruling, the US government announced it would also redeploy for commercial 5G 100 MHz spectrum currently used for military applications in the 3.45-3.55GHz band. This is likely to be auctioned later in 2021 and then a total of 530 MHz continuous spectrum would be free in the midband, giving US 5G services in general a significant boost by being able to offer higher capacity services over a significant footprint.

There is also talk of going even further and vacating yet more midband in the lower 3 GHz range, that is 3.1-3.55 GHz range. Currently this appears to be occupied for classified defense applications that are not openly acknowledged as there are no official occupants. This will take longer to resolve but there will be considerable pressure to make it available. Interference mitigation for sensitive military applications could be an issue to resolve if they are compressed into a smaller band close to the commercial 5G services.

The band 3.3-3.7 GHz was one of the main frequency bands identified for mobile use at the last World Radiocommunication Conference in 2015 (WRC-15) across all three ITU regions. Since then, this has emerged as a core 5G band to enable high speed enhanced MBB services capable of peak download speeds of at least 20Gbps, combined with consistent 100Mbps data rate in urban areas, and 4ms latency, with reasonable range.

The 3.5 GHz band is best placed to provide both the capacity and coverage, leading the 3GPP to specify this for 5G in tandem with existing LTE deployments. As a result, early development of 5G equipment has focused particularly on this band, which was also a priority for spectrum auction. As one of many examples, the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Enterprise (MINECO), concluded an auction of 5G spectrum in the 3.6-3.8 GHz band for €437.6 ($490m), as early as July 2018.