The US direct broadcast satellite (DBS) players, Echostar and DirecTV, are taking bold moves to counter their slow growth, massive cost base and lack of a broadband return path to support a quad play offering. The companies have been mulling close collaboration or even merger for a year and more, in their quest to cut costs, and the stage may be set for that move now, as Echostar and DirecTV’s majority shareholder, John Malone’s Liberty Media, make a joint bid for global satellite communications provider Intelsat. As well as indicating closer relations between the rivals, such a deal shows the pressure to broaden their business model. It would bring them greater firepower in space and a stake in the once despised, but now reviving, mobile satellite business, with a particular emphasis on wholesaling. Addressing the need for two-way broadband in another way, the DBS rivals/partners are also set finally to sign the long awaited deal to use Clearwire’s 2.5GHz WiMAX network in the US – an agreement that, given Clearwire chief Craig McCaw’s long time involvement in the satellite game, is likely to go far deeper than a simple wholesaling deal.
Intelsat’s new owner should be revealed later this week, with Liberty/Echostar, satellite player Loral, and two private equity groups (the UK’s BC Partners and a consortium of Providence Equity Partners, Carlyle Group and Macquarie Bank) understood to be the contenders. The expected price tag is between $4.5bn and $5.5bn plus the assumption of $11.5bn of debt. Many analysts are tipping hyperactive PE group BC Partners to emerge victorious, an outcome that would not necessarily prevent a deal with Liberty in future, and even one that might attract less antitrust attention than a direct Echostar-Intelsat-DirecTV consolidation. BC would be the latest in a line of private equity owners for Intelsat – a consortium of Apax Partners, Permira, Apollo Management and Madison Dearborn Partners bought the company for about $3.1bn in 2004 and aquired rival PanAmSat, also in PE hands for $3.2bn the following year.
Intelsat is the largest commercial satellite operator in the world with a fleet of 51, which would bring Echostar some valuable new revenue streams in wholesaling as well as the chance to offer two-way and mobile satellite services, either as part of a quad play along with the DBS and Clearwire elements, or standalone (the latter giving Liberty an extended international reach and access to emerging economies with limited infrastructure). Last year, Echostar CEO Charles Ergen indicated that the company needed to broaden its scope beyond television broadcasting, and that it would invest in new satellites, largely for wholesale – despite the differences in technology and network configuration for this business compared to TV. Acquiring Intelsat would give the company this new business readymade, and on a global scale. And in a world where rival operators will increasingly pool resources on the infrastructure side, even if they continue to sell services under their own competing brands, it would also be possible for Echostar to maintain some of Intelsat’s content distribution contracts with rivals such as cablecos – the cable TV sector is its largest revenue generator. This would be just another sign that infrastructure is once again becoming an asset not a millstone – the fiber and satellite capacity gluts of the telecoms crash are giving way to a race to deliver quad plays and high definition services, and to backhaul an exploding build-out of wireless networks round the world. All this requires bandwidth, and Liberty could use a major satellite fleet not just to extend its own retail businesses in home television and, potentially, mobile satellite, but position itself as one of the key backbones of the broadband explosion, along with the international fiber giants.
Even if Liberty/Echostar loses out to BC or Loral, the brief cooperation will have set important new precedents and almost certainly will lead to further collaboration. Already, Echostar and DirecTV have decided to make a joint deal with Clearwire to use its broadband wireless network, mirroring the alliance of the four major cablecos with Sprint (though not necessarily going as far as that group, which has adopted a common brand for wireless). Not only does the Clearwire agreement show the two US DBS players coming even closer together, but it draws McCaw into their orbit. Jimmy Schaeffler, chairman of satellite consultancy Carmel Group, said: ‘Now you’re adding Craig McCaw to the mix ‘ he’s another guy who left the terrestrial business to get into satellite big time. You’ve got Craig McCaw, John Malone and Charlie Ergen, and that is just a remarkable combination.’
In particular, it is worth remembering that, as well as Clearwire, McCaw controls ICO, one of three companies (along with MSV and Terrestar) that gained a license last year to operate hybrid terrestrial/mobile satellite networks in the US. ICO is now working with Alcatel-Lucent on a system to combine satellite and wireless for mobile television, which could be a very useful adjunct to the Echostar fixed satellite TV offerings.
Though best known for his terrestrial wireless activities – notably McCaw Cellular and Nextel, plus the less successful Nextlink (now XO) – McCaw has been a major figure in satellite communications for almost two decades, and ridden the rollercoaster of that sector. In 1990 he set up Callings Communications, which later became Teledesic, and had a hugely over ambitious boom-period plan to build a fleet of up to 900 satellites (costed at $9bn, but never built when likely costs looked to reach $20bn). McCaw invested heavily in Teledesic, as did Microsoft, and also ploughed $1.2bn to buy satellite phone operator ICO out of bankruptcy. The two companies were then merged in 2000 into ‘the new ICO’ but has continued to experience volatile performance, as the mobile satellite business has persistently failed to deliver on its potential and the company currently has very low revenues. Now the great opportunity for ICO lies in the ability to offer hybrid wireless/satellite services, combining the bandwidth and relatively low capex costs of the former with the reach of the latter, with strong potential in mobile TV. An alliance of Clearwire in 2.5GHz, ICO with its 20MHz of 2GHz hybrid spectrum, and potentially Echostar with its TV network, could provide a powerful challenger to the quad play activities of the wireless/telco giants and cablecos. Satellite analyst firm TMF Associates predicts that MSS could capture 16m US users by 2015 if one or more operators partner with a satellite TV provider to fund a new nationwide 4G wireless network using WiMAX or similar technologies. Such a network could provide both fixed and mobile voice and data services to a total of 13.5m terrestrial and 2.5m satellite users by 2015, generating annual service revenues of $5.3bn.
“MSS operators will need to partner with larger players, both to fund the US$3bn-plus projected cost of terrestrial base station deployment and to secure adequate mass market distribution channels,” commented analyst Tim Farrar. “We believe that the optimum partner would be a satellite TV operator, because of their compelling need to develop new wireless and broadband service offerings, and the shortage of alternative spectrum options for deploying a nationwide wireless network. Another option would be partnering with satellite radio providers such as XM Satellite Radio or Sirius Satellite Radio to provide capacity for mobile video and telematics services. There are currently five proposed MSS-ATC systems, from MSV, Terrestar, ICO, Inmarsat and Globalstar. However, there won’t be enough partners for all of these companies to successfully deploy their own national terrestrial network.”
On the terrestrial front, the details of the Clearwire deal with DirecTV and Echostar allow both DBS players to resell Clearwire broadband wireless services to their subscribers as a bundle or standalone. The DBS providers signed their first collaborative joint marketing deal last year, with satellite broadband provider WildBlue, but this is primarily geared to rural access. In return, Clearwire can sell DirecTV and Echostar TV offerings to its base from later this year. This complements the start-ups’s recently expanded cross-marketing deal with AOL, and shows how McCaw will use his market influence to sign the kind of partnerships that will enable the wireless operator to punch above its weight. Of course, many are speculating that the most significant of these will be a venture with Sprint Nextel in 2.5GHz, but the conflict of interest with Sprint’s cableco alliance could stand in the way (see separate item). Clearwire now has about 258,000 subscribers in the US plus a growing international reach, and accesses 39 US markets, primarily mid-tier cities and suburbs. It aims to make its service available to 125m people in five years, up from about 10m now. The DBS partners have about 30m subscribers between them.
The new agreement is a strong positive for Clearwire, then, adding credibility and new marketing channels to its fledgling business. But the real significance could come from the way that McCaw could leverage his diverse interests and influence to make this alliance far more than just a valuable distribution and marketing pact. Bringing ICO into the mix, and luring the DBS players with additional multimedia services that should be added to Clearwire next year, could enable McCaw to play his favorite role of power broker, forming a powerful cooperation with Malone and Ergen, and to ensure that the satellite broadcasters are more dependent on his companies, despite their small size, than he is on them.
Satellite trends:
The key opportunities for mobile satellite, most of which Liberty could exploit if it allied with Intelsat and ICO.
‘ Hybrid satellite/radio systems that aim to combine the benefits, and dilute the negatives, of both technologies. Notable in the US is the ATC (Ancillary Terrestrial Component) system in use by mobile satellite operators.
‘ Related to the above, the evolution of dual-mode devices for satellite and radio that are more usable and affordable than previous terminals.
‘ The quest by satellite TV and radio players to move into the quad play, something that will require them to buy wireless spectrum or work with partners.
‘ The auction of new spectrum for both sides of the industry and regulatory encouragement for new competitive services.
‘ The continuing demand for satellite from government and public safety agencies, which is driving a new cycle of investment in satellite. Also, rising demand for truly ubiquitous broadband access is stimulating investment and regulatory policy – whether in ultra-rural areas or on-board aeroplanes and ships.
‘ The expanded potential for satellite to act as backhaul for wireless communications or broadcasting systems.