Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 June 2007

Ericsson positions GSM/EDGE, not WiMAX, for massive rural markets

As the Chinese authorities and operators continue to haggle over 3G terms, the major cellcos are accelerating build-out – of 2G. This activity is stimulating the already impressive boom in spending on enhanced GSM, which with its simple path to GPRS and EDGE data services, is increasingly looking like the only network needed in many developing economies for many years to come. This is music to WiMAX vendors’ ears, since they position 802.16 as a perfect overlay for GSM, to allow for scalable roll-out of broadband services to urban centers and other hotspots, while falling back to GSM/EDGE for roaming, low cost services and rural data. But despite the logic of this commercial model, the vendor that is most determined to dominate the unexpected GSM resurgence is the one determined to keep WiMAX out of the picture – Ericsson. The Swedish behemoth has been the chief beneficiary of a spate of recent mega-contracts for GSM in China, India and other major economies, and it is aggressively positioning EDGE, not WiMAX, as the natural complement to GSM for operators that want to add data but do not have the spectrum or the business case to invest in 3G.

Ericsson’s latest GSM deal is with China Mobile, and is worth $1bn over two years, but could grow to far more than that, since the operator has said it will spend about $38bn on GSM and support systems by 2009 (this figure does not include 3G). In its latest filing with the US SEC authority, China Mobile Hong Kong (CMHK) said it added just under 61m users in 2006, to take its total base to 301m on December 31. Half of these new customers are coming from rural areas, indicating the urgent need for network expansion that can support large cells, sparse populations and relatively low ARPU subscribers. Despite this trend, China Mobile is seeing growth in overall ARPU, driven by a shift in its traditional base towards postpaid contracts, and greater revenues from value added services and corporate customers. Value added services now account for 23.5% of revenue, with the emphasis on mobile search, music, blogging and location-based services.

However, it will be hard to maintain ARPU levels if the shift of business balance towards rural areas continues at this pace, and Ericsson hopes to be the vendor to help China Mobile with the transition, by combining its GSM/EDGE platforms with options such as biofuel power solutions and easier financing. The same issues face many Indian carriers, and in that country – where Ericsson is poised to take the lion’s share of BSNL’s $4.5bn GSM expansion contract – the Swedish vendor is helping operators use local crops like cotton and fish oil to power phone transmitters, to lower the costs of rural access and bring mobile phones beyond the electricity grid. Other vendors have similar ideas – Motorola has been particularly active in developing products such as solar powered base stations. ‘India and China today have more minutes of use on 2G phones than the whole of Europe does, because there are no fixed line telecoms,’ Ericsson CEO Carl-Henric Svanberg said last week, hosting a visit to Sweden by the Chinese president. He boasted that his company is now installing a GSM base station every 25 minutes in India.

While new base station power sources, ultra-low cost handsets and enhancements to GSM and EDGE to make them more spectrally efficient are at the core of efforts for rural economies, Ericsson also has another clear advantage over its rivals – its ability to bundle network sales with managed services and other elements, as it did at BSNL, and to use its scale and plentiful cash to offer attractive financing out of working capital. For instance, it will often agree to long payment terms or some form of risk sharing.

But EDGE remains at the heart of Ericsson’s bid to dominate markets where there will be a hiatus before 3G is deployed, or where 3G proves unworkable altogether. EDGE (Enhanced Data Rates for Global Evolution) is a data oriented software upgrade to GSM networks, running in the same spectrum. The latest release of this ‘2.5G’ standard is dubbed EDGE Evolution, and can deliver data at up to 1Mbps. While, in the real world, nowhere close to the efficiency and speed of UMTS or 802.16e in delivering mobile data to power users or urban populations, enhanced EDGE should prove a very attractive option for operators with limited data requirements.

Ericsson says it will launch commercial EDGE Evolution products by the start of 2009, making a vocal commitment to this technology as one with a long term future. The Swedish giant claims to supply the ‘majority’ of all the 200 commercial EDGE networks in use round the world and clearly sees the Evolution software upgrade as a further way to reap cash from the platform, building on its recent successes with GSM/GPRS in markets where 3G spectrum is not available or where operators are holding back from full scale mobile broadband as yet – the vendor has recently won several massive GSM contracts in India, for instance. The other GSM giant, Nokia, which also claims an EDGE market lead, though this is oriented to handsets, is also making plans for Evolution. Nokia says the typical EDGE impact on monthly ARPU is an increase of around €1 compared to GPRS, or 10-40% higher data ARPU. Similar gains are also possible with EDGE Evolution, even in markets with competitive pricing.

EDGE works by improving the signalling interface to deliver, typically, three times the performance of GPRS, with the current release providing average data rate of 80-160Kbps per user in mobile terminals supporting 2-4 timeslots. It is part of the ITU’s family of technologies and is standardized by the same 3GPP body as W-CDMA, harmonizing the development of the two standards, which will often be used in parallel where operators have spectrum for both.

The main improvements to EDGE promised by the recently standardized Evolution release 7 include:
faster and better cell reselections with NACC/NCCR
guaranteed bit rates with streaming quality of service (Enhanced QoS)
enhanced service continuity with W-CDMA/HSPA.

Most important is an enhanced data rate through lower latency and other techniques. According to Ericsson, these include:

Latency reduction through reduced Transmission Time Interval (TTI) and additional protocol enhancements. Radio blocks are currently transmitted over four consecutive bursts on one timeslot using a TTI of 20ms. Reducing the TTI to 10ms improves latency substantially, to below 100ms. The four bursts are then transmitted on more than one timeslot (parallel timeslots on two carriers or dual timeslots on one carrier).

The most obvious improvement to peak bit rates is through the introduction of dual carriers in the downlink, increasing the carrier bandwidth available above 200KHz. Today’s EDGE terminals receive signals on up to five timeslots but the introduction of dual carriers doubles the available bandwidth (to 40KHz) as well as the practical peak bit rate. Using dual carriers and five timeslots on each carrier provides bit rates of almost 600Kbps with no other changes to EDGE.

Higher average and peak bit rates and improved spectral efficiency are achieved through more advanced modulation, using 16QAM instead of 8-PSK for some schemes; more efficient channel coding for better error correction; and an increased symbol rate (in practise, increasing the carrier bandwidth). Al this boosts peak bit rate to 100Kbps per timeslot, equating to user bit rates of 1Mbps if dual carriers are used. The higher symbol rate enables higher bit rates in the uplink, since dual carriers are only standardized for the downlink.

Dual-antenna terminals enable efficient interference rejection techniques, similar to those used in base station receivers.