The road to the mobile enterprise has been a long and winding one. Despite more than a decade of talking and planning, until recently, when most corporations talked about their wireless and mobile strategies, they really meant email on the move (usually BlackBerry), and enterprise Wi-Fi. There was discussion about fully flexible working, an end to business travel, and multimedia collaboration from cars and trains, but in reality, few companies wanted to entrust their most critical applications to smartphones, and few were really ready to change their processes radically either. Ten years on, greater trust in mobile technologies and economic pressures, plus end user determination to carry out more functions on a handset rather than a PC, have changed the landscape, but the major tipping points have come with the shift to cloud services, and the rise of BYOD (bring your own device) policies.
Both these trends have been well analyzed in terms of their impact on mobile technologies and usage patterns. But they do not just affect the dealings of the corporation with mobile operators and device makers. They also impact on the planning and management of networks within the company’s buildings, as employees increasingly use their smartphones or tablets as their main computers when indoors, not just on the road. That has led to rising enterprise interest in technologies to improve cellular coverage and capacity inside their sites, and to manage these from the same platforms as Lans and wireless Lans. Enterprise femtocells and ‘enterprise RAN’ systems like Spidercloud’s fit this bill.
The changes have also prompted response from the firms which have driven the corporate Wi-Fi boom from the start of the century, as they look to accommodate fully mobile and cloud usage too. Cisco is the obvious example. It is venturing into the cellular RAN field for the first time (with the exception of its shortlived flirtation with WiMAX via its Navini acquisition). This time it is making the move in a more logical way, considering its hold on the corporate network, providing indoor small cells which will increasingly integrate with its WLans, and could end up being run by its mainstream network operating systems.
Another pioneer of the enterprise Wi-Fi trend ‘ which sparked so many innovations across the whole WLan field ‘ is Aruba Networks. The firm is making its controllers more mobile-aware, announcing products which can monitor smartphone applications. The company says it is tapping into the BYOD trend, in which employees can run corporate apps on their own mobile gadgets, which are managed and secured by the company’s systems, and increasingly have separate work and personal ‘personalities’ via virtualization. The logical extension of that movement is BYOA (bring your own application), in which personnel select their own favorite apps or services ‘ but as with the devices themselves, it is vital that companies are able to monitor these for security and efficiency reasons.
This is the promise of Aruba’s trio of new controllers. They can identify which applications are running on the corporate networks, and exclude those which are deemed risky by the IT and security teams, or the policies set by the firm. They can also give priority secured bandwidth to those apps judged to be business critical.
The 7200 Series controllers (the 7210, 7220 ans 7240) inspect data packets flowing through the WLan and apply rules to determine which applications get priority, and which can share bandwith with other apps. The supplier’s Airwave management software analyzes traffic streams and then the AppRF software performs deep packet inspection (DPI), which Aruba says is unique in a WLan controller. Its results are combined with those from Airtime software, which governs fair usage of the bandwidth, and quality of service, and together optimize over-the-air performance.
The Aruba launch reflects a broader trend, both in WLans and cellular networks, to differentiate via software smarts rather than hardware performance. As the equipment itself becomes commoditized, and even significant leaps in speed attract only marginal price hikes, customers are still prepared to pay a premium for software intelligence which boosts their security, performance and cost efficiency.
However, vendors still cannot resist the ‘mine’s bigger than yours’ battle over hardware. Aruba, which is number two to Cisco in the enterprise Wi-Fi market, says one of its top end controllers can handle the traffic of the entire Pentagon, and it told IDG its 7200 can download files about 11 times faster than a comparable Cisco device, for around half the cost. It also said it can support up to 32,000 devices per controller, five times the density of its rivals.
The AppRF technology gives enterprises visibility and control over traditional server-based applications, as well as cloud-based mobile services such as Box, GoToMeeting, Salesforce.com and others. It analyzes traffic down to individual users’ streams to support IT teams in troubleshooting, network planning, and real time prioritization.
‘Today’s IT departments are faced with the challenge of providing better access to deal with onslaught of mobile applications ‘ all while working within the confines of a typically tight budget,’ said Chris Kozup, senior director of EMEA marketing at Aruba. ‘With these levels of visibility, enterprises can experience significant cost benefits as well as redirect their investments from traditional wired equipment, desk phones and expensive video equipment to an all-wireless model.’
Also looking at the intersection between mobile and enterprise networks is Xirrus, which last month launched a controller which sits at the edge of the mobile network, allowing businesses to analyze and manage traffic ‘ including from employees’ BYOD devices ‘ before it gets to the core network. This helps reduce strain on the core and network congestion, and can also enhance security and control right down to the individual user or application.
Xirrus Application Control supports Layer 7 application visibility and control at the edge, harnessing deep packet inspection and using the Xirrus Wireless Arrays multiprocessor engine to prioritize key apps, restrict usage of bandwidth hungry services, and detect threats. Apps are controlled in a distributed fashion by placing the classification and policy enforcement engines on the edge rather than in a gateway or firewall, keeping threats and major traffic burdens away from the main network.
Xirrus has also upgraded the ArrayOS software which powers its Wireless Arrays, also aiming to optimize manageability in the BYOD environment. It claims the Arrays are better suited to this landscape than traditional access points because they prioritize and firewall traffic by application; can handle Apple Bonjour traffic; and can support high densities of users. A new Honeypot SSID mode eliminates much of the unnecessary traffic generated by smartphones attempting to connect to the network, says Xirrus, which has also introduced compliance with the Wi-Fi Alliance’s Passpoint specification, enabling mobile devices to discover and connect automatically to Wi-Fi networks.
‘Wireless APs have become the preferred form and increasingly the only form of access onto enterprise networks,’ said Steven Wastie, CMO at Xirrus. ‘Wireless-only devices such as iPads and BYOD have thrown a wrench into the plans of IT directors. Their wireless networks were not typically designed to handle the onslaught of new devices and unknown application loads.’
Finding new ways to manage and secure a combination of WLans, wireline networks and mobile devices is key to adding value in the enterprise sector these days. That was made clear when Cisco paid $1.2bn last month for Meraki, a major exponent of the idea that cloud networking is the most cost efficient way for companies to unify their wired and wireless operations. It offers a WLan controller cloud platform and ‘network as a service’ subscriptions, allowing clients to equip branch offices with Meraki network products and then link them to the cloud software for controller functions. The customer provisions and manages its WLans and the remote routers through a common web portal and pays a monthly fee for the service.
Initially such strategies were designed to disrupt Cisco’s model and undermine its power in the enterprise, but increasingly, the larger firm has been embracing cloud services itself and the relatively high price it paid for Meraki may reflect that the purchase will be valuable in its broader strategy. Meraki is to become the new ‘Cloud Networking Group’ within Cisco, which gives it unusually high status among acquisitions and suggests a wider remit than just Wi-Fi. Analyst Mark Fabbi of Gartner told NetworkWorld: “It’s pretty clear Cisco bought Meraki because of their ability to manage cloud infrastructure and Meraki has proven that the model works and is robust. I would expect that it will become the platform for Cisco to offer different delivery and management models to a much broader product and customer set.”
Enterprise WLan revenues:
According to IDC, the combined consumer and enterprise WLan equipment market worldwide by revenue grew by 14.6% year-on-year in the third quarter. The enterprise was the key driver, with its 24% growth rate easily outpacing the consumer segment, and representing the sixth consective quarter with more than 20% expansion.
The quarter featured two significant events among the vendors ‘ the IPO of carrier Wi-Fi specialist Ruckus Wireless, which itself followed the acquisition by Ericsson of its chief rival BelAir Networks; and Cisco’s takeover of cloud WLan vendor Meraki.
Regionally, Japan had the highest growth in enterprise WLan gear in the quarter, up by 48.8%, followed by the Middle East and Africa on 42.5%. The US reported a rise of 25.4% and western Europe almost 19%. However, China was a weak spot with a 0.9% decline in sales.
Sector leader Cisco saw its enterprise WLan revenues up by 25.8% to reach $508m, giving it 50% market share. Aruba (excluding its OEM business) grew its revenues by 18.4% and now holds 11.2% of the enterprise WLan space. Third placed HP had more modest growth at 8.2% and ended the quarter with lower market share, at 6.3%, while Aerohive (up 98.5%), Meraki (up 147.1% ), and Ruckus (up 73.7% ) saw the most dramatic leaps.