Several of the world’s chip majors have been circling around Sharp, and the chance to gain a low cost entry to its advanced display technologies at a time when the Japanese giant has warned of the danger of bankruptcy. Though Intel was considered the frontrunner to take a stake ‘ and may still do so ‘ Qualcomm has secured the initial prize, announcing an equity investment and an expanded technology agreement centered on Sharp’s IGZO technology. This should accelerate the commercialization of MEMS-based mobile displays ‘ a low power technology in which Qualcomm has taken a keen interest for years.
This interest springs from Qualcomm’s efforts to optimize its chips for the entire user experience and to increase its influence, IPR holdings and revenue in many elements of the future mobile device. Although its own innovative MEMS-based display, Mirasol, failed to succeed as a commercial business, its Pixtronix subsidiary continues with developments in the MEMS touchscreen field.
This unit will now broaden its 18-month pact with Sharp’s display operation to ‘develop and commercialize high quality color, low power MEMS displays incorporating IGZO.’ Sharp has pioneered IGZO (Indium Gallium Zinc Oxide) technology, which supports very slim displays using existing LCD manufacturing processes. The goal of the joint effort, according to Qualcomm’s statement, is to speed up commercialization of Pixtronix’s low power MEMS displays, by combining the technology with IGZO, and harnessing Sharp’s position as a major force in displays.
“As one of the leading electronics companies in the world, Sharp has an established industry brand and is a recognized leader in the development and commercialization of new innovative display technologies,” Derek Aberle, group president of Qualcomm, said in a statement. Sharp said the incorporation of Pixtronix’s MEMS technology would make its small and medium screens more commercially attractive in a shorter timeframe, improving power consumption levels. The resulting products will be made in Sharp’s LCD panel plant in Yonago, Japan.
The San Diego firm acquired Pixtronix in January for a sum reported to be around $190m. The smaller company’s display, PerfectLight, is based on a digital micro shutter which modulates light from an RGB LED backlight (unlike Mirasol, which harnessed ambient light). It uses MEMS instead of liquid crystal to control light transmission, which greatly reduces power consumption. High switching speed makes it suitable for full speed video, says the company ‘ a failing of Qualcomm’s Mirasol. PerfectLight claims to support greater than 170-degree viewing angles, more than 3,000:1 contrast ratio and 24-bit color depth ‘ all at 25% of the power consumption of LCDs with equivalent size and resolution.
Qualcomm has had strong technology, first with Mirasol and then Pixtronix, but the Sharp deal brings it mass manufacturing capacity to go to market aggressively. Although it had secured a manufacturing plant for Mirasol, Sharp offers greater economies of scale and will also be able to market the screens to its existing customer base. This leaves Qualcomm in a more comfortable position of being the technology provider and licensor, rather than pushing it into an unfamiliar activity in selling displays ‘ a fiercely competitive area.
Pixtronix was founded in 2005 by its CTO, Nesbitt Hagood, and has developed a low cost, low power display technology called PerfectLight. It looks probable that it could be combined with Mirasol. At the point of the acquisition by Qualcomm, the start-up had developed a 5-inch prototype with TFT-LCD display maker Chimei Innolux, and was developing another model for Hitachi. The start-up had raised more than $53m in venture capital from backers including Atlas Ventures, Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, DAG Ventures and GoldHill Capital.
Qualcomm’s interest in displays goes back to 2004, when it paid $170m for Iridigm Display and its Mirasol technology, which was readable in bright sunlight and consumed minute amounts of power. In July, the chip provider gave up on commercializing Mirasol further ‘ it had scored a few wins in ereaders but no tier one names ‘ and said it would seek licensees instead. Sources indicate that, once Qualcomm started to evolve Mirasol towards larger screen sizes and color, it found it difficult to achieve an efficient manufacturing process despite a manufacturing joint venture with Foxlink in Taiwan.
CEO Paul Jacobs said Mirasol would not be abandoned altogether but ‘only certain Mirasol products’ would be commercialized, implying these would be in niches, with the main activity focused on licensing. Some of the R&D and patents are likely to find their way into the Sharp/Pixtronix development.
In 2010, Jacobs had grand plans for Mirasol, which he anticipated finding its way into smaller tablets and color ereaders by now. He said: ‘There will be a time when there is no need for us to design mobile phone screens which black out after 30 seconds, to preserve battery life, because these screens will take so little power.’ And the firm said larger form factors were also viable. An executive said at an analyst briefing last year: ‘There’s no fundamental reason why the technology could not go larger ‘ We would be remiss if we didn’t investigate 9.7-inch.’ But this has reportedly proved more difficult than expected, limiting the addressable market even as other low power display technologies emerge.
The deal with Sharp may finally give Qualcomm the display influence it craves, and even resurrect elements of the Mirasol approach. First, though, Sharp needs to survive. Qualcomm’s investment
is certainly not enough to turn around Sharp’s fortunes, which have been hit by a slump in its core TV business. It will boost confidence and stimulate its mobile display business, an important growth area where it already has a manufacturing deal with Apple, and could attract the iPhone maker to IGZO/MEMS for future RetinaDisplays. But further investors will be sought. ‘This investment is good news for Sharp,’ Hideki Yasuda, an analyst at Ace Securities in Tokyo, said. ‘However, it won’t have sufficient impact to improve the company’s situation dramatically. It’s only symbolic.’
Another analyst, Mitsushige Akino, told Bloomberg that, given Sharp’s problems, even an investment 20 times the size of Qualcomm’s would be ‘meaningless’. Such views will increase speculation that the firm might spin off the small/medium display business to attract new partners and cushion it from the problems of the TV segment.
Sharp said last month there was ‘material doubt’ about its ability to survive after forecasting a record ‘450bn fiscal year loss. In late October, Sharp was reported by Japanese newspapers to be engaged in talks about capital alliances with Intel, HP, Google and Apple.
The equity investment, which will make the US chip designer a minority shareholder, will take place in stages and the completion of the transaction is subject to certain contingencies. Sharp will issue new shares to Qualcomm at development milestones in the venture. According to Bloomberg, terms will include the sale of ‘5bn ($61m) in new shares this year, which would amount to a 2.6% stake based on yesterday’s market value of ‘191bn. It could then invest the same amount again subject to successful outcomes.
Earlier this year, Sharp had agreed that Taiwanese manufacturer Hon Hai/Foxconn would take a stake in return for a broad cooperation on display production, but the deal fell through when Sharp’s value slumped. Since then, various rescue routes have been mooted for the Japanese firm, including a revival of the Foxconn agreement under revised terms, or investment from Intel and/or Dell. According to Wall Street Journal sources, Sharp has asked both Dell and Intel to invest $240m each in return for equity or debt.
Various reports have all centered on Intel, but failed to agree on the amount of money involved ‘ Reuters recently said Intel and Qualcomm would invest about $378m between them, while Japan’s Kyodo News said Intel might stump up as much as $500m on its own. Its motivation would be to gain greater access to advanced touchscreen technology, which could enhance future reference designs for ultrabooks and Windows 8 tablets ‘ the two form factors which Intel is pushing for the hybrid territory between PCs and mobiles, where it needs its x86 architecture to carve out a significant presence alongside ARM-based rivals.
The saga of Sharp’s survival efforts also illustrates many of the pressures and rivalries in the mobile device market. Apple, keen to ensure reliable suppliers of iDevice screens, and to reduce its reliance on Samsung, may have helped bail out the Japanese electronics firm earlier this month, according to some reports. Sharp is one of three manufacturers of RetinaDisplay screens for Apple’s iPhone and iPad and analysts were recently speculating that the US firm might have invested as much as $2bn to ensure its supplier did not go under (a very real danger, according to company filings and comments).
Horace Dediu, an analyst at Asymco, speculated earlier this month that a $2bn capex sum attributed to ‘cashflow’ by Apple might have been for ‘production equipment (or even a plant) previously owned by Sharp’, and that both the failed deal with Foxconn (Apple’s contract manufacturer) and the possible cash injection were attempts by the device vendor to ‘ensure both continuity of supply and a balanced supplier base (offsetting Samsung)’.
Another way Apple might have propped up Sharp, and prevented a disastrous gap in iDevice screen production if it went bankrupt, could have been to prepay for RetinaDisplays, which would have appeared as an off-balance sheet commitment in filings. Dediu notes Apple reported that ‘as of September 29, 2012, the Company had outstanding off-balance sheet manufacturing commitments and component purchase commitments of $21.1bn’, at the same time that Sharp, which had warned of slowing RetinaDisplay output, ramped up to mass volumes.
Apple remains heavily reliant on the Korean suppliers for its displays, and its business was a key factor in a 9% rise in shipments by Samsung and LG during September, compared to August, in a month when the small and medium display (SMD) segment fell overall. However, IHS iSuppli notes in its round-up of the sector that Samsung’s shipments to Apple are declining as the iPhone maker tries to find other sources such as Sharp, AU Optronics and Chimei Innolux.
Samsung Display and LG Display totalled 48m SMD units in the month, while the combined panel shipments from the six main Taiwanese suppliers declined by 3% to 166.8m units in the same period and the whole sector slide by 0.7%. “Samsung continued to supply LCD panels for the iPad in September, although its monthly shipment volume to Apple declined compared to the first half of 2012,” said analyst Vinita Jakhanwal. “LG Display is expected to take the leadership position in terms of supplying displays for the iPad product line.’
Samsung and LG will be keeping a keen eye on IGZO and MEMS as they reach commercial reality helped by Qualcomm’s funds and market muscle. Samsung has majored on the AMOLED technology, which it dominates, and has also invested in various innovative start-ups of its own, for instance when it acquired LiquaVista. As the mobile display becomes an increasing source of differentiation and revenue, Sharp should be able to ride that timely wave and ensure its own survival as a counterweight to the Koreans.