Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 April 2007

Ericsson demonstrates how it could strangle newly merged rivals in key markets

A few weeks ago, the belated creation of the Nokia Siemens joint venture was somewhat overshadowed by cautious forecasts from the new company and its rival Alcatel Lucent (see Wireless Watch April 16 2007). It seemed that, amid the huge deals that have taken place as the infrastructure market consolidates, market leader Ericsson was taking advantage of the turmoil to strengthen its position, rather than being threatened by its new, enlarged challengers. The Swedish giant’s first quarter results confirmed the suspicion, and point to a market advantage that could last for the rest of the calendar year, though the company will face its own challenges as it seeks to adapt to the convergence market and shift its balance of revenue and profit towards services.

Ericsson reported revenues up 8% year-on-year to SEK42.2bn ($6.27bn), and net income up 27% to SEK5.8bn ($862m). CEO Carl-Henric Svanberg sung from the new Ericsson hymn sheet, accrediting the strong performance to the company’s scale and ability to offer a soup-to-nuts services including managed services (one of Ericsson’s most important growth areas, and the lever for some of its largest equipment deals, such as recent GSM expansion contracts in India). Justifying its decision not to make a massive acquisition (though it has been padding out its shift to convergence with purchases like Marconi and IPTV company Tandberg), Ericsson has talked up the stability it will offer clients in a time of uncertainty and its expansions in the areas of services, enterprise and IPTV/media. It is also keen to play down criticisms from some quarters that it remains over dependent on GSM and UMTS and that it should have moved more quickly into fixed/mobile convergence. Svanberg said mobile revenues across all three Ericsson business units – networks, professional services and multimedia – were up 6% year-on-year, almost as much as the overall company, and that it had made ‘solid market share gains’ in GSM and UMTS. He believes Ericsson will gain mid-single digit growth in mobile systems in 2007, with ‘strong growth’ in the other areas.

The highlight of the Ericsson figures, and the most worrying for its rivals, is the stability of its operating margins, which were unchanged from last year, at a time when other vendors are all experiencing tough price competition and erosion, some of which they blame on Ericsson’s use of its economies of scale to undercut them on large equipment deals. With Ericsson leading the pack in aggressive pricing but maintaining its margins, its focus on bundling managed services and other elements into carrier deals appears to be paying off, and is something it will be hard for competitors to emulate quickly (though Nokia does have some track record here too). Ericsson turned in operating margins of 17% on revenues of SEK29.3bn in its networks division, 15% on revenues of SEK9.5bn for professional services, while its smallest unit, Multimedia, increased its margin from 3% last year to 8%, on revenues of SEK3.4bn. This division is responsible for IPTV and content activities. Overall, first quarter gross margin was 43%, compared with a more typical 35% for Nokia Networks.

The general delight with the results was summed up by a research note from Dresdner Kleinwort, which pointed to ‘unsurpassed profitability compared with any of its peers’ and resilient margins that ‘signify a superior market position with pricing powers second to none’.

The main challenges that Svanberg aims to take on in the coming quarters are expansion in India and China, to reduce the dependence on EMEA, and improving performance in North America, where Ericsson has recently acquired Redback and Entrisphere to boost fixed line offerings. These two delivered revenues of SEK400m ($59.5M) between them in the first quarter, and the takeover of video vendor Tandberg Television was also completed last week, providing what Svanberg called ‘a new set-up in the US’. The main focuses will be on fixed line markets, especially GPON for the fiber plans of the big telcos, and on the triple play.

By contrast, Alcatel-Lucent was losing revenues and market share in GSM and UMTS, largely to Ericsson, and this was the main factor behind a profit warning last week. CEO Pat Russo said ‘our first quarter results were impacted by lower volumes in traditional wireless and core networks at a time when considerable investments were made in the next generation of these technologies’. Alcatel-Lucent is in the midst of streamlining its dual product lines, along with the 3G equipment purchased from Nortel, which will replace Alcatel’s now discontinued UMTS base stations. Lucent is keeping its own UMTS gear, mainly for its one major customer, Cingular/AT&T. Meanwhile, Alcatel-Lucent is finding its hard to be price competitive with Ericsson, Huawei and others in GSM systems for emerging markets.

Analysts expect wireless sales at the merged company to drop by as much as one-third year-on-year in the first quarter, which would take them to about €1bn ($1.36bn). This would be made up of about 40% GSM and UMTS, with the rest coming from CDMA, where Lucent is sector leader, but where shareholders fear a slowdown in the market from 2008. Alcatel has often complained about Ericsson’s aggressive undercutting in GSM, and now it seems clear that the Swedish vendor is using its scale to strangle its rival’s GSM business, while keeping its margins respectable by bundling in services.

Sony Ericsson:

Handset maker Sony Ericsson announced its results a week before its co-parent’s and has clearly made a significant contribution, doubling its first quarter net income to €254m ($347.07m) from €109m. Revenue rose 47% to €2.925bn from €1.992bn.

Sony Ericsson said it would make a total payment of €848m to its two parents in 2007, through dividends, or dividend and capital redemption, showing its increasing value to the companies – a far cry from three years ago when they were forced to inject more funds in the venture and when Ericsson was widely expected to exit the handset space altogether.