While the large commercial operators’ contracts grab the headlines, many technologies have had their first real success in the military world, and WiMAX proponents have been working for the past few years to carve out a role for 802.16 in this field, particularly with the US armed services, which are in the midst of massive technical overhaul projects geared to creating ‘network centric warfare’ in which all personnel and equipment are constantly connected and monitored by broadband wireless networks serving devices based on highly intelligent software defined radios.
WiMAX has made some strides in the core – though troubled – project in this area, JTRS (Joint Tactical Radio System), but has not got beyond the assessment stage, and more short term opportunities could arise from a new relationship with the US Army’s Communications Electronics R&D Engineering Center (CERDEC). This is to spend several months evaluating 802.16e equipment, mainly from Samsung, for suitability in military environments, particularly battlefield scenarios where users are highly mobile and ad hoc networks need to be created, often using fully mobile base stations.
Of course, there is a long way to go from R&D evaluation to commercial contracts, but in the context of the Army’s need for always-on communications in hostile environments – and the tortured progress of the larger, cross-services JTRS project – there is a fairly urgent need for a technology that could support multibillion roll-outs in the short to medium term. Samsung is likely to be focusing on enhanced implementations of 802.16e featuring elements of the so-called Wave 3 specification, which is yet to be finalized by the WiMAX Forum. Importantly, the use of smart antenna formations will be intensified for a military version, with MIMO systems using at least two antennas at each end, and often more. Such approaches would approach the shortcomings of current mobile field systems – fully mobile base stations are often used, but tend to support only low bandwidth, while military-specific communications gear can be heavy, expensive and non-compatible with systems used by other services or by allies’ forces.
Full IP, and fairly simple support for a wide range of higher level protocols such as ATM, are features of WiMAX that are appealing in the military context, claims Rosettex Technology and Ventures, a prominent participant in US government technology programs, which has created its own WiMAX-based systems for military and public safety use, notably the massive Guards emergency response project ongoing in New York. This initiative, originally based on the NextNet kit owned by Clearwire, is likely to have been one factor in Motorola’s keenness to take over NextNet as part of its investment in the start-up operator last year, giving the handset maker a potentially lucrative deal in one of its most natural markets, safety.
Motorola would also be considered a natural choice to supply the Army with prototypes for its evaluations, given the company’s long experience in field radio systems and security applications. But it has lost out, at least at this early stage, to Samsung, which gains a huge endorsement just from being part of a US Army trial, given the armed forces’ usual inclination to prefer homegrown vendors.
Samsung will provide its equipment to the C4ISR (Command, Control, Communications, Computers, Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance) On-The-Move experimentation facility, in Fort Dix, New Jersey, in a project that will be a real test of just how mobile 802.16e can be – and, if successful, potentially a strong riposte to naysayers who claim WiMAX is not fully mobile in the sense that the CDMA technologies are.
Samsung’s early rush into 802.16e – with its huge input to the standard and its support for Wave 1 profiles, largely ignored by the major vendors – will have gained it an important profile boost with the Army. Officials from the US Department of Defense visited Korea last October and were given a demonstration of WiBro, the semi-proprietary precursor of WiMAX that Samsung helped invent, and which has been deployed in capital Seoul by Korea Telecom.
Some of the trials of mobile base stations and broadband field systems are expected to be fed into real RFPs and product roll-outs at high speed (by military standards) in the face of a wave of criticism of the outdated equipment with which some soldiers had to cope in Iraq. But the most significant military broadband wireless project, the JTRS, is already heavily delayed and over budget, giving WiMAX supporters an opportunity to reiterate claims that their technology could provide all the features that the US forces want from their future radios, but at lower cost and with shorter time to market.
These claims first surfaced in 2005 and have been gaining ground again this year. Two years ago, some vendors started a campaign to exploit weaknesses in the JTRS plans and promote a specialized version of WiMAX as the basis of the DoD’s own wideband network and adaptive radio projects. They gained some support for their claims from within the DoD. Two doctoral students at the Naval Postgraduate School, Robert Guice and Ramon Munoz, put forward arguments that WiMAX could, with some modifications, meet all the broadband data requirements of JTRS ‘ arguments that are said to be taken seriously in senior reaches of the military. Guice and Munoz said that WiMAX radios would often perform better in a battlefield situation than the planned JTRS Wideband Networking Waveform (WNW), which delivers only 5Mbps, over a maximum range of six miles, (this can be exceeded by WiMAX when using dedicated bandwidth). Many companies, such as Proxim and Motorola, have already enhanced WiMAX gear for capabilities such as in-vehicle operation and creating ad hoc networks, both important in the public safety and military markets.
The JTRS is designed to evolve into a cognitive radio that can move intelligently between the best available frequencies. This is also a key work in progress for WiMAX and other wireless standards, as indicated by the IEEE’s 802.22 project, which focused on a standard for cognitive radios that would avoid interference with incumbents in frequencies such as 700MHz, which are changing usage. Now that WiMAX products are starting to come to market, the arguments for it to take a greater military role are gaining force, with several vendors claiming that their technologies could be be easily adapted for JTRS, by combining a WiMax wideband waveform and a MAC that supports multiple frequency bands and modulation types.