Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 April 2007

Qualcomm’s strong quarter temporarily diverts attention from Nokia

With such intense attention focused on Qualcomm’s ongoing licensing battles with Nokia, it was psychologically important for the chipmaker to deliver a good quarter that showed the way the company could survive even the most negative outcome of its legal battles. With characteristic confidence, the CDMA leader duly delivered impressive growth and some convincing arguments that, while a severe reduction in Nokia royalties – which would set a precedent for the whole handset business – would be very harmful in the short term, Qualcomm’s own product operations would ensure the blow was nowhere near fatal.

Qualcomm exceeded expectations on the top and bottom line and raised forecasts for the coming quarter, with several analysts raising their ratings in harmony. The “sheer magnitude” of growth was impressive, said one of the company’s closest watchers, Albert Lin of American Technology Research, who reiterated a ‘buy’ rating in a research note, and raised his target price from $45 to $60. Revenue in the second quarter was up 21% to $2.22bn (analyst consensus had predicted $2.19bn) and earnings, excluding option costs and one-off charges, were 50 cents a share. Qualcomm raised its full year earnings outlook to $1.84 to $1.88 per share, from a previous target of $1.72 to $1.77. This has already factored in a possible earnings hit of 4-5 cents in the fourth quarter from lower Nokia payments (the Finnish company, on the expiration of its licensing deal on April 9, has unilaterally decided on a royalty level, which it will pay, but which is significantly lower than Qualcomm claims is due. Assuming the dispute has not been settled either way by the fourth quarter, the impact of this lower payment will start to be felt.)

This was a robust display of confidence in the face of the real threats of a damaging Nokia settlement and/or negative judgements in the possible European Commission probe and other legal actions. Qualcomm’s CEO Paul Jacobs has done a fair job in the past six months of shifting the emphasis from controversial licensing practises to the area where Qualcomm can win arguments on more empirical grounds – product quality and time to market. Early uptake of HSDPA products, progress towards highly integrated multi-radio chips such as the Universal Broadcast Modem (UBM) for mobile TV, continuing growth in the much-written off CDMA handset sector – all these are achievements based on core engineering and marketing skills, and the elevation of Sanjay Jha to be second in command after Jacobs was a strong move, putting an engineer, and one who is moderate and persuasive as well as clever, in the front line.

Jacobs’ message has been clear – if the worst happens on the licensing front (savage Nokia royalty cuts, negative EU judgements and so on), Qualcomm will take firm action, even to the extent of spinning of the intellectual property arm, and come back a strong, if changed, company. The quarterly results call continued the theme, steadfastly downplaying the Nokia issue – “nothing new to discuss” was Jacobs’ summary – and focusing on product growth and engineering excellence. Strong forecasts for the year helped make the message palatable to shareholders, though of course the real effect of any Nokia settlement will be fully felt in the next fiscal year.

Among the highlights, Qualcomm generated $1.09bn in free cashflow in Q2, increasing its war chest of cash and marketable securities to a huge $11.3bn, itself a defiant gesture to legal adversaries and a conciliatory move towards shareholders who have been worried by the legal bills of $200m that Qualcomm expects to pay this year – with so much cash at hand, it is easier to accept the chip giant’s argument that the investment in lawyers will be worth it in the medium term because it will safeguard future revenues.

Qualcomm also gained a windfall from another legal fight, this time with Sony Ericsson, which was settled earlier this month in the chipmaker’s favor. Though with nothing like the broader significance of the Nokia battle, it was encouraging for Qualcomm investors to see the company scoring points against handset majors, plus a ruling that the Sino-Swedish phonemaker had underpaid royalties for the past two years will bring an additional $30m in back payments into the Qualcomm coffers. This dispute seemed to revolve around technical financial arguments rather than general principles over royalty payment levels, like the Nokia one, but it is nonetheless significant that Sony Ericsson has agreed to increase its fees going forward, and with relatively little fuss.

Qualcomm is riding on the wave of various trends and vendor decisions with its recent and forthcoming chipset additions, and some analysts expect it to exceed even its enhanced full year guidance. Positives include an extended relationship with Motorola, which is increasing its purchase of chips from Qualcomm as it diversifies its supplier roster away from former subsidiary Freescale. The other star client for Qualcomm is LG, which is also adopting 3G chips at an accelerating rate. Qualcomm says it is seeing faster integration of its GPS/cellular technologies by new customers, better than expected sales of dual-mode chipsets – especially of iDEN/CDMA devices to Sprint Nextel suppliers, and GSM/CDMA to Verizon.

Qualcomm has also benefited from its policy of driving advanced chips into the market at the earliest stage to gain a headstart where prices can still be charged at a premium. It did not see the sequential drop that many other chipmakers experienced in the second quarter because the W-CDMA market remains at the high end of the price/margin range and is experiencing very strong growth, and Qualcomm is both stretching its performance at the high end with multimode chipsets and HSDPA upgrades, and pushing 3G into lower cost packages for midrange handsets. Once the latter becomes a more general trend, it will lose the current advantage that it has in this respect, with W-CDMA becoming more commoditized and price pressurized, and subject to the familiar seasonal ups and downs. Typically, this pattern would continue to buoy Qualcomm in Q4 but could cause problems in Q108, when effects of any Nokia cutbacks will also start to bite in earnest.

So in the absence of a settlement of the Nokia case in this calendar year, these quarterly results are ones that Qualcomm should relish. However well it does in the current and fourth quarters, the shadow of Nokia, and the knock-on effects of any negative judgement, will hang increasingly heavily over future results, as the financial bite comes closer and investor uncertainty heightens. It will be hard to be as bullish about fiscal 2008 as about the second half of this financial year, unless something dramatic happens in the handset chip licensing arena. However, Qualcomm is showing its usual fighting spirit, and basing its bid for shareholder loyalty on real achievements, not just propaganda. It will become increasingly vital that it continues to turn in strong product lines and sales performance in order to retain investor and customer confidence during difficult days ahead, and that it continues to build its case that, in the most extreme outcome, it will still be capable of delivering rising value, even from its chip business alone.

Financial Highlights Q207:

‘ Revenues rose 21% year-on-year and 10% sequentially to $2.22bn.
‘ Net income was up 22% (12% sequentially) to $726m.
‘ Earnings per share were 43 cents, up from 34 cents a year earlier.
‘ Shipments of chipsets rose 24% year-on-year to 61m.
‘ Operating cashflow was $1bn, up 11%. Pro forma free cashflow was more than $1bn and 49% of revenues.
‘ The company returned about $440m of capital to shareholders in dividends and a $40m deal to repurchase 1m shares of common stock.
‘ Qualcomm CDMA Technologies, the product arm, enjoyed record revenues from its core MSM range, and saw revenues up 24% year-on-year to $1.3bn, and margins up from 26% in Q1 to 29%.
‘ Qualcomm’s Technology Licensing division grew its revenues 19% year-on-year to $759m in spite of the legal battles. This area contributes almost two-thirds of the company’s profit, and grew its pre-tax earnings by 8% over the year. Its operating margins rose slightly since Q1, from 82% to 83%.
‘ Software developers using the Brew platform had cumulative earnings that exceeded $1bn for the first time.
‘ Average selling price for Qualcomm-based handsets was $214.
‘ W-CDMA royalties were 49% of the total. Qualcomm estimated there were 301m handsets shipped in calendar 2006 containing its CDMA technologies – about two-thirds of these CDMA2000.
‘ Guidance for the fiscal year was raised – revenues now forecast to be in the range $8.1-8.6bn to $8.4-8.7bn; earnings per share to be $1.84 to $1.88 (factoring in the potential impact of Nokia reductions in Q4, estimated at 4-5 cents per share).