There has always been significant tension in the Android community between Google’s own implementation of the smartphone platform, centered around its services such as Search and Maps, and those of some of the biggest handset makers.
In the past year, this tension has deepened because Google has stopped allowing Huawei to use its mobile services, since the Chinese firm was placed on the US entity list. This has prompted Huawei to develop its own alternative mobile platform, and to gain support for it from several other large Chinese handset makers, including Xiaomi and Oppo.
Then there is a community of smaller device makers which use the open source version of Android – they have not signed up for the Open Handset Alliance (OHA), which governs the commercial Android-based platform, and so are not required to implement the Google services or its approach to the user experience. This is a mobile wild west in which Google has complained that poor Android experiences may be developed, giving a bad name to the whole operating system.
But even in the world of OHA all is not harmonious. Most large Android smartphone makers support OHA, largely to have access to the Google services to which users are so accustomed, and to the full ecosystem of developers, tools and apps. But while certain aspects of the user experience, such as support for the core Google applications, are mandated, there is still considerable freedom for handset makers to develop their own variants, and Google has often complained that these may deliver a poorer overall experience than the ‘official’ implementation it showcases in its own Pixel models.
The latest outbreak of tension between Google’s desire for a unified, reliable and high quality user experience, and the need for Android device makers to differentiate their products, was seen last week when a Google engineer alleged that alterations Samsung had made to the Android Linux-based kernel had made its Galaxy devices vulnerable.
The engineer, Jann Horn, is part of the Project Zero team which works on Android security, aiming to identify zero-day vulnerabilities. In a blog post, he defended vanilla Android code, writing: “In my opinion, some of the custom features that Samsung added are unnecessary, and can be removed without any loss of value.”
Further, he claimed the modifications compromised security, adding: “That I was able to reuse an infoleak bug here that was fixed over a year ago shows, once again, that the way Android device branches are currently maintained is a security problem. While I have criticized some Linux distributions in the past for not taking patches from upstream in a timely manner, the current situation in the Android ecosystem is worse. Ideally, all vendors should move towards using, and frequently applying updates from, supported upstream kernels.”
In February, Samsung added new security features to its implementation of Android for its Galaxy smartphone portfolio. These features are known as PROCA, but Horn believes it would be more effective to pay more attention to preventing unauthorized access in the first place.