The past few days have been busy ones for wireless patent lawyers with a string of judgements and filings. Most significantly, HTC claims to have safeguarded Android from Nokia, after it defeated the Finnish firm over one of the same key patents that forced Apple into a rare settlement two years ago.
HTC was cleared of infringing two of the Finnish firm’s patents by a German court, one of them being a broad piece of IPR labelled ‘method for using services offered by a telecommunications network, a telecommunications system, and a terminal for it’. The District Court of Mannheim dismissed the claims, and said it believed Nokia ‘exaggerated the scope of its patent in order to extract unwarranted licensing royalties from Android handset manufacturers’.
HTC claimed the ruling should safeguard Android against ‘oppressive enforcement of this patent’ and said in a statement: ‘While Nokia will doubtless try to downplay the significance of this victory, the ‘120 patent is Nokia’s flagship patent, and appears to be one of the reasons that Apple was forced to settle with Nokia after it was asserted against Apple in the same court.’
HTC is also pursuing a challenge to the validity of the patents, with the UK and German IPR courts, and says it expects the patent to be revoked before Nokia has a chance to appeal the Mannheim ruling.
The same court dismissed another Nokia complaint regarding a patent for ‘Electronic Display Device and Lighting Control Method of Same’.
In another case, Nokia and HTC find themselves on the same side. Both are being sued once again by licensing firm IPCom, after European and German authorities confirmed the validity of one of its patent families. The European Patent Office (EPO) and German Patent and Trademark Office has ruled that IPCom’s patent family number 100 is ‘new and inventive’, supporting the company’s claim that phonemakers must license them.
The main patent at issue covers the way that channels are assigned to users on 3G networks, granting priority to emergency services, and thus counts as standards essential IPR, says IPCom. Its director, Bernhard Frohwitter, said UK and German courts had already ruled that Nokia and HTC infringed on the patent, and that the confirmation of validity enables it to renew its efforts to strike a licensing deal.
‘These decisions significantly strengthen our patent portfolio in Germany and the UK and all the other countries covered by the EPO,’ Frohwitter said. ‘Companies which have not yet negotiated license agreements can continue to count on quickly coming to a fair agreement with us.’ IPCom does not always sound so reasonable ‘ in December it threatened Nokia CEO Stephen Elop with jail, while last month it ordered the seizure of HTC handsets imported to Germany.
Also in Germany, Microsoft looks set to win an injunction which could block Google Maps in the country. The case, in Munich I Regional Court, centers on Microsoft’s European patent for ‘a computer system for identifying local resources and method therefore’, which the software giant filed in 1995. According to patents expert Florian Mueller, Judge Dr Matthias Zigann seemed certain, at a hearing on Thursday, to hold Google and its Motorola Mobility subsidiary liable for infringement. A decision is expected in about two months, and if Microsoft does win the injunction, Google will have to stop shipping its Maps Android app in Germany, exclude Maps from its browsers and disable access for computers with German IP addresses.
Microsoft’s complaint originally focused on Motorola Mobility’s use of Google Maps in its Android devices, but it added Google itself as a defendant after Motorola executives denied knowledge of how Google’s Map servers operate. Most other Android device makers have licensed the Microsoft patent.
Over the water, US District Judge Lucy Koh has ruled that an Apple patent infringement case against Samsung ‘ the second major case in her San Jose court ‘ should be allowed to go ahead. Last month she said that the proceedings, which center on Apple’s Siri personal assistant technology, might be put on hold until the outcome of Apple’s appeal against another of her decisions ‘ that there should be no ban on Samsung products found guilty of infringement in the high profile case won by Apple last summer.
She had said the eventual ruling on the first case could resolve both, commenting: “I just don’t know if we really need two cases on this’. But she has now agreed not to suspend the second lawsuit, but insists both antagonists must “significantly” simplify its scope. It is not scheduled until next March.