Google has scored an important victory for its chosen video codec, VP8, which it hopes to make a dominant feature of the evolving HTML5 and webRTC standards. MPEG LA, the patent licensing organization which controls the main alternative, H.264/5, has pledged not to go after VP8.
The codec is one option to drive webRTC, (Real Time Communications). This future standard sets up browser-based communications between devices and allows programmers to build real time voice and video chat applications which execute within the browser interface without plug-ins. However, no codec is mandated in the standard, despite lobbying by the likes of Google (for VP8), Apple (for H.264) and Microsoft (for its own route).
This has raised the specter of a standards and IPR battle in this important part of the future mobile platform. Google backs VP8, the basis of its WebM video format ‘ technology acquired with ON Technology and then open sourced. It says webRTC should use a royalty-free codec like VP8, whereas MPEG LA’s technologies are licensed for money.
Despite that argument, Google itself has signed a licensing deal with MPEG LA, which means the group will abandon its efforts to form a patent pool and pursue users of VP8 and its predecessors. That will reduce the risk for companies to implement VP8 and likely accelerate Google’s work on a successor, VP9. However, the search giant still faces the challenge of the hefty installed base of H.264/5.
MPEG LA CEO Larry Horn said in a statement: ‘We are pleased for the opportunity to facilitate agreements with Google to make VP8 widely available to users’, while Google’s deputy general counsel for patents, Allen Lo, added: ‘This is a significant milestone in Google’s efforts to establish VP8 as a widely deployed web video format. We appreciate MPEG LA’s cooperation in making this happen.’
No financial details were revealed but Google’s new arrangement gives it rights to IPR, from about a dozen companies, which is essential to VP8. It will be able to relicense its technology with its customers safe from any claims from MPEG LA. In 2010, after Google released its codec to open source, MPEG LA said it would form a patent pool and the following year, claimed to have identified 12 firms with IPR that was essential to VP8. Google rejected the assertions but they did create nervousness among potential partners. Microsoft said it would not support WebM or VP8 in its browsers until the patent situation was resolved. Now Google will have far greater strength in its battle to make WebM the default solution in webRTC.
Google’s move is reminiscent of Microsoft’s back in 2005. Then, it emerged that the Windows giant had been giving away its VC1 codec for years, but that technology used essential patents from about a dozen other companies. Apparently to avert potential legal action from those patent holders, Microsoft asked
MPEG LA to set up a patent pool for the licensing of VC1. It ended up getting very few of the royalties for a codec that ostensibly it controlled, and which it was trying to use to dominate the market ‘ though in fact, H.264 won the day that time.
The parallels with the VP8 story are clear. Google wants to be able to give VP8 away legally but 11 companies need to give it their blessing and receive some money. So now VP8 will cease trying to have a patent pool of its own, and instead, this deal should mean that VP8, and one further generation of the technology, remains free to sub-licensees.
The royalty for H.264 is free up to 100,000 units, then costs 20 cents per unit, falling to 10 cents a unit after five million copies, and is capped at $6.5n per year, rising with inflation. It’s very likely that this is the order of magnitude that Google paid for its licence ‘ essentially chicken feed for legitimizing an attempt at codec domination.
Back in April the European Commission began investigating Motorola Mobility over its licensing of standards-essential patents, when it tried to ask for $4bn from Microsoft and Apple, for a group of patents, some of which it said were essential to H.264 streaming . It had never submitted those patents to the MPEG LA patent pool, and so it tried to claim that it could separately license those patents for that type of money. This of course was a mistake, and one that has shown up before in this standard. Qualcomm once tried to hold Broadcom over a barrel on H.264 patents that were not in the patent pool and a US judge upheld the patent, but said that since it had not declared the amount it was going to charge to the standards body, it just couldn’t charge it. Google may have now inherited those Motorola patents, but because they are not yet part of the MPEG LA patent pool it is likely they cannot bring in very much money, even if they were added to the VP8 essential work.
But the truth is that the world is moving on from here, and wishes to engage with HEVC on most portable devices, in order to preserve wireless bandwidth. We wait to see how patent pools work out for HEVC.