LTE-M is an emerging standard from the 3GPP, which aims to address the 4G standard’s considerable shortcomings when it comes to machine-to-machine activities. It hopes to fend off similar efforts by the IEEE to optimize the 802.11 WiFi standards for new data goldmines like smart cities and sensor networks.
WiFi is currently targeting new spectrum in the TV white spaces spectrum, as well as bandwidth in the 868MHz and 900MHz bands of the ISM spectrum, which support the long range and strong propagation needed to blanket a city or workplace cost-effectively with coverage. LTE can already do this, because it already runs in sub-1GHz bands such as 700MHz, 800MHz and even 450MHz, but it lacks other vital qualities necessary for these long range M2M connections.
Designed to cope with the advent of the smartphone, regular LTE is all about high data rates and high bandwidth – qualities which are rarely essential for IoT applications, which instead require very high levels of reliability and security for their constant and critical updates, combined with very low power consumption and, in many cases, a lower cost base than cellular.
Large cellcos are busily carving out a back end role in this market, creating cloud-based device management services and other offerings. These platforms will have to support multiple network standards, but the operators will be happiest when they are delivering their updates to the endpoints, and collecting the data back from the sensors and gadgets, over LTE.
If WiFi dominates the market for connecting the devices, gateways and WPANs (wireless personal area networks) to the cloud, operators’ management services will have no differentiation against those from Hewlett-Packard or IBM. If LTE is the most widely used connection, they will have a significant advantage, promising the optimized service enabled by their intimate understanding of those connections.
LTE-M offers hope for the mobile operators, that they will have their own unique platform which will be a strong alternative to WiFi (and, in relevant applications, specialized networks like Sigfox). LTE-M is a way of maintaining control of an ecosystem that is on the verge of slipping away from them.
LTE-M featured prominently in Huawei’s pre-MWC event this week, with the Chinese vendor placing LTE-M firmly at the center of its ‘4.5G’ platform (see separate item). The message was very clear – the next wave of networks will not just be about smartphones and video, but equally importantly, they will be optimized for the IoT, giving cellcos a strong weapon not a blunt instrument.
Huawei explained: “4.5G supports up to 100,000 per-cell connections via LTE-M, 100 times that of 4G. LTE-M also provides better coverage. Receivers require just one-hundredth of the signal of existing 2G systems, 20dB gain, using low power terminals.”
In reality, LTE-M is a shadowy beast. Some specifications are already emerging from the 3GPP, mainly tweaking what is already there to support better M2M usage. Subsequent releases will include more fundamental new standards specifically created for machine applications. What Huawei is showing off seems likely to be neither, though it demonstrated a smartband which claimed to be running a pre-commercial implementation of LTE-M. In fact, its chip and connectivity came from Neul, the UK start-up Huawei acquired last year, along with its Weightless M2M network platform. It is likely that the ‘pre-standard LTE-M’ touted by Huawei is actually Weightless, whose technology does fulfil some of the coverage and latency criteria outlined above – and which the Chinese firm will be hoping to push into future 3GPP releases.
The demo of the smartband made perfect sense of Huawei’s acquisition of Neul. Neul developed Weightless initially for the TV white spaces spectrum and more recently for the 900MHz/868MHz unlicensed bands. Since other technologies in this area, like Sigfox, are more commercially advanced and are targeting similar low power, long range smart city applications, such as traffic management, there were question marks over why Huawei had chosen Neul.
Now that is clearer –Neul has brought it working silicon which it can embed in real products with a ‘pre-LTE-M’ logo, plus technology which it can hope to include in future standards, gaining a market head start and IPR advantage.
The vendor is promising to announce an LTE-M engagement with a UK operator during MWC and expects the technology to be finalized and commercially deployed next year. It would be unsurprising if that UK operator turned out to be Vodafone, which has also been making LTE-M claims based around projects with Neul. Last week, the operator announced it was working with Huawei, Neul and u-blox to bring the initial 3GPP LTE-M specs (which it calls Cellular IoT) to market for the first time.
It said it would run the Cellular IoT technology as a new network access layer on its existing global M2M network. That layer would support and manage embedded devices such as smart meters or fire extinguishers, which involve small amounts of data but are business-critical. Other operators are expected to follow suit once the ‘Cellular IoT’ specs are published in full.
Vodafone has been very influential in the development of LTE-M from the start. Last spring, it joined with Verizon Wireless and others to publish a white paper discussing three main options for cellular IoT – extending LTE, with the specific requirements of M2M in mind, but using existing bandwidth; doing the same but in narrower bands; starting with a ‘clean slate’ cellular standard. In all cases, the overriding aim was to argue that licensed spectrum would remain an advantage, for quality of service and global coverage (though some firms would argue that this should be specific spectrum, dedicated to IoT and not necessarily controlled by mobile carriers).
Elements which were essential to a cellular IoT network, in whatever form, were listed in the white paper and will largely feed into what becomes LTE-M – including deep coverage in “highly shadowed locations such as basements, meter closets, manholes and even underground”, as well as support for low cost and sometimes disposable devices; ultra-low power consumption; optimization for small payloads to enable remote monitoring without substantial signaling burden; and an “adapted IPR licensing regime based on the FRAND principles and reflecting the reduced functionality that the new standard will provide for the specific M2M market (low cost, high volume)”.
The white paper also gave a high level outline of what the clean slate option might look like, recommending a solution that would operate in a narrow 200KHz bandwidth using half-duplex FDD and single-carrier modulation with frequency and time division multiple access for downlink and uplink. The benefit would be that the design could be fully optimized for cellular IoT with no consideration for legacy functionality, and it could potentially operate in re-farmed GSM spectrum or in the guard bands of an LTE carrier.
Whatever their precise specifications, these new-style networks will enable new business models for operators, said Huawei, unveiling its “business blueprint” for its cellco customers. They will be able to target new types of customers, such as public utilities or local authorities, and to support new services. Huawei talked about a test it has conducted with Korean operator LG U+, which transmitted data and 4K video from embedded devices to drones over a ‘4.5G’ connection.
This shows why the smartband demonstration was symbolic – because it showed an industry moving on from being smartphone-centric to having to focus on a host of new and varied devices, and the networks need to be ready. LTE represents the new network that was required to support the iPhone when it first appeared. Release 13, and its pre-standard ‘4.5G’ implementations, will be, as Huawei’s president of products and solutions, Ryan Ding, put it, a network that is focused not just on people and their smartphones, but on “people and things”.
Huawei’s VP of marketing Bob Cai said that 4.5G “supports new business opportunities and an improved user experience through enhancement of the mobile network’s capacity and capability. This in turn will transition our industry into an all online world with ultra-high speed massive connections and low latency, allowing all of us to be fully prepared for the large scale arrival of applications for cellular internet of things” (with the emphasis heavily on ‘cellular’. Huawei and the other cellular giants may talk WiFi, but they know it is LTE that allows them to keep carriers and growth markets within their closely controlled world.