Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 July 2007

Intel makes its bid to drive mobile Linux standards

Although Intel’s halting mobile Linux moves, notably its support for the OS in its latest UltraMobile PC architecture, have been widely touted, the chip giant has thrown very little of its considerable weight behind the open source system to date. Conflicts of interest with its witch’s familiar Microsoft and technical hitches have been blamed, but finally Intel seems to be getting serious, creating a mobile Linux initiative called Moblin. But while any activity in this area may please those who want the mobile internet future to be open source, in reality Moblin represents a gathering political battle for influence over Linux, which will lead to fragmentation and disputes rather than accelerating uptake in the short term.

It is clear that Intel wants more than just to narrow the gap with rivals in the mobile field that have taken a stronger lead in Linux ‘ notably Nokia, whose Internet Tablet roadmap, for all its technical similarity to UMPC, represents a fundamental challenge to Intel’s vision of creating the future mobile device in its own PC-derived image. To do that, all the chip company needed to do was adopt a well established mobile Linux distribution, such as MontaVista’s Mobilinux, across a range of platforms, and step up the developer and customer support. Instead it is clearly aiming to propel itself into pole position as the driver of the as-yet immature mobile Linux standards, and so is adding yet another ‘initiative’ to a market that is already overfull with them ‘ from the Nokia’s backed Maemo (see Wireless Watch May 29 2006) to the Gnome Mobile & Embedded Initiative (GMAE), in which Motorola is likely to be a key mover. Others include OpenMoko, which recently released a handset, the neo1973, containing only open source software, and Trolltech’s Qtopia, which has a phone edition.

Intel has created a web site, Moblin.org, which lists initial projects to be undertaken, including key components such as the kernel, a user interface, a browser, a multimedia framework and embedded image creation tools, along with developer resources. It says the work will link to that of various community projects, including Ubuntu’s Mobile and Embedded Edition and Red Flag’s Midinux (which Intel used, with the Mozilla browser, in its most recent UMPC reference platform).

However, this excludes the most widely used mobile Linux distribution, MontaVista, with its inevitable supporting ‘initiative’, Mobilinux, already pointing to a worsening, rather than improvement, of the chief problem with mobile Linux, its fragmentation. MontaVista pointed out, in an interview with internetnews.com, that it is a commercial company delivering production quality distributions, while efforts such as Moblin will ‘produce prototype software of varying utility and quality on unpredictable schedules’ from which Linux and device players can, if they choose, ‘invest in the effort to make usable real products out of the technology’.

MontaVista said it had met with Intel several times to discuss Moblin and that it would port Mobilinux to Intel UMPC devices as customer demand dictated. This was hardly a huge endorsement and suggests that keeping its distance is largely the Linux company’s decision rather than Intel’s. Indeed, it is another indicator of the coming battle between the Intel PC/internet approach to mobile devices, and the traditional cellular industry view, a clash in which Linux variants are just one element. MontaVista has taken the most specifically cellular approach of any of the Linux players, and numbers Motorola, NEC and Panasonic as its major handset customers, while its primary chip partner is Texas Instruments (though it does also work on some Intel platforms). With this pedigree and little black book, the company has clearly thrown in its lot with those who seek to adapt the existing cellular platforms and models for the mobile internet, rather than those who aim to take that market by storm using the techniques and architectures of the PC industry.

Intel, meanwhile, will aim to increase its influence by making Moblin and its participants as widely applicable as possible. Initially, all the Moblin projects are focused on the Intel architecture but in future will be “open to contributions for support of other architectures’, says the company. The first Intel processors to be targeted are the 600MHz A100 and 800MHz A110, which work with the 945GU Express chipset and ICH7 I/O controller hub to form UMPC 2007.

Nobody should underestimate Intel’s potential influence, even outside its true comfort zone. A few years ago it made its initial attempt to drive Linux in the telecoms world with its Carrier Grade Linux initiative, which subsequently gained widespread vendor support (including from MontaVista) and was one element in the far swifter adoption of Linux for telecoms servers than enterprise systems.

The key for Intel to take a similar leading role in the far more complex process of creating mobile Linux standards will be to unite as many of possible of the current initiatives, a feat that would require delicate negotiations with other giants, such as Nokia and Motorola, that already hope to grasp the steering wheel through support for their own pet Linux initiatives. Particularly thorny will be the user interface and browser elements, where all the participants ‘ including Qualcomm ‘ hope to add their value and drive future standards. While this particular battle could eventually lead to hyper-innovation and strong products for consumers and operators, in the short term, it is likely to hold fragment the developer communities and cause damaging uncertainty, something Microsoft will certainly turn to its advantage in the emerging UMPC sector.

Components of Moblin:

So far, the main elements of Moblin are:

Linux kernel:
User interface framework: a GTK-based effort, using the Hildon application framework (similar to Nokia’s Internet Tablets).
Browser: based on Mozilla, but with a finger-driven UI and Hildon integration.
Multimedia framework: a ‘Moblin Media Artist’ player offering a choice of gstreamer or Real’s open source Helix streaming frameworks.
Embedded image creation tools: the Moblin image creator will be for quick creation of platform-specific build environments and target file systems, with “customized contents chosen from a list of available feature sets’, Intel says. It will produce binary images that can run on actual devices, or in an emulated environment.
Messaging: an image capture, management, and sharing application for still and video images, based on Telepathy but with added support for popular messaging protocols.
Power management policy project: aims to provide a “comprehensive, robust, and extensible” framework for mobile device power management.
Network profile manager: a ‘unified, dynamic configuration system’ supporting the various protocols, such as Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, used to connect mobile devices.