Verizon Wireless has dealt a huge blow to Qualcomm by signing a licensing deal directly with Broadcom for the patents at dispute between the two chipmakers. Previously Verizon Wireless, one of Qualcomm’s largest and usually most supportive customers, had backed its chip partner’s efforts to have pro-Broadcom judgements overturned. But it now apparently sees that strategy as too uncertain and has backed away from the risk of a ban on imports of new handsets based on the technologies at issue, at the price of a royalties deal that will not cheer the campaign to reduce the handset IPR burden. If Qualcomm’s various appeals fail, a ban on imports of new handsets containing the disputed technologies would be the consequence, and could put Verizon at huge disadvantage, especially in the light of the success of its arch-rival AT&T’s iPhone launch. But Verizon may not just be playing safe ‘ a parallel development alliance with Broadcom points to a more strategic move to distance itself a little from Qualcomm and increase its own power.
Verizon Wireless has agreed to pay Broadcom as much as $6 a handset, up to a maximum of $40m per quarter and $200m in lifetime total, in order to keep its supply of new cellphone models from suppliers like Samsung uninterrupted. The move suggests it lacks confidence that Qualcomm will win its appeals ‘ which Verizon had originally enthusiastically supported, and which should be decided at the end of August. It may also be a tactic to score a few power points over the chipmaker with which it remains so close ‘ as Qualcomm spreads its own wings beyond its CDMA platform into UMTS, open IP and other broader technologies, Verizon Wireless could stand to lose some of its hefty influence over the chip designer.
However, handset makers will be less than pleased with the outcome. Broadcom’s case with the US International Trade Commission had echoed many of the complaints about Qualcomm business practises that Nokia and its supporters are pushing in front of the European Commission. But by dealing directly with Verizon, Broadcom shows that its own actions were about no more than royalties, since it has effectively endorsed the high fee levels and ‘double dipping’ (taking payments from both phonemakers and operators for the same patent) of which Qualcomm stands accused by the Nokia faction. If Nokia had hoped that a Broadcom victory would set valuable precedents for Europe, and its campaign to fix a ceiling on total handset IPR burden, it will be disappointed. ‘We are assessing this outcome, but certainly don’t see it as all positive,’ said a typically circumspect insider at the Finnish company.
Officially, Qualcomm was welcoming its customer’s decision, saying in a statement that this was a ‘positive development’ that would ‘reduce the risk of disruption’. It added: “The agreement, which purports to grant licenses to Verizon Wireless under the six patents asserted by Broadcom against Qualcomm in the ITC action as well as in federal district court cases in Santa Ana, California, removed uncertainty for Verizon Wireless and its customers by ensuring that Verizon Wireless will be able to continue to sell wireless broadband products powered by Qualcomm’s chipsets and software.”
Some analysts, too, chose to look on the bright side, seeing the deal as an insurance policy for Qualcomm, guaranteeing it sales to its largest customer even if its appeals fail (somewhat cold comfort, one might think). Mike Burton of ThinkEquity Partners said in a research note that the development was positive because it reduced Qualcomm’s risk, and even speculated that Qualcomm might ultimately pay part or all of Verizon Wireless’ bill to Broadcom, something on which the carrier would not comment.
But despite all this forced optimism, Qualcomm’s shares fell sharply, dropping by $1.56 to $43.54 on news of the Verizon deal. And with good reason. The Verizon move not only weakens Qualcomm’s case in the Broadcom dispute, but also gives ammunition to its other legal enemies, notably Nokia, with which it remains engaged in multiple lawsuits having failed to agree terms on a renewed patent licensing agreement.
In the short term, its lobbying of the president and other bodies to reverse the ITC injunction will lack the support of Verizon, one of the most skilled lobbyists in Washington, and arguments that the ban would harm large numbers of subscribers as well as the carriers will be weakened by the fact that the second largest cellco is no longer affected (and the largest, AT&T, was always less exposed because it has a wider choice of handsets for its GSM/UMTS network). Also, Verizon’s decision may well undermine other carriers’ confidence that Qualcomm will prevail, and they may also be prepared effectively to double up on royalty payments to protect their handset supply.
Despite all this, Qualcomm said it would continue to fight the ITC ruling, including calling for a presidential veto, but it will now rely primarily on the backing of the other major CDMA operator, Sprint Nextel, which has taken a different tack, and is said to be testing a workaround to the Broadcom patents codeveloped with Qualcomm.
‘Although the announced deal would appear to reduce the risk of disruption of Verizon Wireless’ network, it does not resolve the problems arising from the ITC’s order for the many other wireless carriers affected by the ITC’s order, their tens of millions of subscribers, their suppliers, and the public safety and other vital organizations that depend upon their networks and services,’ Qualcomm said in its statement.
While a Broadcom victory would widely be welcomed by the anti-Qualcomm faction as a step towards fairer and lower handset royalties, if the Verizon deal provides any kind of precedent, it will be no such thing. The level of royalties to which Verizon Wireless has agreed for just six patents concerned with power management will do no favors to the companies campaigning to reduce the IPR burden in handsets ‘ a campaign that has largely been targeted at Qualcomm’s policies ‘ and nor will its acceptance of effective ‘double dipping’, one of the most common accusations levelled at the CDMA giant. Broadcom may have been the ‘fair royalty’ effort’s most aggressive stalking horse in the US, but in the hard world of carrier negotiations, it has proven as willing as any to put a licensee under intense pressure and then collect the resulting bounty ‘ perhaps showing Nokia and others the danger of relying on another chip company, rather than on chip buyers, to represent them in the battle with Qualcomm.
There was another sign that Verizon Wireless’ decision may be more than merely a panic reaction to the threat of handset supply cuts, but could also be an opportunistic move in a strategy of distancing itself somewhat from Qualcomm. Separately from the royalties agreement, it signed a ‘strategic alliance’ with Broadcom that will focus on new mobile device chipsets for various technologies, including Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, optical networks, Multimedia over Coaxial Cable (MoCA), GPS, ‘and DSL and fiber network components including set-top boxes’.
This hints at another threat to Qualcomm, one that goes to the heart of its hostility to Broadcom. While the former has no competition in CDMA, and in our view faces little threat from Broadcom, at least in the short term, in UMTS/HSPA, it know it has to broaden its horizons to embrace all the wireless and converged platforms. Although Qualcomm has so far proved successful at integrating many wireless elements into its chipsets, having got over its initial antipathy to Wi-Fi and dual-mode, this is also the area where Broadcom excels. If Verizon aims to reduce its dependence on Qualcomm, the logical place to do this will be in fixed/mobile convergence and in technologies like Wi-Fi, and here Broadcom is well placed. It seems to have won the giant cellco’s favor with the type of co-development partnership that Qualcomm enjoys, and which serves the operator’s aim of weighting the balance of power against the handset manufacturers. Verizon Wireless is showing no indications of wanting to move away from CDMA EV-DO any time soon, and so will remain Qualcomm’s most important carrier ally, but the CDMA chip leader will have to fight far harder to retain its pole position in other markets, especially where these include fixed convergence.