Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2006

IPWireless challenges WiMAX with fast track route to 3.9G

Darwin’s evolution theories may be under attack, but one company certainly believes in perfect adaptability ‘ broadband wireless company IPWireless has shifted its focus in order to survive several times, and its latest and most ambitious bid is to offer a fast track route for carriers looking to move to the emerging LTE standard for next generation cellular networks.

IPWireless – which specializes in TD-CDMA systems that use the underused time division duplex (TDD) unpaired strand of the W-CDMA 3G spectrum ‘ is now promising an early implementation of LTE in these TDD bands, up to two years ahead of likely systems for the mainstream FDD (frequency division duplex) spectrum. This could give operators an accelerated path to LTE, using their TDD spectrum in the first year or two and then moving to a full deployment later. It also gives it a potential niche of its own before LTE, which will erase the distinction between FDD and TDD kit, forces it to work out a whole new business model.

LTE ‘ also known as 3.9G, Super 3G or 3GPP Release 7 ‘ is heavily backed by Japanese carrier NTT DoCoMo. Officially called UTRAN LTE (Universal Terrestrial Radio Access Network Long Term Evolution), it promises to deliver 100Mbps downlink speeds and 50Mbps uplink ‘ a step on the way to the 1Gbps while stationary recommended for 4G by the International Telecommunications Union ‘ and is currently being fine tuned within the 3GPP process. It is expected to be ratified in mid-2007, with deployments from 2009, around the same time that mobile WiMAX is likely to be achieving mass uptake, but many of its features are already agreed. Key enhancements include support for MIMO smart antennas and for multiuser detection (MUD), which cancels interference within a cell using advanced signal processing. IPWireless will implement these features in its Release 7 technology at the start of next year, along with its own MUD technology, GMUD, which also addresses intercell interference. These improvements will double the data rate in real use to 29Mbps in each sector on a pair of 5MHz channels and treble the edge cell rate, claims the company, and be available to carriers 1-2 years before more mainstream LTE systems. The company sees this as a key weapon to beat off 802.16e, which will use similar techniques to shift towards 4G.

The first operator to trial the new IPWireless platform will be Sprint Nextel in the US, which is already testing the company’s mobile television platform, TDtv, in its 2.5GHz spectrum. The trial will start in March, as part of the existing TD-CDMA trial in the Washington, DC area that was announced in June 2005, which is focusing on broadband access for laptops, PDAs, and handheld devices as well as a video streaming, online gaming, document collaboration and videoconferencing.

Other users or triallists of IPWireless’ current TD-CDMA technology, such as Orange and T-Mobile, are mainly installing it in their 1.9GHz 3G bands ‘ where European carriers, in particular, received TDD spectrum with their core licenses. Sprint, by contrast, is assessing either TD-CDMA or WiMAX as a separate parallel system to its CDMA-based 3G network, but IPWireless’ chief technology officer and co-founder, Roger Quayle, believes 2.5GHz will become the most important band in general for IPWireless, because it will form the 3G expansion band in Europe. Although WiMAX backers are hoping this band will be made technology neutral, IPWireless argues that with its platform, carriers can offer true broadband wireless but with a smooth integration with their cellular systems and a migration to fully fledged LTE. ‘Having a common platform with Europe and Asia in the 2.5GHz band would bring a number of benefits,’ said Barry West, chief technology officer at Sprint Nextel.

Carriers will be able to evolve from IPWireless Release 7 to the full LTE standard ‘ though like any ‘pre-standard’ option, there are sure to be risks and costs associated with this upgrade. A key victory for this future migration path came recently when IPWireless succeeded in getting the TD-CDMA frame structure adopted for LTE by the 3GPP standards body. LTE will also support self-contained transmissions, allowing it to mix modulation schemes, with the network automatically detecting which standard the user device supports.

This makes TD-CDMA less niche, and should encourage larger operator investment than has been seen to date, but it also makes it even more important to IPWireless to attract major OEMs in order to survive as an independent player. These will be essential to attract the major operators and achieve economies of scale, and Quayle claims there are four majors lined up to announce deals for TD-CDMA, joining its existing licensing partners, UTStarcom and Alcatel.

In the end, the major vendors are likely to snap up the small, clever players, as Qualcomm’s acquisition of Flarion has shown. All the emerging ‘almost-4G’ platforms, using MIMO, MUD, OFDM and so on, will have their place, but one trend is clear whichever individual suppliers succeed or fail ‘ the progress towards the next generation network has been significantly accelerated by the challenge of WiMAX to the 3G roadmap and by the rising appetite of consumers for broadband mobile data.

BOX – TDtv

IPWireless’ other major current thrust is mobile television, and Orange has now joined Sprint Nextel in trialling the TDtv platform, which uses the 3GPP Multimedia Broadcast and Multicast Services (MBMS) standard. Orange will launch its technical trial in the UK in its unpaired 3G spectrum, starting mid-2006.