Nortel has been one of the most enthusiastic companies in talking up WiMAX as a future convergence platform, but at 3GSM it was announcing enhancements to its W-CDMA platform that could enhance that network’s ability to match 802.16e in fixed/mobile convergence and next generation rate/range. This shows that the largest telecoms vendors are focusing for growth, not on backing just one network, but on applying key enhancements ‘ such as OFDM and smart antennas ‘ to multiple systems, so that they can address broad markets and promise carriers the same benefits on different platforms. This should enable operators to select a network based less on performance capabilities, and more on commercial considerations such as type of spectrum held or legacy investment.
The main areas where Nortel was showing off at 3GSM were early moves towards the ‘3.9G’ extension to W-CDMA, called LTE; and use of the 900MHz band in Europe for stretching 3G’s capabilities for rural access.
With cellcos under pressure to improve rural 3G coverage, there is increasing interest in the lower reaches of the spectrum, which support large wireless cells and so are more cost effective for providing access to sparsely populated regions. Some regulators, notably in Finland, are allowing non-UMTS technologies to be used for rural access in the 450MHz band, which is being vacated by analog telephony, and Ericsson recently promised a 450MHz implementation of GSM to rival existing solutions for this band ‘ CDMA450, TD-CDMA and Flarion Flash-OFDM. In the US there are high hopes for the 700MHz spectrum, due to be vacated by analog television broadcasters, as a rural option, and WiMAX in particular is keen to take its natural spectral efficiency into this band. In Europe, a more likely choice will be 900MHz (which in the US is license-exempt). Nortel is one company lobbying the 3GPP standards body and various European regulators to allow UMTS in this band in order to stimulate rural build-out, and WiMAX could also create a profile here if regulators are friendly ‘ several WiMAX vendors have proprietary broadband wireless offerings for unlicensed 900MHz, which could be adapted for the standard and for the European licensed spectrum.
In January, Nortel demonstrated W-CDMA and HSDPA running in 900MHz with Orange in France, and chip technology from Qualcomm. Qualcomm has always seen the pressures of rural coverage as a back door into new markets, and has gone as far as to buy up 450MHz spectrum in some territories in order to promote CDMA. Now it is also focusing hard on low spectrum implementations of W-CDMA as a potential growth market for its chipsets.
Vodafone is another major backer of 900MHz W-CDMA, claiming that this achieves a 60% reduction in cell sites required to serve rural areas compared to 2.1GHz, and delivers improved quality of service in urban areas by enhancing in-building penetration by 25% – another area where 802.16e currently has significant advantages over W-CDMA and HSDPA.
Looking towards the next generation of cellular networks, Nortel has gained 3GPP approval for its HSOPA (High Speed OFDM Packet Access) technology, which combines OFDM and MIMO smart antennas, for inclusion in the ‘3.9G’ standard, also called LTE (Long Term Evolution). The company has been a pioneer in this area, bringing to HSOPA the same technologies it has also applied to its emerging WiMAX architecture. This is in line with its policy of taking a cost efficient approach to R&D that enables reusing generic work in fundamental areas for several different technologies.
The HSOPA project draws on many of the areas into which Nortel has ploughed R&D resources in recent years, particularly smart antenna arrays, OFDM and mesh networking. All these developments have been incorporated into Wi-Fi mesh and WiMAX developments, but incorporating them into HSOPA will enable Nortel to play for far higher stakes ‘ the chance to be the dominant player in a 3GPP industry standard, a role it has in the past ceded, in the wireless world, to Ericsson and Qualcomm. Such a role would bring it significant new intellectual property revenues and a high measure of influence over future networks, as well as making it easier for it to integrate its WiMAX and 3G platforms and support multi-network carriers.
Nortel claims HSOPA/LTE has the potential to increase tenfold the number of users that can be served by an operator’s network and to reduce the cost per megabyte to the operator to a potential one-twentieth of current W-CDMA costs. The vendor plans to deliver a laboratory prototype this year that provides 25Mbps uplink in the 5MHz spectrum and at least 37Mbps downlink. It anticipates beginning customer HSOPA/LTE trials in 2007, promising smooth evolution from GSM and W-CDMA, as well as, by 2008, a converged core that will terminate traffic from any fixed or wireless access technology ‘ including WiMAX.
The introduction of OFDM and MIMO into the 3GPP standards for LTE (see separate item on IPWireless for details) was agreed in December 2005.